Skip navigation
The Crucifixion DOESN’T Contradict Islam!
0:00 / 2:03

The Crucifixion DOESN’T Contradict Islam!

The Muslim Apologetic

@TaymiApologia3.4K followers

Visit on X
345 likesDownloadOriginal post

17,203 views

The Crucifixion DOESN’T Contradict Islam!

20 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Brian Siedelman's profile picture

    @LuckyBounce7

    So allah started christianity and made them dominant according to the quran lolol

    5 likes

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    Link for full debate below:

    4 likes

  • Manny's profile picture

    @Manny81145117

    What are you babbling about? The event of the death, burial, and resurrection of my Savior Jesus Christ is the starting point for the followers of Jesus Christ in which Islam denies happened. Are you okay?

    3 likes

  • Wizz_guy's profile picture

    @wise_guy_B

    There are simply more documented attestations outside of the Bible that a man named Jesus was crucified. The Quran claims He wasn’t crucified based simply on the fact the Quran says so.

    2 likes

  • Great Gatsby's profile picture

    @_GreatGatsby_

    The difference between Our God and your Allah is that Our God doesnt need to “make anything appear” to DECEIVE US Your Allah is the greatest deceiver That is how he makes Mohammed “appear as” a prophet A pedo warlord 😊

    2 likes

  • BrxnSpirit's profile picture

    @IamBrxn

    If Jesus Christ was not crucified then both New and Old Testaments are false. But that's the problem with this. The birth of Jesus Christ and His ministry as well as His suffering and burial in a rich man's tomb was revealed in the Old Testament and the Jewish people saw Him. That's why He said that they were guilty and they would be judged by Moses because they were pretending to follow that law and they past their traditions to their children so they do the same. At that time, they already had their scriptures which revealed the Messiah to them and they saw with their eyes Jesus fulfilling the Old Testament in Word and deed and they rejected Him which was also prophesied, just as they largely rejected Him in their hearts throughout the Old Testament. The New Testament confirms the Old Testament, and uses Israel as a warning to the world of what happens when you forsake God after He reveals Himself. The difference between them and the rest of the world is that they have a promise given to them that after they 'pay double' and 'their time of trouble' they are restored in the Kingdom of their King when they 'look on Him whom they've pierced,' their Messiah on the cross. The rest of the world doesn't get that promise because of the rejection of free grace after He revealed Himself. The Bible repeats and the nature of God never changes. He is made a Man in His Own Image.

    2 likes

  • MODBAN's profile picture

    @modban

    You Muslims always twist your narrative This just further supports why the Quran is incoherent

    1 like

  • Star Star's profile picture

    @StarSta96464571

    Defending the indefensible. The Quran is an inspiration of Satan, AKA Allah, Jibril. Satan is the god of the world. He is the father of lies. You folks are under his web while speaking grammar. The bewitchment which Muhd suffered is still ingrained in his indoctrinated followers

    1 like

  • adafg's profile picture

    @antinomia0

    So the reality is contradicted with the fact?

    1 like

  • palharri's profile picture

    @palharri

    You are talking out of your arse if you think making it appear that the crucifixion happened allows history to line up with the Quran It still doesn’t stop the fact that Allah created the religion of Christianity

  • Jeff💫💫's profile picture

    @Jaypee0200

    Proto-muslim 😭😭😭😭 Wetin I no go hear 😭

  • Harun®️'s profile picture

    @haarruunns

    Perfectly explained thank you

  • velvateen's profile picture

    @collum444

    It's simple holmes, of all the books written, only John was actually there

  • The Kufr Chronicles's profile picture

    @kufrchronicles

    This clip is a textbook example of what happens when internet apologists try to defend Islam without any grounding in Mantiq (logic), Usul al-Tafsir, or Hikmah (Islamic philosophy). Every single premise in this two-minute argument collapses under basic rational scrutiny: Redefining 'History' as 'Illusion' Destroys Epistemology Claiming that 'history tracks perception, not reality' so that the Bible and the Quran do not contradict each other is philosophical nonsense. In classical Islamic logic (Mantiq) and philosophy, truth (Sidq) is the correspondence of a statement to objective reality (Mutabaqat al-Khabar li al-Waqi'). Either Jesus (as) died on the cross in objective reality, or he did not. Two mutually exclusive claims about a physical event are logical contradictories (Naqidayn). If 'history' merely records mass hallucinations engineered by God, you haven't harmonized scripture with history. you have destroyed the reliability of all historical transmission, including your own. Attributing Mass Deception to God Violates Divine Justice (Adl) and Wisdom (Hikmah) Under your model, God deliberately staged a miraculous illusion so convincing that Jesus's own sincere disciples were deceived into believing he was crucified, leaving humanity in that false belief for 600 years. From a rationalist ('Adliyyah) standpoint, God does not fabricate sensory deceptions to mislead faithful believers into building a false theology. Worse still, your analogy to 2 Kings 7 is an embarrassing blunder: in that Old Testament story, God frightens an invading enemy army to save His people. In your crucifixion theory, God deceives His own Prophet's disciples! Using an unverified Old Testament war story to explain Surah An-Nisa 4:157 shows zero familiarity with classical Tafsir. Complete Ignorance of Classical Tafsir (Shubbiha Lahum) Anyone who has actually opened major works of Tafsir from al-Razi to Allamah Tabataba'i's Al-Mizan will know that shubbiha lahum has deep linguistic and exegetical nuances (such as 'the matter was made ambiguous/confused to them,' rather than a simplistic Hollywood-style magic trick played on the disciples). Presenting a superficial, pop-apologetic reading as definitive Islamic theology while calling pre-Islamic believers in a false narrative 'perfectly Muslim' confuses excused ignorance (Jahl Qasir) with objective truth. Islam does not need cheap philosophical word games or borrowed Old Testament analogies to defend itself. Before lecturing people on history and theology, take the time to actually study Mantiq, Kalam, and classical Tafsir.

  • justsomebodyxx's profile picture

    @RaheelGill25532

    So what about all the instances that were recorded of jesus appearing to thr apostles? Are those mere illusions too?

  • Blo_wid's profile picture

    @Blo_wid

    Islam is indeed the solution to all problems

  • nature's profile picture

    @whymeldn

    @grok is the Quran clear on this what is the Arabic word used

  • Melkisedet's profile picture

    @marinocant70837

    Abdul you are too stupid to understand the fallacy

  • UTID's profile picture

    @f1ynny

    In Christianity the Crucifixion has a massive purpose so I’d expect to have seen it happen, but if Allah is God then why did it happen at all, it has no relevance or purpose to be in scripture….

  • Manny's profile picture

    @Manny81145117

    As a Christian, I rejoice that the truth of the cross continues to be proclaimed even by Muslims today. Jesus never fails in his promises!