The data is flawed. It's simply not possible mathematically. the IAS IPS recruitment follows reservation percentage. the total number of SC - IAS will be above 15 % of total strength, ST -IAS/IPS will be above 8 %.. and total OBC-IAS/IPS will be above 27 %of total strength.

They are creating fake atrocity literature and presenting it in government. They will do so because we operate in good faith thinking that we should accept all the atrocity literature

तुम चूतिए हो क्या ? मुझे तो तुम्हारा प्रोपेगंडा नजर आ रहा है। जो रिपोर्ट राज्य सभा में पेश की गई है उसमें कैटेगरी वाइस 5 साल यानि 2020 से 2024 वाला डाटा दिया गया है। 1 जनवरी 2025 तक का अपडेट है तो 10 साल की बात क्यों कर रहे हो ? तुम्हारा भेजा काम नहीं कर रहा है 🤡🤡

bhai apka logic sahi he, par isme wire ka koi role nahi.. ye data modi government ne present kiya he parliament me..

@thewire_in another devesh... Once is error, twice maybe error but repetition is ineptitude + malice!

Absolutely here is full data Wire does not even vet numbers for calculating

5% ST toh kewal Meena hi honge..in last year (2024), out of 87 ST seats, 32 were Meena..apart from that, now only 70 general candidates on average become IAS due to migration of candidates from OBC and other communities..this data is present in a flawed manner and another way to disrupt the harmony and dividing communities..

इसका मतलब जो सरकार ias ips ifs के खाते में तनख़ाह डालती है उसे पता नहीं है, आपको बहुत ज्यादा पता है

This shows the credibility of wire Simple as that😌

Reservation is for qualification not for posts.

There is no data for the UCs in open merit,while General cat. itself has OBC CL,merit OBC/SC/ST, muslim, christian and other minorities. Aur surname se ghanta kuch pata chalta hai.

A few days ago, I came across a report claiming that 90% of university faculty members are “Upper Castes.” How is that even possible? So I opened the report and read it in full. It turns out they conveniently classified (GC + OBC) together as “Upper Castes.” And then, some OBC members began citing that very report to claim that “Upper Castes” have captured all the university positions.

@thewire_in iss news agency se news ka matlab hi hai fake news. Ye sirf desh mein aag lagana chahta hai.

@thewire_in don't spread false reports. Don't u dare to think the public won't realise ur fake propaganda!!!take ur fake report down

@ajeetbharti @ARanganathan72 @neha_laldas @Tushar15 @Sanjay_Dixit @kushal_mehra If the reserved seats are fixed and can't be occupied by gc how come the govt is giving the number specially the article talks about 2020-24. Another step by the govt to push gc into a corner.

If seats are fixed category-wise every year, how is it even possible that one category ends up having more IAS and IPS officers than others? General category students cannot be selected against reserved seats, and the number of seats for each category is already predefined🙄

अमित भाई सब साले दल्ले है और ये लड़ते भी इसलिए है किसी और की जगह ये दलाली खा सके सारी लड़ाई दलाली खाने की है

Wire = Liar अगर उन्होंने छापा है तो झूट ही होगा

Hey Mate! Do not be so hyperactive while presenting the facts. Pls read my analysis carefully. 1️⃣. The data what is presented in the Rajya Sabha by Minister of state Mr.Jitender Singh is for 2020-2024 presumably for 5 years. 2️⃣. If you sum up all the figures of OBC+SC+ST what he gave in his statement for those 5 years period they amount to 1264 = 135 +67 + 245 + 141+71+231+95+48+231. The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) typically recruits around 180 IAS Officers, 200 IPS Officers, and 45 IFS Officers annually. All services cumulatively 425 Officers and for 5 years(2020-2024) period it amounts to 2125 Officers. Now the percentage of Reserved quota = (1264/2125)x100 = 59.48% 3️⃣. One more astonishing thing I noticed is that in your video while presenting the facts your screenshot of @thewire_in article is not matching with below link to The Wire's same article. They have corrected at 10.07Am? If so they are also in haste like you to jump the gun. 😳😳😳 @GarimaCgj1 @vipul__p @Ruchisi72528 @AnkitaGiggles Govt Evasive on Number of SC, ST, OBC Officers in IAS, IPS, IFS, Only Provides Data of Direct Recruits in Last 4 Yrs - The Wire

Someone should drag the wire to the courts

The data is conflicting or at least narration. Little research shows different number, deep dive could reveal more details. Sources:

Ase farji News walo ko BJP 12 sal me kuch nhi kar saki

Unbelievable report

How many IAS officers from the SC, ST, and OBC categories are working under the PMO, and how many have been appointed so far? Also, please mention how many IAS officers belong to 'Jaat' caste, you belong to this cast.

Let's @grok explain it

@Kanchanyadav000 dekh le ❤️di

reservation applies at the recruitment stage, not necessarily to the total existing cadre strength at a given moment. So while theoretically SC ≈ 15%, ST ≈ 7.5–8%, and OBC ≈ 27% over long periods, real-time cadre composition may fluctuate above or below those benchmarks.

1. Govt provided only direct recruit data (2020-24), not full data sought by MP. The Wire misreported it as overall stats; now corrected 2. Why didn't govt disclose complete data? 3. There is no resrvation in Gr A promotions. Uses 'promotion by selection' method. Why did u lie?

the wire is correct.

The wire is a propoganda publish tool

"Mera challenge hai govt. ko " " Govt. kyu jhooth bol rhi rhi? " Mr. Challenger , pls read the question asked in Rajya Sabha and then the written reply given. I agree it's inadequate data, but first research it properly before blabbering anything.

फर्जी डेटा फेकने वाले देश मे आग लगा रहे है। ये चाहते है कि सामान्य क्लास बस पेपर देना ही छोड़ दे ताकि भारत मे भी वही स्थिति बन जो बंगलादेश, श्रीलंका व नेपाल में बनी

It's fashion now days to target General Category. And the outlets like @thewire_in intentionally do fake Propganda to create hatered against general category in society.

In my office I rarely see any general category employee. From Supdt to commissioner, every fking one is SC/ST. Another shocker, SC/ST candidates in CBIC gets promoted from LDC to Addl. Commissioner, total 9 promotions. While Gen/Obc still struggle fr 2-3 promotions till retiremnt

They deleted the post

The wire name should be ..The liar spreading fire(false information)