Topologically, how many holes does a doughnut (torus) actually have? 🍩
@TheMathFlow91K followers
25,237 views
27 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@rapg72
T2=S1×S1, Algebraicamente: b1=2
4 likes

@cibrigi47428
If you take away the donut, is the hole still there?
4 likes

@Millbstrd
Interesting question. Topologically speaking, one might say there are no holes? Except where tunnelling may be possible. Doesn't the "shape" itself replace infinite zero, with +1, as seen in 2D (0,1)+1, 3D (0,1,(+-)1)+1, and 4D (0,1)+1(0,1(+-)1)+1? Way oversimplified, sorry.
4 likes

@JohnSmith828182
Two holes. One per Z of the fundamental group. Well almost 😁
2 likes

@rmhood300
Who cares? Just eat and enjoy.
2 likes

@shamrockFen
It depends where you're observing from but assuming you are looking at it objectively, it's a ring of rings +2. So how many rings make up the torus... Then add one for the middle and one for the boundary.
2 likes

@AnthonNoire
Topologically if the torus is represented contiguously without a hollow interior it has one hole. That hole allows it to be plastically deformed a great many ways like a worm or teacup (one hole each) but not a plate (zero holes) or mammal (many holes). Unlike inside a balloon a lasso loop cannot be shrunk to zero inside a hollow torus or donut (like hostess raspberry donuts) so hollow donuts have two holes.
2 likes

@robots_n_tools
Zero. It's flat
1 like

@JCNVXXX777
"If you don't want your plasma destroying your reactor walls, you’ll have to pay. This type of solution isn't free
1 like

@TimothyWhi89929
1
1 like

@MatthewAlbano8
There two holes which tells us about the homology groups and the fundamental group of T^2. I might be mistaken but I think H_2 ~ Z^2.
1 like

@ToroidGames
0.
1 like

@stoicfaux
None. The object is solid with no holes in it.
1 like

@LXVI_Hadron
topologically, 1
1 like

@TimothyWhi89929
If there's no one there to watch another eat the donut, is there still a hole? BWAHAHAHAHAHA
1 like

@diweixia
1 hole because it's not simply connected. @grok

@_camronwilliams
0

@HenningSittler
ITT In this thread 0 1 2 What are we missing?

@pandazhao1982
还好,我死去的记忆告诉我是1个洞的时候,我查了gpt和claude,他们同意我的看法,1个洞。

@VvictoryVgc
Yep







