The energy needed to pulverise rocks/metals/etc.
@cirnosad135K followers
21,467 views
41 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@cirnosad
[You might also wonder where and how the HELL such a mechanical wave could be generated, I'm not going to answer this question in this thread. :) You will have to wait for my final thread] [NB: The wave will remain in the lattice, like sound waves remain in the water of the sea.]
233 likes

@cirnosad
It might seem easy for a glass, and wouldn't take much energy, but concrete, rock and metal is a totally different ball game. You would need to vibrate the lattice of each of these materials with such a large phonon energy that the bonds break apart at many site defects points.
239 likes

@cirnosad
And for that matter, HOW would you do this? Through a mechanical wave pulse of immense intensity & impulse, we can create a standing wave that pulverises the building! Sound. This wave would travels through the metal, concrete and so on, much more dense than the air around it.
261 likes

@cirnosad
Thus, we can also safely discard the stupid pancake collapse idea and its modern incarnation of "spontaneous crumbling". That leaves one question then: How much energy would it take to actually pulverize 100 floors of the WTC spontaneously [and from the bottom upwards]?
251 likes

@cirnosad
You can thus, create a scaled experiment at home by strapping a grenade to a concrete or reinforced structural steel beam and verify for yourself that it doesn't get pulverised. There's not enough energy to do this. You could blow the sheet metal of a washing machine up though:
234 likes

@cirnosad
This impact is thus equivalent to distributing 100 grams of TNT (yes,grams) for each meters squared of flooring, whether this is a steel beam or concrete etc. this would be on the surface, not *embedded* within the target, as it would be a surface impact. Similar to a M67 grenade
201 likes

@cirnosad
I'm going to go further to reveal a bigger problem. Let's return to the impact energy of the putative mass. A kg of TNT has about 4.184 MJ of energy. At 1.94GJ, the energy of the top mass is equivalent to: 464 kg of TNT. This is distributed across an area of ~4,000 m^2.
220 likes

@cirnosad
[Point 1: If you can't grasp the last point, remember Newton's third law: every force is complemented by a matching force in the opposite direction.] [Point 2: As the floors meet resistance, they will slow down and the impact will get lower and lower.]
259 likes

@cirnosad
Furthermore, the "pulverising mass" doesn't have any more strength/hardness than the mass below, they are EXACTLY the same. We can assume we would lose at least one floor to pulverisation/dispersion to crumble another. This means we would stop at just 24 floors. Thus, impossible!
241 likes

@cirnosad
We can use a basic formula from physics, P=mgh to obtain 1.94GJ as the energy of this impact. One questions arise: If this is enough to pulverise the next floor, how much kinetic energy would remain? We would need enough energy to pulverise the next floor and so on!
233 likes

@cirnosad
Let's grant 12 floors of mass of the 110 floor tower, and 1 "missing" floor where the putative failure occurs. This is more than generous and unrealistic. Each floor was 4 meters high. That's 12/110=11% of the mass or for a 450,000 ton building, 49,500 tons of concrete and steel.
226 likes

@cirnosad
Now you probably have even more questions than before. What the hell happened to the steel below? Let's return to the initial paper's assumption: That the top floors, teleporting through the "weakened" floors below (from muh jet fuel) pulverised the entire building. (π)
319 likes

@cirnosad
Once you've absorbed the above, watch this video of the North tower's top section collapsing SOLIDLY (not as dust) into the tower below, which offers zero resistance. This eliminates the silly "DEW" idea, as a column of energy would have "vaporised" the building uniformly.
275 likes

@cirnosad
How can I possibly justify the idea that the tower instantly turned to dust? It sounds nonsensical, I know. Well... hold on to your seat and try not to scream. How did that steal beam turn to dust AS it fell??? Look at it again, carefully! Have you ever seen this before?
392 likes

@cirnosad
All directed energy weapons involve a transfer of energy, through photonic emission. This can be used to ionise a target, but such a thing would 1st result in a phase change from solid to liquid, then from liquid to gas. The towers didn't turn into gas, but dust -- still solid.
264 likes

@cirnosad
How could the towers have turned to dust in an instant? Let's eliminate one stupid idea by a shill, Judy Wood: Directed energy weapons. Like lasers or wacky particle beam. But this is outright impossible: There was no "energy build up"!
274 likes

@cirnosad
In fact, in a "mystery" I won't answer in this thread, some of this dust piled up in the very hot basement! Shown below are two of the "WTC meteorites", with the one on the left representing four entire floors of steel structure, concrete, office furniture, equipment & people.
317 likes

@cirnosad
Now, the concrete couldn't have disappeared on its own, and certainly, if the steel (thus iron), which held up the building remained, it wouldn't have collapsed. So the 90,000 m. t steel was certainly pulverised along with the rest of the 450,000 mt tower, minus basement mass.
269 likes

@cirnosad
A USGS survey of the dust detected Fe-rich primary metal and metal-oxide phases. Unfortunately, the dust also consisted of everything else in the tower which was pulverised into fine dust (1% in 2.5um, 99% above). We can say given visuals of rough transparency, 80um on average.
259 likes

@cirnosad
We have to shift the focus to the mechanism of destruction: 90,000 tons of steel "disappeared". Let's focus on ONE place we know it ended up: Much of it spontaneously turned into fine translucent dust. This dust ended up everywhere and on everyone. It was HIGHLY toxic too.
320 likes
