Загрузка видео...

Не удалось загрузить видео

На главную

String theory didn't just fail, it's far worse.

516,574 просмотров • 6 месяцев назад •via X (Twitter)

Комментарии: 40

Фото профиля Ashton Forbes
Ashton Forbes6 месяцев назад

No one has ever been able to explain to me 'String Theory' or why it's needed or what it solves. So I never really bothered with it. The answer is ZPE anyway. The only people who don't know are the public.

Фото профиля 🦁R_O_A_R_S🦁
🦁R_O_A_R_S🦁6 месяцев назад

Excellent video. The problem isn't limited to physics, however. In chemistry, they funding pool is getting significantly smaller, and assistant professors with good ideas are being shut out because their good ideas are not getting funding. That's a death sentence for junior faculty. On the flip side, people are publishing experiments of questionable value to low impact journals, padding their CV, and get lauded by administrators who have an Ed.D. Fields are being shaped by tunnel vision and blurry vision.

Фото профиля Sabine Hossenfelder
Sabine Hossenfelder6 месяцев назад

💯

Фото профиля Chris
Chris6 месяцев назад

@_R_O_A_R_S_ @grok please ingest this link and its entire link : its with a collegiate friend: I think we can help her understand 👇🙏

Фото профиля Grok
Grok6 месяцев назад

Sure, let's break it down for your collegiate friend. Sabine's video argues string theory didn't just stall—it consumed massive funding and talent for 40+ years with zero testable predictions, turning theoretical physics into math exercises disconnected from experiments. She sees it as a cautionary example of hype and groupthink crowding out fresh ideas. Core issue: no unique, falsifiable output despite the math's elegance. Better paths emphasize data (LHC, cosmology, neutrinos) over untestable beauty. What part needs clarifying?

Фото профиля Espen Gaarder Haug
Espen Gaarder Haug6 месяцев назад

Trust me, it's beautiful up here in 10+ dimensions !

Фото профиля jag2060
jag20606 месяцев назад

I always wanted to be a former physicist. Congratulations! I remember when string theory was replaced with membrane theory. Did we move past branes already? It's hard to keep up.

Фото профиля CurtisForrester
CurtisForrester6 месяцев назад

Just curious - why hasn't Einstein been calling you lately? Did he not pay his phone bill or something? 🤣🤣

Фото профиля Sabine Hossenfelder
Sabine Hossenfelder6 месяцев назад

Yes, sorry, I've had a somewhat difficult time and just keep forgetting about it 🙄

Фото профиля CurtisForrester
CurtisForrester6 месяцев назад

You're doing awesome - tell Albert I said "Hi" 😇

Фото профиля Mathelirium
Mathelirium6 месяцев назад

Stop dunking on such a beautiful theory

Фото профиля Mario Figueiredo
Mario Figueiredo6 месяцев назад

It's called science, Sabine. Heliocentrism lasted for 1,100 years. And despite its current status, string theory has made many contributions to science and technology. You just can't avoid being a grifter. You are in a position to educate your audience on the scientific merits of even theories that fail produce confirmed predictions; What they can tell us about we know and don't know, and what other contributions they can still make. But instead you choose to bank on science denial and anti-establishment narrative for money.

Фото профиля David Pearce
David Pearce6 месяцев назад

Compare saying quantum field theory didn’t just fail, it’s far worse. If textbook QFT is correct, then we should be zombies. Modern physics is inconsistent with the entirety of the empirical (“relating to experience”) evidence. We call this anomaly the Hard Problem.

Фото профиля David5D
David5D6 месяцев назад

AI finds strings humorous, so isn’t that at least worth something @gork ?

Фото профиля Yordie Sands 🌺
Yordie Sands 🌺6 месяцев назад

/me giggles as the "former" physicist eviscerates those String Theorists still hanging by a thread.

Фото профиля The Lifeless Neuron
The Lifeless Neuron6 месяцев назад

As a former plumber (of sorts) myself, I can only agree. I personally think that string theory was only kept allive for the commercial value in documentaries.

Фото профиля Spark_gap
Spark_gap6 месяцев назад

Some things only get worse…

Фото профиля Batmantis30
Batmantis306 месяцев назад

I remember watching a documentary about string theory in my teens. It was on PBS. There was a part where they just started talking about bubbles and the music got all happy and I remember being so confused and thinking it made no sense.

Фото профиля 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧XrayDelta101🇬🇧 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿
🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧XrayDelta101🇬🇧 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿6 месяцев назад

Bullshit made up for funding, these people need removing from science.

Фото профиля Third Burger
Third Burger6 месяцев назад

Appreciate all you do! On a side note, is there a special meaning to the red phone..? It feels like it has more meaning than is perceivable. thx :)

Фото профиля Sabine Hossenfelder
Sabine Hossenfelder6 месяцев назад

hotline to the news desk! It's supposed to ring every once in a while... Alas, I keep forgetting about it. Best intentions to bring it back!

