Skip navigation
Some more observations today from testing USA -5 vs BBCOR -3
0:00 / 1:02

Some more observations today from testing USA -5 vs BBCOR -3

TheBatDoctor

@TheDataCage5.3K followers

Visit on X
109 likesDownloadOriginal post

33,726 views

Some more observations today from testing USA -5 vs BBCOR -3

26 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Paul Belo's profile picture

    @PaulBelo2

    critical question: What is the acclimation period of the hitter. A 33”/-6 is 20% of the length in ratio, less oz. of metal equate to thinner walls, after the bat & the hitter become acclimated, the ball will trampoline at a higher velocity. An ^ of 1mph of bat speed = 1.2 of EV.

    2 likes

  • TheBatDoctor's profile picture

    @TheDataCage

    I want to do my best to not sound insulting, but your assumptions are what’s confusing you. The bat will still need to pass BBCOR standards…so no “trampoline” that you’re assuming here.

    3 likes

  • Paul Belo's profile picture

    @PaulBelo2

    Breaking in over time. Whats insulting is the belief that this -6 change is not significant. Ask yourself if no change in the performance or performer exists than why the need for change? Why would I market/purchase a bat that, as you attest, negatively impacts my performance?

  • Paul Belo's profile picture

    @PaulBelo2

    Well educated, but what you have failed to answer is why the change & what is the acclimation period you have given your hitters before you can support your data? Secondly, fibers overtime loosen (hoop modes) tensile strength is compromised, less energy will be lost in the ball

  • TheBatDoctor's profile picture

    @TheDataCage

    Paul, are you actually trying to explain to a bat developer how bats work? Sit back and think about that for a moment. Also, USA is very clear on why this is being tried. Have you not seen the explanation?

    1 like

  • Paul Belo's profile picture

    @PaulBelo2

    No more than you are trying to get me to agree that this is not a significant change! I have asked two specific questions? Why haven’t you answered them. Why would you the developer put something on the market that reduces a players ability to perform? According to your data!

  • Reggie's profile picture

    @reginitis257

    @TheDataCage I don’t understand your disconnect regarding break in. Metal bats do not break in and comp bats are subject accelerated break in tests and should they exceed the standard they fail or are supposed to break before exceeding the standard. This isn’t usssa of 15 years ago

    1 like

  • TheBatDoctor's profile picture

    @TheDataCage

    @PaulBelo2 Thank you Reggie. Spot on.

  • TheBatDoctor's profile picture

    @TheDataCage

    👍🏼

    1 like

  • Bob Jones's profile picture

    @BobCjones2nd

    Regardless of what happens. The playing field is still level. All teams can swing what they're comfortable with.

    1 like

  • Andrew Rappl's profile picture

    @RapplAndre73380

    What’s funny is I changed my son over to a minus 5 at age 11. He was barely 5 foot tall 80 lbs. I did so because the ball went nowhere on minus 10s. He started hitting the ball to or around the fence immediately with a minus 5 if he could catch up to it.

    1 like

  • Kayden Lucas's profile picture

    @KaydenLucas0

    Love it ..🤙

  • Andrew Tavani's profile picture

    @andrewtavani

    Basic science. If I were a HS kid playing today, I’d be asking for a 33/33. More mass, please

  • Andrew Rappl's profile picture

    @RapplAndre73380

    This rule will help kids with slow hands play longer as it will allow them to make contact and not get their doors blown off.. with that said it’s just delaying the inevitable of them getting there doors blown off.

  • GlaucomaDoc's profile picture

    @Doc_Glaucoma

    Physics is ALWAYS undefeated for sure 🎯

  • Gerard T.'s profile picture

    @GerardM62228871

    Exactly. USA bats are junk

  • Chris fuller's profile picture

    @cfuller2218

    You work for a bat company Stop gas lighting

  • Storm0light's profile picture

    @storm0light

    Can you give us a longer video

  • Al Smizzle's profile picture

    @AlZeidenfeld

    Can you post the data please? I’m very interested in seeing the results

  • TheBatDoctor's profile picture

    @TheDataCage

    3 sessions with same player. His gamer is a 33/30 In one of the sessions he swung a 33/28 Which of these 3 is the -5?