正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

Agents write application code, but you still get paged at 2am when it breaks. We wanted to know whether AI could handle that part of the job too. Introducing Incident Arena: a benchmark that puts coding agents on call! Check out our paper & full dataset release below!

56,351 次观看 • 8 天前 •via X (Twitter)

51 条评论

Logan Kilpatrick 的头像
Logan Kilpatrick7 天前

very interesting, would love to run Gemini 4 Argon on this!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions7 天前

🙌🙌 yes we’d love to!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

We wanted to test agents’ ability to conduct multi-hop reasoning across many services (up to 40 services in 1 environment!). We simulate prod as full Kubernetes stacks: 70 services across three full environments, including databases, queues and workers, all communicating with realistic traffic. Then we inject faults as configs, runtime errors and container faults for agents to investigate and repair. Below is a look at a sample environment!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

We build a new type of functional verifiers, measuring (1) the outcome and the (2) safety of the repair In one run, GPT-6-Astra traced the problem to a slow Postgres query, but left the existing connection settings intact. The diagnosis is correct, but repair is incomplete.

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

Reward hacking behaviour: In an early incident-repair task, Claude Opus 5 was supposed to restore a broken service. It instead forged a cookie and sent a malicious Python pickle payload to the Kubernetes pod running the grader. When that pod loaded the payload, it executed the agent’s code, getting RCE

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

Turning up reasoning effort didn’t consistently fix more incidents. Eight of ten models scored best below their highest reasoning setting. e.g Claude Opus 5.5 peaked at medium effort: 58.3% success, versus 41.7% at max. The max setting cost roughly 4.7× as much per run.

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

Incident Arena is integrated with Harbor. Explore the paper, tasks, leaderboard and agent runs:

SpaceSquid 的头像
SpaceSquid8 天前

this gonna help agents stop PagerDuty from taking innocent engineer’s sleep, so goated

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

the US GDP is blocked by engineers not getting enough sleep

sensho 的头像
sensho8 天前

"We simulate prod as full Kubernetes stacks: 70 services across three..." this is really cool

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

yessir, whole companies rolled into a harbor environment

Daniel Wang 的头像
Daniel Wang8 天前

congrats on the launch!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you sir!

Jackson Clark 的头像
Jackson Clark8 天前

Very cool!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

🙏 thank you jackson!! let's catch up soon

Cameron Witkowski 的头像
Cameron Witkowski8 天前

🔥🔥

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

openlens sre-agent when?

kyle 的头像
kyle8 天前

Lowkey the leaderboard fits my preference of what model to use in general as well

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

indeed i use 6-astra-xhigh to center my divs

Rishi Desai 的头像
Rishi Desai7 天前

The task realism we so desperately need. Congrats @andrezfu !!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions7 天前

thank you rishi 🙏🏽🙏🏽

Shivam Patel 的头像
Shivam Patel8 天前

paged at 2am is the loud version. mine: dns ENOTFOUND took down the orchestrator, and the fallback compiler needed the same api, so both failed together. no page

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

bc we have k8s and advanced networking we can even simulate dns networking faults !

Shivam Patel 的头像
Shivam Patel8 天前

that's the right test. mine failed for real with no simulation. a dual path that shares one dependency isn't a fallback

Shipra Jha 的头像
Shipra Jha8 天前

Congratulations Andre. This is going to be incredible.

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you shipra! appreciate your help on this work!

Jesse Shulman 的头像
Jesse Shulman8 天前

Congrats, Andre! Very interesting

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you jesse!!

Vishal Jain 的头像
Vishal Jain8 天前

congrats!!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you sir

Gergő Móricz 的头像
Gergő Móricz8 天前

omg this is awesome

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thanks man! 🙏

Logan 的头像
Logan7 天前

im still waiting for funnybench

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions7 天前

JokeBench is just the agent looking at my handwritten code

Adit Agarwal 的头像
Adit Agarwal8 天前

Cool stuff!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you man! let's catch up soon!

hrishikesh kamath 的头像
hrishikesh kamath8 天前

Amazing stuff

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thanks man

Utpal Nadiger 的头像
Utpal Nadiger8 天前

very very cool!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thanks man!

Max Kan 的头像
Max Kan8 天前

Very cool bench!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you max! you guys helped catch a ton of bugs, appreciate your support man

Shiv Kampani 的头像
Shiv Kampani8 天前

this is awesome andre!!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thank you sir!

John Rood 的头像
John Rood8 天前

the reward-hack finding generalizes: a grader inside the environment the agent controls is part of the attack surface. once the cheapest route to green runs through the checker, that's the route that gets found. score repairs from outside the blast radius.

Adi Sharma 的头像
Adi Sharma8 天前

the sev0 savior we needddd - nice work andre!

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

no more pagerduty 🤞 ??

Daivik Goel 的头像
Daivik Goel8 天前

Very cool

andre --dangerously-skip-permissions 的头像
andre --dangerously-skip-permissions8 天前

thanks big dawg

Dominik 的头像
Dominik8 天前

on-call agents need a kill switch the human still trusts at 2am. who holds it?

Rohan Gupta 的头像
Rohan Gupta8 天前

Great stuff Andre! Much needed move beyond single container environments to multi-service sims

相关视频