Video yükleniyor...

Video Yüklenemedi

Ana Sayfaya Dön

'Southern states will get fewer seats after census': Ranganathan's blunt delimitation explainer Anand Ranganathan delivers the clearest mathematical explainer of the delimitation arguing that the southern states are not being punished but are actually gaining seats under the current 50% pro-rata increase. He points out that in the last...

timesofindia's profile picture

The Times Of India

13,937,383 subscribers

119,291 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce •via X (Twitter)

Haberler & PolitikaEğitim
LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Yorum

Yorum bulunmuyor

Orijinal gönderinin yorumları burada görünecek

Benzer Videolar

NDTV is quoting one line out of an entire statement. Here’s what Thalaivar K.Annamalai said. He said that if the delimitation exercise were based on the Census numbers, North Indian states might deserve a large number of MPs, and hence a grand bargain was brought in to ensure that southern states are not affected and that the current proportional representation in parliament is maintained even after the delimitation exercise.
3:06

NDTV is quoting one line out of an entire statement. Here’s what Thalaivar K.Annamalai said. He said that if the delimitation exercise were based on the Census numbers, North Indian states might deserve a large number of MPs, and hence a grand bargain was brought in to ensure that southern states are not affected and that the current proportional representation in parliament is maintained even after the delimitation exercise.

Krishna Kumar Murugan

37,691 görüntüleme • 2 ay önce

Every state would have received an equal share in the increase of Lok Sabha seats through delimitation, but now many states will suffer. Tamil Nadu and West Bengal are among them. The ruling parties of these states have voted for a move that could reduce their Lok Sabha seats.
0:42

Every state would have received an equal share in the increase of Lok Sabha seats through delimitation, but now many states will suffer. Tamil Nadu and West Bengal are among them. The ruling parties of these states have voted for a move that could reduce their Lok Sabha seats.

Facts

14,640 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

'Delhi gets less than southern states, why are they shouting?': Anand Ranganathan's data takedown Anand Ranganathan silences the southern states' family planning argument with a devastating data comparison between Tamil Nadu and Delhi. ‘Tamil Nadu's fertility rate is 1.3, Delhi's is lower at 1.2. Tamil Nadu gets back 30 paisa for every 100 it gives India. Delhi gets back just 0.5 paisa and isn't shouting.’ He asks the harder question: ‘will Stalin tomorrow demand poorer Tamil districts to break away? All of us have to grow together. This is hypocrisy.' Aditi Prasad #Delhi #Delimitation #Census
1:41

'Delhi gets less than southern states, why are they shouting?': Anand Ranganathan's data takedown Anand Ranganathan silences the southern states' family planning argument with a devastating data comparison between Tamil Nadu and Delhi. ‘Tamil Nadu's fertility rate is 1.3, Delhi's is lower at 1.2. Tamil Nadu gets back 30 paisa for every 100 it gives India. Delhi gets back just 0.5 paisa and isn't shouting.’ He asks the harder question: ‘will Stalin tomorrow demand poorer Tamil districts to break away? All of us have to grow together. This is hypocrisy.' Aditi Prasad #Delhi #Delimitation #Census

The Times Of India

26,380 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

The Women's Reservation Bill is actually a Purush Bachao Yojna through which Parliament will be converted into a Family Club! If the government is serious about Women Reservation, give the Women 33% Reservation from the exsisting 543 MPs, why Delimitation! Even the 50% increase in seats for all states is a serious disadvantage to Southern States. Let me explain : Parliament runs on absolute numbers not percentage, so a 50% increase in seats for UP is 80+40 = 120 A 50% increase for Tamil Nadu is 39+20= 59! Today the difference in MPs between UP & TN is 80-39= 41, after Delimitation it will become 120-59= 61!
2:10

The Women's Reservation Bill is actually a Purush Bachao Yojna through which Parliament will be converted into a Family Club! If the government is serious about Women Reservation, give the Women 33% Reservation from the exsisting 543 MPs, why Delimitation! Even the 50% increase in seats for all states is a serious disadvantage to Southern States. Let me explain : Parliament runs on absolute numbers not percentage, so a 50% increase in seats for UP is 80+40 = 120 A 50% increase for Tamil Nadu is 39+20= 59! Today the difference in MPs between UP & TN is 80-39= 41, after Delimitation it will become 120-59= 61!

