Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

A change to consensus rules with no consensus. The BIP-110 debate is not about spam, it is about the dangerously low bar now set for pushing consensus changes into Bitcoin.

JAN3com's profile picture

JAN3

32,985 subscribers

12,308 views • 6 days ago •via X (Twitter)

LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Comments

No comments available

Comments from the original post will appear here

Related Videos

Daniel Buchner: Why BIP 110 Cannot Stop Bitcoin Spam | SLP758 Daniel Ƀrrr dismantles the case for BIP 110, showing that embedding data in public keys and hashes makes consensus-level spam filters ineffective from day one. Timestamps: 01:31 — Locusts Flock to Bitcoin's Last Pasture 03:32 — Core Policy Tweaks Aren't Consensus Rules 08:44 — Spam Hides in Any Public Key or Hash 11:12 — Spammers Adapt in a Day, Consensus Can't 14:59 — BIP110 Debate Exposes Major Inconsistency 20:44 — Why the House Analogy Totally Fails 25:25 — Nodes Get Cheaper Even With Max Spam 28:08 — Set Tolerances Assuming Worst Case 30:35 — Legal Liability for Bad Chain Data 33:04 — Filter Regime Creates Government Backdoor 35:13 — BIP 110 Risks Centralizing Dev Around Luke 37:33 — Economic Incentives Trump 'Good Guy' Miners 39:03 — Economic Nodes Outweigh Basement Node Runners 43:49 — BIP 110 Has Near-Zero Economic Support 48:43 — Game Theory? 55:52 — BIP 110 Fork Dies With a Whimper
57:01

Daniel Buchner: Why BIP 110 Cannot Stop Bitcoin Spam | SLP758 Daniel Ƀrrr dismantles the case for BIP 110, showing that embedding data in public keys and hashes makes consensus-level spam filters ineffective from day one. Timestamps: 01:31 — Locusts Flock to Bitcoin's Last Pasture 03:32 — Core Policy Tweaks Aren't Consensus Rules 08:44 — Spam Hides in Any Public Key or Hash 11:12 — Spammers Adapt in a Day, Consensus Can't 14:59 — BIP110 Debate Exposes Major Inconsistency 20:44 — Why the House Analogy Totally Fails 25:25 — Nodes Get Cheaper Even With Max Spam 28:08 — Set Tolerances Assuming Worst Case 30:35 — Legal Liability for Bad Chain Data 33:04 — Filter Regime Creates Government Backdoor 35:13 — BIP 110 Risks Centralizing Dev Around Luke 37:33 — Economic Incentives Trump 'Good Guy' Miners 39:03 — Economic Nodes Outweigh Basement Node Runners 43:49 — BIP 110 Has Near-Zero Economic Support 48:43 — Game Theory? 55:52 — BIP 110 Fork Dies With a Whimper

Stephan Livera

14,580 views • 12 days ago

The media insist a “scientific consensus” says climate change is a manmade crisis. “It’s a manufactured consensus,” researcher Judith Curry tells me. Curry knows—she once spread alarm about climate change. Now she reveals the nefarious ways “the science” is corrupted.
7:13

The media insist a “scientific consensus” says climate change is a manmade crisis. “It’s a manufactured consensus,” researcher Judith Curry tells me. Curry knows—she once spread alarm about climate change. Now she reveals the nefarious ways “the science” is corrupted.

John Stossel

631,421 views • 3 years ago

John Lynch was asked about them reaching for draft picks in the past couple of years according to the consensus: “I appreciate that you think that, it depends on whose consensus. We’ve got consensus in this building. That’s the consensus I care about.”
0:24

John Lynch was asked about them reaching for draft picks in the past couple of years according to the consensus: “I appreciate that you think that, it depends on whose consensus. We’ve got consensus in this building. That’s the consensus I care about.”

Coach Yac 🗣

158,989 views • 3 months ago

🚨JUST IN: Charles Schwab Corp introduces #Ordinals and #Runes to Wall Street due to BIP-110's lack of broad consensus across the Bitcoin ecosystem.
2:36

🚨JUST IN: Charles Schwab Corp introduces #Ordinals and #Runes to Wall Street due to BIP-110's lack of broad consensus across the Bitcoin ecosystem.