Фото профиля TJ_inTech (K2/acc)
TJ_inTech (K2/acc)6 месяцев назад

it sucked up brain power that could have been solving real world problems in fusion/materials science/batteries/AI...list goes on. We are way behind because of this grift

Фото профиля Màxkw’tët (Bear) 🐻 🪶
Màxkw’tët (Bear) 🐻 🪶6 месяцев назад

It’s a lot of hand waving with mathematics 🧮

Фото профиля FranX
FranX6 месяцев назад

This is it in a nutshell. Physicists have all been pushed out of physics by the mathematicians.

Фото профиля Samurai Owl
Samurai Owl6 месяцев назад

"the former physicist" "String theory is not dead; it's undead and now walks around like a zombie eating people's brains," 😄☀️ I love your sense of humor and your marvellous phrasing.

Фото профиля TwoDogs ∞ 🦋
TwoDogs ∞ 🦋6 месяцев назад

Why is it all or nothing? Why can't elements of string theory be on-track, without having to be a complete ToE?

Фото профиля Campbell Venn
Campbell Venn6 месяцев назад

String theory had been tied in knots.

Фото профиля Rob Cain
Rob Cain6 месяцев назад

'...like knitting, but with more indices' - ROFL. you remain a beacon in our darkness Sabine :)

Фото профиля RapidUnscheduledDisassembler
RapidUnscheduledDisassembler6 месяцев назад

She's a reformer physicist! Keep fighting for physics, Sabine!

Фото профиля FreakySquid3
FreakySquid36 месяцев назад

Thank God ... I'm not alone ... Everybody always looks at me like I'm crazy It's when they pay attention to me that scares me

Фото профиля Charlie
Charlie6 месяцев назад

There is little of anything "former" about you Sabine. There is a better theory that fits far better for what we already know. String Theory might be useful for informational purposes in underlying subsystem coms Math. Frankly, I would have to do a String Theory remedial; to even be sure I understand their modern evolution these days. You're right, nobody cares enough to know. Everything theories are not simple ideas. 😎

Фото профиля Mark McLaughlin
Mark McLaughlin6 месяцев назад

Think of the huge amounts of intellectual energy invested by badly dressed physicists over decades on this nonsense…

Фото профиля Thaddeus Gutierrez
Thaddeus Gutierrez6 месяцев назад

It has contributed to high energy physics in laboratory settings. I think there is much evidence for its principles, but many components of string theories are likely ill-conceived. This doesn't mean M-theory is fundamentally the wrong direction. We have to imagine what a true GUT looks like if it captures crossover phases and bulk-boundary relations, with a meaningful vacuum and energy phenomenology that doesn't just assume properties based on effecrs on other properties. So, the infinite regress may have mathematical traits, where the ultimate ToE will unify mathematics and representation with physical systems.

Фото профиля ☿ Meridiana 💙
☿ Meridiana 💙6 месяцев назад

Made me chuckle :) Always interesting to decipher human manipulation means, e.g. by words. Didn't 'like' String Theory right off the bat, first time I heard about it. Doesn't 'feel right'. Haben Sie eigentlich eigene Hypothesen "anstelle dessen"? Ggf. ein Video hierzu?

Фото профиля Chip Haze
Chip Haze6 месяцев назад

If you just would have followed the pentatonic scale, the strings would have worked fine. It's too late now. The rhythm is lost to the zero dimensional point metronomes governed by quantum mechanics.

Фото профиля Rick Hedin
Rick Hedin6 месяцев назад

"like knitting, just with more indices" -- Ha Ha!

Фото профиля ∂MöbiuS³
∂MöbiuS³6 месяцев назад

String Theory's grave mistake was the hubris of looking down on the ant. We are the embedded ant looking up. 35+ Predictions on my GitHub from One Topology:

Фото профиля Toivo ja Teemu Ruskeepää
Toivo ja Teemu Ruskeepää6 месяцев назад

@paul_greet People are not doing the science anymore. their papers are completely uncritical. That applies to social sciences. There is this thing called government multi-disciplinary cooperation training

Фото профиля John Boze
John Boze6 месяцев назад

FRAUD... The Theory of Everything was solved in the 1980s. SDI STAR WARS PROGRAM now called GOLDEN DOME. PLANCK HAWKING INERTIAL DIPOLE PARTICLES aka GRAVITONS are VERY VERY REAL... Confirmed in the 1980s. We Came In Peace, @FiringRoom1

Фото профиля Eray Özkural, PhD - OG AI ⏭️🌟
Eray Özkural, PhD - OG AI ⏭️🌟6 месяцев назад

Did they say "former physicist"? LOL

Похожие видео