Tehseen Poonawalla Official 🇮🇳

22,535 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

By opposing this bill, what has Congress actually achieved? * They have delayed the implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill, betraying women. * By opposing the 50% proportional seat increase, they have enabled the next delimitation to be done on the 2027 Census, which will redistribute the existing 543 seats and will gravely compromise the less populous southern states. Congress and DMK will have a lot to pay for. Shame on them!
0:51

By opposing this bill, what has Congress actually achieved? * They have delayed the implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill, betraying women. * By opposing the 50% proportional seat increase, they have enabled the next delimitation to be done on the 2027 Census, which will redistribute the existing 543 seats and will gravely compromise the less populous southern states. Congress and DMK will have a lot to pay for. Shame on them!

Tejasvi Surya

26,257 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

States that contribute significantly to nation building must be rewarded, not penalised. During the delimitation, fiscal contribution should also be taken into consideration not population alone. BRS Working President KTR has long been demanding that delimitation should be carried out based on states’ GDP contribution to the nation. Alternatively, if seats are increased, they should be expanded proportionately, while ensuring that the current share of seats for each state remains unchanged.
2:19

States that contribute significantly to nation building must be rewarded, not penalised. During the delimitation, fiscal contribution should also be taken into consideration not population alone. BRS Working President KTR has long been demanding that delimitation should be carried out based on states’ GDP contribution to the nation. Alternatively, if seats are increased, they should be expanded proportionately, while ensuring that the current share of seats for each state remains unchanged.

BRS Party

19,801 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

Delimitation Row: Andhra Minister Nara Lokesh Hits Back at Shashi Tharoor - Nara Lokesh cites Article 81 to counter Tharoor Lokesh Nara tweets, "...Article 81 envisages that seats in the Lok Sabha be allocated on the basis of population. The constitutional freeze linked to the 1971 Census was always temporary and was due to expire in 2026. In the absence of any intervention, a fresh delimitation based on 2026 Census will see several southern states facing a sizable reduction in their share..." Sowmith Yakkati shares more details with Amita Wadhwa🇮🇳.
4:31

Delimitation Row: Andhra Minister Nara Lokesh Hits Back at Shashi Tharoor - Nara Lokesh cites Article 81 to counter Tharoor Lokesh Nara tweets, "...Article 81 envisages that seats in the Lok Sabha be allocated on the basis of population. The constitutional freeze linked to the 1971 Census was always temporary and was due to expire in 2026. In the absence of any intervention, a fresh delimitation based on 2026 Census will see several southern states facing a sizable reduction in their share..." Sowmith Yakkati shares more details with Amita Wadhwa🇮🇳.

TIMES NOW

14,657 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce

#WATCH | On delimitation issue, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi says, "We want to ask the Home Minister, what is the meaning of pro-rata?... Will delimitation be based on population or not? If Southern states are penalised based on the population they have reduced, their political impact will be reduced in the Centre..."
1:42

#WATCH | On delimitation issue, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi says, "We want to ask the Home Minister, what is the meaning of pro-rata?... Will delimitation be based on population or not? If Southern states are penalised based on the population they have reduced, their political impact will be reduced in the Centre..."

ANI

14,165 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

Rep Andy Biggs says California has 7 extra seats in Congress they shouldn’t have because they are counting illegals in the Census To put that into perspective California’s illegals have more representation than 36 states (36 states have 7 or fewer seats in the US House of Representatives) We must exclude illegals from being counted in the Census
0:48

Rep Andy Biggs says California has 7 extra seats in Congress they shouldn’t have because they are counting illegals in the Census To put that into perspective California’s illegals have more representation than 36 states (36 states have 7 or fewer seats in the US House of Representatives) We must exclude illegals from being counted in the Census

