Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
An explanation for why modern games stopped using transparency and started using dithering.
618,188 views • 8 months ago •via X (Twitter)
35 Comments

I prefer transparency anyway. I play on lower graphical settings and being forced to deal with dithering just makes it look so much worse (looking at you Age of Wonders 4)

I agree. I find dithering always breaks immersion for me

I think dithering is good for when an object's not actually transparent but the game's letting you see through it for convenience. An unnatural effect for an unnatural ability.

heheheheheh amogus

That's not a bad explanation. I can expand it by saying draw order has largely been solved, but the performance hasn't. While you miss out on a lot of color and distortion effects doing this checkerboard effect, the performance (especially on low-power hardware) is worth it.

modern games avoid transparency because most engines use deferred renderers, which compute final colors after geometry info (normals, albedo) are rendered

What's also interesting in the case for Pokopia is that it also still uses dithering, mainly for objects that get close to the camera like trees. My other assumption is that it also just alleviates the bandwidth stress you'd normally get from alpha effects filling the screen.

Anyone curious about this subject, I reccomend reading through this article. The Dreamcast early on had hardware transparency solutions, which proceeded to break in every remake of Sonic Adventure

I love how the only game that can do transparency correctly is Sonic Adventure for the Sega Dreamcast, sega was ahead of the time :tr:

@harryamoros Theres a better example

It’s not just about effects. Transparency is WAY more expensive than dithering. Also, fading an object over time through dithering rather than transparency creates a sand-like fading look. So it can even make “broken crates fades” effects look better.

You know what? I was wondering about that just the other day. Thank you.

I'm playing DK Bananza and I absolute *hate* the dithering effect they use. It's just ugly and distracting.

In this case specifically, its not transparency sorting. Its more to do with depth writing. Transparent pixels generally don't write depth value. The cube is writing depth to cull the internal faces, causing the pixels of the particles to be discarded.

I hate dithering, it looks so distracting and low res. I miss when close up objects just turned invisible or clear, no speckled dots...

I'm pretty sure this is because most rendering solutions nowadays use "deferred rendering" instead of "forward rendering", with the former style making transparency bad in performance.

This is a problem with render queue. This can be fixed easily. This has been fixed years ago in Half-Life's Alpha build. Ensuring your render queue is set up correctly is crucial. Alternatively, you can use render setups such as Additive, or Multiply.

How would it look in dithering I don’t understand

Donkey Kong Bananaza is a great example of dithering looking horrible. 90% of the time you are looking at DK though objects and it just is a dithered mess.

Dithering is basically a cheat, you keep the object in the opaque pass so it behaves nicely with depth and lighting, punch tiny holes in it with a pattern, then let upscalers smear that into something that looks like transparency without paying the full cost.

love that i can still learn things about gaming like this

well whats the explanation? am i looking at dithering or transparency? what was supposed to happen, genuinely annoyed how many people are acting like this is obvious?

Dithering is less taxing then transparency

Oh so dithering is why we can't see close details of characters in games? i never knew until now never knew until i searched what dithering was after seeing this, and im talking about actual details not just looking at panties xD that i know someone will comment

Is that MIKE FUCKING JONES!?!?

render layers are a pain in the ass

Is more optimze not to show some pixel than doing transparency switch have game using that like mh rise to get better performance like other games

Like Saturn in high res

I hate dithering so much

Actually, transparency is just more expensive than dithering. The GPU handles z-sorting, so it’s not about drawing order, just an optimization issue. Many post-processing effects are done in a separate pass, so transparency breaks those effects. BOTW is a good example of this

It's because of deferred rendering. Where you computer the final shaded colours after rendering all the geometry information to a myriad of buffers. The issue is that one can't store two different samples of surface info in a single pixel which would be the case for transparenty

Forward vs. Deferred rendering. Deferred saves on complex lightning equattions but you lose the ability to make stuff translucent at will. Translu (alpha blend) will return when the industry adopts Forward+.

Of course you can stack transparent objects, this info is incorrect either that transparent object is set up incorrectly, drawing to the depth buffer and not allowing other transparencies to draw, or is not really transparent and it copies the screen texture before transparents

Skill issue TBH, just throw your translucent pipelines to their own framebuffers

Render queue, my beloathed </3