Vincent (Cryptolution) 👑

19,262 views • 19 days ago

We have absolutely no idea what kind of chaos is going to ensue if BIP-110 gets pushed through without consensus. If the market sides against the restrictive rules, we are left with a smaller, weaker monetary Bitcoin while the "spam-enabling" version wins all the institutional money. I pulled this clip from my recent chat with Luke de Wolf because it highlights the true stakes of this governance debate. Check it out here or catch the whole of discussion below.
5:33

We have absolutely no idea what kind of chaos is going to ensue if BIP-110 gets pushed through without consensus. If the market sides against the restrictive rules, we are left with a smaller, weaker monetary Bitcoin while the "spam-enabling" version wins all the institutional money. I pulled this clip from my recent chat with Luke de Wolf because it highlights the true stakes of this governance debate. Check it out here or catch the whole of discussion below.

Guy Swann

37,049 views • 1 month ago

#Jaguars GM James Gladstone on the consensus board debate: “We build consensus internally, and that is leveraged at every pick point.” He added that consensus doesn’t always align because they don’t take into account scheme or the situation a player is coming into. (🎥 Jacksonville Jaguars)
1:31

#Jaguars GM James Gladstone on the consensus board debate: “We build consensus internally, and that is leveraged at every pick point.” He added that consensus doesn’t always align because they don’t take into account scheme or the situation a player is coming into. (🎥 Jacksonville Jaguars)

Ari Meirov

179,003 views • 3 months ago

The “scientific consensus” talking point was succinctly dismantled by Dr. Judith Curry in her interview with John Stossel back in October. 𝗝𝗼𝗵𝗻 𝗦𝘁𝗼𝘀𝘀𝗲𝗹: “The overwhelming scientific consensus. That’s what people still believe.” 𝗗𝗿. 𝗝𝘂𝗱𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗖𝘂𝗿𝗿𝘆: “. . . when you talk about ‘scientific consensus,’ like the Earth orbits the sun, you don’t need to say ‘There’s a consensus that the Earth orbits the sun,’ it’s a well-known fact. When you’re talking about consensus, it’s usually on a topic where there is disagreement, and a government has asked a group to come to some sort of an agreement on what’s what. You see it in science, you see it in. . . medical boards. . . So, it’s a manufactured consensus. It’s a consensus of scientists, which is different than a scientific consensus. . .” Dr. Curry goes on to explain that there is no consensus on the most contentious issues of climate change, such as extent of human contribution and the impacts. 𝗗𝗿. 𝗝𝘂𝗱𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗖𝘂𝗿𝗿𝘆: “. . . there’s a true scientific consensus on very little of this, you know that, • The temperatures have been increasing for over a hundred years. • That burning of fossil fuels emits CO₂ into the atmosphere. • And, CO₂ has a radiation spectrum that sort of keeps the Earth’s surface warm, all other things being equal. Beyond that, there’s no real big consensus on anything. The most consequential issues we don’t have a consensus on: • How much of the recent warming is caused by fossil fuels? We still don’t know. • Is fossil fuel and is warming dangerous? This is the weakest part of the argument. There’s no agreement as to whether warming is dangerous.” 🔗 You can watch the full 40+ minute interview here:
2:04