Wall Street Apes

107,908 görüntüleme • 7 ay önce

Women's Quota Bill A 'Trick' To Increase Lok Sabha Seats? | Delimitation | Slam Dunk With Tehseen Is the Women’s Reservation push also a numbers game? With the Modi government introducing the Bill in a special Parliament session, a larger question emerges: delimitation. The proposal could expand Lok Sabha seats to enable 33% reservation for women. The Opposition supports reservation in principle, but wants closer scrutiny of the process. Will an increase in seats change the balance of power? The Centre says all states will see around a 50% rise in representation, easing southern concerns. However, worries persist that northern states may gain more seats, potentially shifting political advantage. In Slam Dunk With Tehseen, Tehseen Poonawalla (Tehseen Poonawalla Official 🇮🇳) raises key questions and highlights the risk of reform turning into political strategy. #womenreservationbill #delimitation #parliament #bjp #congress #slamdunk #tehseenpoonawalla
2:58

Women's Quota Bill A 'Trick' To Increase Lok Sabha Seats? | Delimitation | Slam Dunk With Tehseen Is the Women’s Reservation push also a numbers game? With the Modi government introducing the Bill in a special Parliament session, a larger question emerges: delimitation. The proposal could expand Lok Sabha seats to enable 33% reservation for women. The Opposition supports reservation in principle, but wants closer scrutiny of the process. Will an increase in seats change the balance of power? The Centre says all states will see around a 50% rise in representation, easing southern concerns. However, worries persist that northern states may gain more seats, potentially shifting political advantage. In Slam Dunk With Tehseen, Tehseen Poonawalla (Tehseen Poonawalla Official 🇮🇳) raises key questions and highlights the risk of reform turning into political strategy. #womenreservationbill #delimitation #parliament #bjp #congress #slamdunk #tehseenpoonawalla

The Times Of India

13,438 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce

Rep Andy Biggs says California has 7 extra seats in Congress they shouldn’t have because they are counting illegals in the Census To put that into perspective California’s illegals have more representation than 36 states (36 states have 7 or fewer seats in the US House of Representatives) We must exclude illegals from being counted in the Census
0:48

Rep Andy Biggs says California has 7 extra seats in Congress they shouldn’t have because they are counting illegals in the Census To put that into perspective California’s illegals have more representation than 36 states (36 states have 7 or fewer seats in the US House of Representatives) We must exclude illegals from being counted in the Census

Wall Street Apes

45,787 görüntüleme • 5 ay önce

Modi can follow Vajpayee method and not increase Lok Sabha seats for 25years - CM Revanth Reddy at Fair Delimitation meeting Do delimitation taking state as unit and conduct it within the state, change boundaries based on latest census. Increase SC ST and 33% women seats Today south has 130seats of 540seats which is 24%. I demand to increase it by 33% if they want to do delimitation at any cost. If it is done on population basis, South India will lose voice and make us secondary citizens. Even prorata basis will not help A resolution will be passed in Telangana assembly against delimitation. A meeting of South Indian states will be conducted along with a public meeting
6:58

Modi can follow Vajpayee method and not increase Lok Sabha seats for 25years - CM Revanth Reddy at Fair Delimitation meeting Do delimitation taking state as unit and conduct it within the state, change boundaries based on latest census. Increase SC ST and 33% women seats Today south has 130seats of 540seats which is 24%. I demand to increase it by 33% if they want to do delimitation at any cost. If it is done on population basis, South India will lose voice and make us secondary citizens. Even prorata basis will not help A resolution will be passed in Telangana assembly against delimitation. A meeting of South Indian states will be conducted along with a public meeting

Naveena

230,276 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

Increase the proportion of Lok Sabha seats on the basis of GDP contribution of states or don’t change it at all - BRS working president KTR Southern states contribute 36% to the national GDP yet are being sidelined In Telangana and Andhra, delimitation of assembly seats had to happen as per AP Reorganisation act, but the union govt didn’t do it bcos BJP has nothing to gain, but they did in J&K. So we don’t trust them Rewarding states that dragged the country behind is not the way forward. As we approach 2047, if India wants to become a superpower, developed states must be encouraged - not punished.
6:12

Increase the proportion of Lok Sabha seats on the basis of GDP contribution of states or don’t change it at all - BRS working president KTR Southern states contribute 36% to the national GDP yet are being sidelined In Telangana and Andhra, delimitation of assembly seats had to happen as per AP Reorganisation act, but the union govt didn’t do it bcos BJP has nothing to gain, but they did in J&K. So we don’t trust them Rewarding states that dragged the country behind is not the way forward. As we approach 2047, if India wants to become a superpower, developed states must be encouraged - not punished.

