Skip navigation
The dad was right.
0:00 / 4:38

The dad was right.

Mo

@atmoio86K followers

Visit on X
456 likesDownloadOriginal post

48,823 views

The dad was right.

32 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Adam Jacob's profile picture

    @adamhjk

    I think you under-rate human creativity and capacity for struggle. The 9 year old getting tips on how to talk to her sisters will still, in fact, struggle to talk to her sisters. The painting example falls flat because it is disconnected from a wider context - but if they created that house out of an entire conception of a virtual world, the creativity simply expanded beyond the original limitation (her ability to draw houses.) We will not eliminate creativity, or struggle. We will express it in new shapes, we will struggle in new ways. For me, I would teach my daughter that what she needs to learn is how to incorporate technology into her own creative life. AI is no different.

    10 likes

  • Mo's profile picture

    @atmoio

    true i suppose. i guess im not imaginative enough to figure out what the future of struggle looks like

  • Adam Jacob's profile picture

    @adamhjk

    the swimming question is perfect. She's not going to become a better swimmer because google gave her tips on how to increase her times. Still going to have to struggle! AI agents can draw pictures for you, they can write code for you - and today, that's astounding, because doing those things required years of skill and struggle. But for our kids? Far less. Which just means we won't be astounded when they auto-generated a picture of a house. But we will be by what they do with that capacity. From a Buddhist perspective - AI doesn't eliminate the four noble truths. There will be plenty of struggle and suffering to go around. No need to worry about that. :)

    3 likes

  • MSA's profile picture

    @MainStreetAIHQ

    Startup idea: AI for kids I expect a 10% cut from anyone who steals my idea Also something to think about: Does this mean people who grew up with the internet shouldn't have had access to the internet? and people shouldn't have had access to books? Or mentors? I get that AI is different but at what point do we draw the line of outside factors not allowed to affect our kids? I would argue it's worse to let (some) teachers influence your kid than it is AI Though, AI is not much better I think the solution to all of this is to spend as much time with your kids as possible That way you can put your way of life into your kid

    6 likes

  • Kirill Zubovsky's profile picture

    @kirillzubovsky

    "He wasn't upset that she was using Gemini..." 🤣

    4 likes

  • Mo's profile picture

    @atmoio

    😄

    1 like

  • Harshil Lodhiya's profile picture

    @HarshilLodhiya

    Backed by MIT for a reason.

    4 likes

  • allOS.dev - Creating Cross-Platform Apps's profile picture

    @raddevus

    "Her friend, at 9, is shipping triple A games..." I reject the entire premise 9yr old figured that out right? How to deploy to Steam etc? Nope. Don't believe it at all. Also, "triple-A game"... Nope! I reject the entire premise as false, fake, AI-slop.

    2 likes

  • Ihtesham Ali's profile picture

    @ihteshamali

    Dads are always right.

    2 likes

  • SatyaNaaksh's profile picture

    @SatyaNaaksh

    New industry affected by AI: Parenting

    2 likes

  • james gibson's profile picture

    @jamesalangibson

    I like your analysis. One more datum related is that you might think of the actions normally done to get the output is a kind of achievement when done well, which is intrinsically valuable. This value in the act gets lost by outsourcing effort to AI.

    2 likes

  • Mario Figueiredo's profile picture

    @fromdevoid

    Very good, as always! And you are right, the truth is always somewhere in the middle. But that metric is fundamental to our ability to elevate ourselves in a world that won't stop being competitive and no doubt continue on its brutal rising slope. And every unit counts. There is no question the type of kids I will want my son and daughters to raise. And I'll be sure to influence that decision on them at every single moment of their newly acquired adult lives.

    2 likes

  • D.R. Guérit-Tout's profile picture

    @PKMerlott

    It's weird that the dad is railing against AI when both he and his daughter and this bullshit post were completely invented by it.

    2 likes

  • loudz's profile picture

    @loudzxbt

    The Dad was right indeed Mo!

    2 likes

  • AP's profile picture

    @Bettop1

    I don't agree with this. AI is a tool, a tool like a smartphone is a tool or as the internet itself is a tool. The problem is not the tool itself, but teaching your children how to use those tools responsibly

    2 likes

  • Skinner's Fattest Pigeon's profile picture

    @_SFPigeon

    This is exactly the same as finding out your wife uses a dildo

    1 like

  • Vlad's profile picture

    @valerionxv

    he was right for the wrong reasons

    1 like

  • Dr Lyra - Pretty Helpful Device's profile picture

    @EKG_DrLyra

    Human creativity, imagination, curiosity, are not confined to the physical realm - creative writing is a skill and the best GenAI comes out of creative writing. Same with taste and refinement that comes from it. These are very human qualities and regardless of how they are utilized, they should be reinforced. Your daughter drew you a picture in crayon is a nice gesture. The same thing can be said about generating an image using genAI. They are not mutually exclusive and youre putting more value on the medium and not the action. If you want to talk about sycophantic AI and how detrimental that can be with kids, Im with you and that can be a serious discussion. OAI put kid gloves on their models and frankly, they should. Other companies should also follow suit. But if youre talking about your daughters INTENT - to create something for you - then does it matter HOW she did it? The Mona Lisa has no connection to you emotionally because you dont know the artist, have no connection to the painting itself. Your daughter has to have a thought and desire first : "I want to make something for my dad" and **THAT** should be all that matters. When you start attaching stipulations to peoples intent - "it doesnt matter as much because of X", "you didnt work as hard for Y", "I dont value the output as much because of Z" - what youre doing is minimizing the intent. Not only is that detrimental to development, but its also extremely discouraging to people. I dont care whether someone generated me a piece of artwork using genAI, or drew something for me themselves, because ultimately, they were thinking about me and decided to exert effort (any amount) to make it happen. Remember : "Its the thought that counts" 😉

    1 like

  • Dule🍃's profile picture

    @dusanmitrovic98

    Without a doubt, the father was right! Seeing what AI does to grown ups using it makes me worried... Not to mention what would happen to a child growing up using it. That is such a scary thought. Parents protect your children! You do not know what you have lost until you lose it 🙂.. I would have done the same without a second thought 💯

    1 like

  • Guy tamam's profile picture

    @GuyMosheTamam

    My kid was typing something to chat while I sat next to him and I saw a chat titled “what does it mean to be a good dad”, it comes after stressful period in general and specifically between me and my wife, a day later I talked to him about it, didnt ask why, just told him this->

    1 like