The “scientific consensus” talking point was succinctly dismantled by Dr. Judith Curry in her interview with John Stossel back in October. 𝗝𝗼𝗵𝗻 𝗦𝘁𝗼𝘀𝘀𝗲𝗹: “The overwhelming scientific consensus. That’s what people still believe.” 𝗗𝗿. 𝗝𝘂𝗱𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗖𝘂𝗿𝗿𝘆: “. . . when you talk about ‘scientific consensus,’ like the Earth orbits the sun, you don’t need to say ‘There’s a consensus that the Earth orbits the sun,’ it’s a well-known fact. When you’re talking about consensus, it’s usually on a topic where there is disagreement, and a government has asked a group to come to some sort of an agreement on what’s what. You see it in science, you see it in. . . medical boards. . . So, it’s a manufactured consensus. It’s a consensus of scientists, which is different than a scientific consensus. . .” Dr. Curry goes on to explain that there is no consensus on the most contentious issues of climate change, such as extent of human contribution and the impacts. 𝗗𝗿. 𝗝𝘂𝗱𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗖𝘂𝗿𝗿𝘆: “. . . there’s a true scientific consensus on very little of this, you know that, • The temperatures have been increasing for over a hundred years. • That burning of fossil fuels emits CO₂ into the atmosphere. • And, CO₂ has a radiation spectrum that sort of keeps the Earth’s surface warm, all other things being equal. Beyond that, there’s no real big consensus on anything. The most consequential issues we don’t have a consensus on: • How much of the recent warming is caused by fossil fuels? We still don’t know. • Is fossil fuel and is warming dangerous? This is the weakest part of the argument. There’s no agreement as to whether warming is dangerous.” 🔗 You can watch the full 40+ minute interview here:

Chris Martz

112,060 views • 2 years ago

Q: If the consensus candidate emerges within the ADC Coalition, will you step aside in the interest of unity? Atiku: It is not about stepping aside, the first option in coalition is to work out a consensus. If that doesn’t emerge, then we go for direct primaries.
1:15

Q: If the consensus candidate emerges within the ADC Coalition, will you step aside in the interest of unity? Atiku: It is not about stepping aside, the first option in coalition is to work out a consensus. If that doesn’t emerge, then we go for direct primaries.

Imran Muhammad

90,474 views • 3 months ago

Mechanic is back on the show. Softfork Mechanic #BIP-110 talks about BIP110, who controls Bitcoin, spam, using bitcoin as money, the fight for bitcoin's future. Links 👇
1:32:19

Mechanic is back on the show. Softfork Mechanic #BIP-110 talks about BIP110, who controls Bitcoin, spam, using bitcoin as money, the fight for bitcoin's future. Links 👇

Danny Knowles

27,604 views • 2 months ago

Tomorrow, independent developer Super Testnet comes on the show to share why he's proposing a User-Rejected Soft Fork for BIP 110 — and explores the different ways a potential 'soft fork war' could play out around BIP 110 in August. This episode is chockfull of soft-fork history, with insights into how changes to consensus have historically been executed and how these processes could shift going forward.
0:33

Tomorrow, independent developer Super Testnet comes on the show to share why he's proposing a User-Rejected Soft Fork for BIP 110 — and explores the different ways a potential 'soft fork war' could play out around BIP 110 in August. This episode is chockfull of soft-fork history, with insights into how changes to consensus have historically been executed and how these processes could shift going forward.

Isabel Foxen Duke⚡️

17,045 views • 1 month ago

MUST WATCH🚨 "Bitcoin is not physical gold. You can kill Bitcoin." Matthew R. Kratter #BIP-110 on the spam war, Bitcoin Core gone rogue, and BIP-110. This might be the most important Bitcoin interview of the year. The Bitcoin Matrix Podcast ⚡️ #279: Bitcoin Is Under Attack is out on audio now.
0:58

MUST WATCH🚨 "Bitcoin is not physical gold. You can kill Bitcoin." Matthew R. Kratter #BIP-110 on the spam war, Bitcoin Core gone rogue, and BIP-110. This might be the most important Bitcoin interview of the year. The Bitcoin Matrix Podcast ⚡️ #279: Bitcoin Is Under Attack is out on audio now.