Naveena

787,377 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

🚨Rep. Greg Steube urges President Trump to redo the census, blasting the Biden administration for stealing seats from red states in “the biggest scandal in America.” Do it before the 2026 midterms, and many red states could gain multiple seats: “The President needs to redo the census. The Biden administration shorted Florida a seat, Texas two seats. New York and California should have less Congressmen.” “If they are able to do the census before these elections, Florida gets a seat and Texas gets a seat. They started a committee to start that process.”
3:03

🚨Rep. Greg Steube urges President Trump to redo the census, blasting the Biden administration for stealing seats from red states in “the biggest scandal in America.” Do it before the 2026 midterms, and many red states could gain multiple seats: “The President needs to redo the census. The Biden administration shorted Florida a seat, Texas two seats. New York and California should have less Congressmen.” “If they are able to do the census before these elections, Florida gets a seat and Texas gets a seat. They started a committee to start that process.”

Benny Johnson

110,428 görüntüleme • 10 ay önce

Govt is all set to punish South India The Union government has now signalled that delimitation may be moved ahead without waiting for the Census after 2026, raising the possibility that the 2011 Census could become the base for redrawing Lok Sabha seats. For those who don’t know what delimitation is, it is the process of reallocating parliamentary seats among states in line with population changes It has a stated aim of preserving fair and proportional democratic representation. But this is where the debate becomes serious. Population trends across India have not moved uniformly A major reason is the difference in fertility rates among states. Most southern states—Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana—have already brought fertility below the replacement level of 2 Meanwhile, states such as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar continue to record comparatively higher fertility levels. If seat redistribution follows these numbers, the political balance could shift sharply The five southern states together may end up with around 164 Lok Sabha seats, whereas Uttar Pradesh and Bihar alone could together command nearly 222. The larger question, then, is philosophical as much as political: Should states that succeeded in stabilising population growth lose representation because of that success? Many in the South see this as a structural disadvantage, almost a democratic penalty for effective population management. The political implications are equally significant Since the ruling party’s electoral strength has historically been far deeper across northern India than in much of the South, any expansion in seat share in the Hindi belt could naturally reshape the national balance of power in a way that may politically benefit the current establishment We are waiting for Govt’s official version Because if the present documents floating on internet are true, then South India is going to be penalised heavily in their possible future representation in Indian Lok Sabha 🙏
1:36

Govt is all set to punish South India The Union government has now signalled that delimitation may be moved ahead without waiting for the Census after 2026, raising the possibility that the 2011 Census could become the base for redrawing Lok Sabha seats. For those who don’t know what delimitation is, it is the process of reallocating parliamentary seats among states in line with population changes It has a stated aim of preserving fair and proportional democratic representation. But this is where the debate becomes serious. Population trends across India have not moved uniformly A major reason is the difference in fertility rates among states. Most southern states—Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana—have already brought fertility below the replacement level of 2 Meanwhile, states such as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar continue to record comparatively higher fertility levels. If seat redistribution follows these numbers, the political balance could shift sharply The five southern states together may end up with around 164 Lok Sabha seats, whereas Uttar Pradesh and Bihar alone could together command nearly 222. The larger question, then, is philosophical as much as political: Should states that succeeded in stabilising population growth lose representation because of that success? Many in the South see this as a structural disadvantage, almost a democratic penalty for effective population management. The political implications are equally significant Since the ruling party’s electoral strength has historically been far deeper across northern India than in much of the South, any expansion in seat share in the Hindi belt could naturally reshape the national balance of power in a way that may politically benefit the current establishment We are waiting for Govt’s official version Because if the present documents floating on internet are true, then South India is going to be penalised heavily in their possible future representation in Indian Lok Sabha 🙏

Shekhar Dutt

48,592 görüntüleme • 3 ay önce