why can't we have nice things?
@owocki134K followers
22,772 views
42 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@0xPetra
u can just do stuff jedi: positive sum games mid: doesn't play dumb: negative sum games
11 likes

@wor
Thanks for this clear presentation of the multipolar trap as a structure of incentives. ..... but/and before we speak of terrain, valleys, or the reshaping of landscapes, I must ask you to return, with me, to the things themselves as they are given in your own experience @owocki . How does this “race to the bottom” actually appear in your lived experience? Not as an abstract model, not as a diagram of arrows pointing downhill, but as it is lived by you ... moment by moment. When you encounter others defecting, or feel the pressure not to be the first to cooperate, what is the precise character of that experience? What is the intentional structure of that sense of being “stuck”? and how is the 'better' summit given to you ... intuitively, anticipatorily, or only emptily meant? Rest aside, for a moment, the economic and game-theoretic interpretations. Describe for me, as faithfully as you can, the phenomena as they present themselves in the first person. From a more pure description of the lived experience I think we can begin to see the essential structures at work.
9 likes

@owocki
I think a good example is climate. Hypothetical but relatable example follows: I make a decision to say, fly across the world (or drive somewhere, or other economic activity), because I want to work/leisure/some other goal, while knowing the carbon footprint is non zero. Of course I don’t want to live in a Venus-ified planet. But I also don’t know that I trust the carbon offset product offered by airline (or in case of other economic activity, offsets don’t exist). Nor does my individual commitment make much difference without commitments from many others. So i just do the economic thing and usually don’t offset the carbon. How dat?
4 likes

@wor
Yes … getting there , @owocki. I want to stay with the phenomena as they give themselves in that moment of decision. You stand before the possibility of the flight (or the drive, the purchase). The goal ( work, leisure, the concrete project ) is given with a certain fullness....: it draws you, it has the character of something already underway in your practical horizon, almost bodily anticipated. Alongside it, or rather co-given but in a different mode, is the carbon footprint. How does that appear? Not as a number first, but as a non-zero mark, a shadow that accompanies the intentional act of choosing the trip. Is it given as a present perception, or more as an empty intending ..... a meaning that points toward consequences never yet fulfilled in intuition for you personally? The Venus-ified planet: how is it present to consciousness in that instant? As a vivid fulfillment of dread, or only as an emptily meant horizon, a limit-possibility that floats at the edge of the practical field without ever pressing into the here-and-now with the same force as the immediate goal? And the offset: you do not trust it. Describe that distrust as it is lived. Is it a felt opacity in the object itself (the “product” offered by the airline), a sense that the intentional rays directed toward it fail to reach any genuine fulfillment? Or is it more the awareness of an intersubjective failure ... that the chain of acts required for the offset to mean what it claims remains unfulfilled by the others? Here is the turn in direction: “my individual commitment makes much difference without commitments from many others.” Here our sense of being “stuck” crystallizes. What is its precise intentional structure? Do you experience yourself as one among anonymous others whose acts remain empty, so that one’s own act is felt as almost nullified in advance? Is the “many others” given as a concrete community of co-intenders, or only as an abstract multiplicity whose cooperation is perpetually postponed? And finally ...... the settling into “just doing the economic thing.” What is the character of that settling? A release? A residual unease that continues to co-intend the unfulfilled horizon? A shift in the mode of attention, where the practical goal absorbs the field and the ecological meanings are bracketed, not denied, but simply no longer attended to with the same intensity? I want to stay with these lived structures a little longer, if we can. From the pure description of how these meanings are given ... full or empty, near or remote, fulfilled or frustrated .... .. we may begin to see the essential forms that make the multipolar trap more than a diagram.
1 like

@wor
I sincerely try to make room for experience, but my theoretical fluency often rushes in to occupy that room.
1 like

@wor
I am learning to let experience interrupt my understanding before my understanding organizes the experience.
1 like

@wor
I don't want to abandon theory, but to suspend its premature authority and make it answerable to how things are given, evidenced, and corrected. .. in other words ... Experience gets to interrupt theory before theory speaks for experience.

@owocki
i think theory/empiricism are complementary ways of knowing. one of my favorite scenes from one of my favorite movies:

@wor
The scene stages two incomplete forms ... A. theory without embodiment, and B. action without understanding. What it seems to seek is praxis: .... thought that risks becoming conduct, and conduct that remains reflective and answerable to the world. I would put it this way ..... A theory of transformed life becomes credible when it is permitted to transform the theorist’s life.
2 likes

@brianakaka
No one thinks they are evil but we have evil in the world. Rational actions are based on perception of the world. Different perceptions lead to different rational actions.
6 likes

@RGreen622
I discuss much about aligning incentives like this in my book. It covers Routing Work, one of the few consensus mechanisms thats truly incentive aligned:
6 likes

@cdor_n
why do tech people need a 3 dimensional plane to explain the concept of honour
4 likes

@wonderwomancode
My current business thesis in a nutshell. --> Partner w other startups and municipalities, even if they seem like "competition" --> Climb the hill together, linked arm in arm --> Gain critical mass to topple the hyperscalers.
4 likes

@at0x_eth
This is how a pot full of crabs behaves: one starts to climb, and the others actually drag it down.
3 likes

@Moneyz0x
imagine if we all just decided to share instead
3 likes

@allnaz1sRn0nces
hmm 🤔 if only enough people could rise up at once to dismantle the old perverse incentive structures and establish new ones in which everyone benefits bc the individual interests have now aligned with the collective interests...
3 likes

@clix81ne
bro you can’t fix the players without fixing the game
3 likes

@Salomon0x5A10
There were some political movements in the early 1900s that tried to implement this solution. If only there was a way to bind everyone’s commitments in a single rational direction.
2 likes

@blanktablets
cooperate with a knife held between your teeth
2 likes

@kittycatgaba
working on this at
2 likes



