Cedric Youngelman ⚡️

44,136 views • 1 month ago

"What matters isn't BIP 110 ... what people really care about isn't spam ... it's can the Bitcoin network get its shit together to defend against quantum" Dave on what people are really worried about beyond the BIP 110 debate "Where is the value, where are people looking? The new narrative on Ethereum is it's a safer network and it'll be quantum resistant and faster" "The narrative on Bitcoin is there's a BIP 110 debate. At the end of the day, and I'm oversimplifying, what matters isn't BIP 110, what matters is the process" "Can the Bitcoin network get its shit together to defend against quantum, and can they defend against theoretical attacks like the one that Duke professor you quoted [51% attack with short perps position] last week talked about"
1:08

"What matters isn't BIP 110 ... what people really care about isn't spam ... it's can the Bitcoin network get its shit together to defend against quantum" Dave on what people are really worried about beyond the BIP 110 debate "Where is the value, where are people looking? The new narrative on Ethereum is it's a safer network and it'll be quantum resistant and faster" "The narrative on Bitcoin is there's a BIP 110 debate. At the end of the day, and I'm oversimplifying, what matters isn't BIP 110, what matters is the process" "Can the Bitcoin network get its shit together to defend against quantum, and can they defend against theoretical attacks like the one that Duke professor you quoted [51% attack with short perps position] last week talked about"

The Wolf Of All Streets

41,038 views • 22 days ago

Forcing protocol changes without real consensus turns #Bitcoin development into FIAT-STYLE politics. "The attitude is one that inevitably leads to some form of authoritarianism." - Jimmy Song (송재준)
1:55

Forcing protocol changes without real consensus turns #Bitcoin development into FIAT-STYLE politics. "The attitude is one that inevitably leads to some form of authoritarianism." - Jimmy Song (송재준)

TFTC

32,126 views • 10 months ago

A climate change consensus used to exist in Britain. It is a shame how much the Conservative Party has changed.
0:24

A climate change consensus used to exist in Britain. It is a shame how much the Conservative Party has changed.

Dr. Jeevun Sandher MP

83,384 views • 8 months ago

Is #bitcoin spam an ideological issue? "This is a practical matter... If blockspace is mostly being used up by junk we need to do something about it." - Softfork Mechanic #BIP-110
1:18

Is #bitcoin spam an ideological issue? "This is a practical matter... If blockspace is mostly being used up by junk we need to do something about it." - Softfork Mechanic #BIP-110

TFTC

53,858 views • 1 year ago

There is consensus among AI systems about the best form of money for the Age of Digital Intelligence:
1:55

There is consensus among AI systems about the best form of money for the Age of Digital Intelligence:

Natalie Brunell ⚡️

39,698 views • 5 months ago

Consensus Begins with The President Choosing People He Can Control — Otubanjo There are no democratic parties in Nigeria. Obasanjo was the only president who thought of his party and I give that to him. It is a waste of time talking about consensus, because consensus is not important and they can always win by dominating the convention with their people. The governors have autocratic powers. Prof. Femi Otubanjo, Research Professor of Intl. Relations & Strategic Studies, Nigerian Institute of Intl Affairs
6:11

Consensus Begins with The President Choosing People He Can Control — Otubanjo There are no democratic parties in Nigeria. Obasanjo was the only president who thought of his party and I give that to him. It is a waste of time talking about consensus, because consensus is not important and they can always win by dominating the convention with their people. The governors have autocratic powers. Prof. Femi Otubanjo, Research Professor of Intl. Relations & Strategic Studies, Nigerian Institute of Intl Affairs

ARISE NEWS

37,876 views • 2 months ago

Is Bitcoin Still The Most Asymmetric Bet Of The Next Decade? Consensus 2026 is a wrap & it made the answer to that question very clear!
4:40

Is Bitcoin Still The Most Asymmetric Bet Of The Next Decade? Consensus 2026 is a wrap & it made the answer to that question very clear!

The Wolf Of All Streets

42,832 views • 2 months ago

🥼 Trust the Experts The New York Times ran a hit piece against Trump energy appointees for doubting "the consensus“ on climate change. But "the consensus" is often just politically driven agenda intended to give the left more power over our lives.
2:56

🥼 Trust the Experts The New York Times ran a hit piece against Trump energy appointees for doubting "the consensus“ on climate change. But "the consensus" is often just politically driven agenda intended to give the left more power over our lives.

10 Minute Drill

100,113 views • 1 year ago