正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

Been asked what's the difference between Brilliant & Paper and why either would be chosen over Figma. I'll start by saying Paper is an excellent tool and a great choice (not trying to be politically correct, but genuine appreciation for their craft and effort. Building a design tool is...

12,979 次观看 • 20 天前 •via X (Twitter)

33 条评论

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Paper: Agents generate HTML/CSS. The canvas is DOM-based. Therefore: high automation using AI (agents know HTML/CSS very well), limited manual editing functionality.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

This isn't true only for Paper. Looking at Google Stitch, Claude design, Lovable, Base44 and every other HTML/CSS based canvas - it's very hard to have full professional depth when the underlying substrate is DOM-based. Not only because in some of the tools you're looking at a website, but there's a mathematical ceiling in each of these tools based on the tech stack they chose.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

So HTML/CSS based canvases - incredible for agents, but have a hard time becoming a full blown editor.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Figma: Full manual control, professional depth. Everything needed to imagine and iterate on what a product should look like. But - proprietary file format, hard for agents to natively work on and reason about. Was also built starting 2012 without agents in mind.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Therefore, figma: High manual editing control, limited AI control

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Brilliant: A professional vector design tool similar to Figma. Full manual control and the professional depth needed to imagine what a product will look like. Design systems, components, auto layout, vector networks, boolean ops etc.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Similar to Figma it has a highly performant GPU-native rendering engine and can handle real-world canvases of 100K+ elements.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

But unlike Figma, Brilliant is built from scratch around Blueprint, a lossless language for design, tailored for agents (

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Agents read and write blueprint, and from their POV it's like a super concise, highly expressive version of HTML/CSS (video below is not sped up)

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

It's actually more than that: The file format itself is blueprint (plain text .bl files) and even the rust wgpu rendering engine takes in blueprint which means you can have plain text blueprint design "blocks" in markdown. You can see an example of this here:

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

So Brilliant: Full manual control, professional depth AND high automation using AI

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Also, the entire editor is free, unlimited MCP requests, and supports using your existing Anthropic, OpenAI, Cursor subs plus BYOK for any OpenAI-compatible AI provider. you can also try it, in the browser, without signing up here:

Crypto Español 的头像
Crypto Español20 天前

fully sold in :)

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Objectively, it's amazing :)

Anton Anisimov 的头像
Anton Anisimov20 天前

This is very impressive... Love it!

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Thank you! drop any feedback you have via cmd+k "Send Feedback" or just ask your agent

Andu 的头像
Andu20 天前

If performance matters (nice video), note this is lagging -

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

Thanks for this! Our agent fleet is already on this, trying to reproduce. Care sharing what browser/os you're using?

Andu 的头像
Andu20 天前

Latest Chrome / Mac OS.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

thanks! please send anything else you see my way

Luca 的头像
Luca20 天前

Amazingg

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

YOU are amazing

Luca 的头像
Luca20 天前

<3

Amalgama 的头像
Amalgama20 天前

I agree with this the thing is is why I am going to use this if there is already something like @penpotapp that is literally infinity customizable and actually get updated for free, I understand the performance but actually agents are going to be moving 70% of the work in any design software. I just don't see, apart from convince, how is this adding to the scene in the long run, I actually like the product that you develop but I don't see it been adopted. I think your breakthrough on Dom base canvas and other things is amazing and I want you to win, but as someone that is working with Ai it's just crazy that I can open my ai harness tell it what I want and I can set up the use of penpot as a tool and just make insane presentations or anything pretty much, all local,self hosted and most importantly managed by the harness.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

thank you! Penpot is also excellent and love their vision and thesis In case you missed it - Brilliant is (and will always be) Free. You can run it locally, offline, with your own AI sub to Antrhopic, OpenAI, and Cursor, or an API key to those plus Google, OpenRouter and any OpenAI-compatible provider. You can learn more about our thesis here if you're interested:

Amalgama 的头像
Amalgama19 天前

@penpotapp Amazing going to try it out and see if I can get brilliant to work on the workflows that I have already. Thank you for taking the time to make this clear. Will send feedback.

Athena Prime 的头像
Athena Prime20 天前

Interesting how the visual comparison turns implementation details into a clear design tradeoff.

Danila Poyarkov 的头像
Danila Poyarkov19 天前

👀

dotSQUARE 的头像
dotSQUARE19 天前

Just downloaded it. On the desktop version for windows, when hovering over Rectangle the "T" icon moves to the left and looses one pixel on the left! Super annoying! Other than that, awesome experience. Just told claude to recreate my web project. Did it!

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband19 天前

Oh really! On it. Throw any other feedback you have my way

dotSQUARE 的头像
dotSQUARE19 天前

Yeah I DMd you.. But somehow can't send you screenshots there.. Probably you have to answer me first.

Daniel Brassnyo 的头像
Daniel Brassnyo20 天前

I've been using Brilliant, Pen (formerly Pencil), and paper in parallel to find my go-to agentic design tool. That said, my team and I still use Figma for documentation and as a source of truth. What I miss in all three products is a way to export designs back to Figma without friction. I understand from a business standpoint why they only offer import, but from a UX standpoint I think it's a miss. At the end of the day I'll still use the product for 99% of the work and pay for the subscription. Why lock the user into another ecosystem 🤷‍♂️ Btw I'm curious about your take on @pendev.

Amichai Mantinband 的头像
Amichai Mantinband20 天前

@usebrilliant Have you tried right click -> send to figma? NOT locking you in is kind of our thing :) As someone who's been using all three, I'd love to hear your thoughts and where you think we can improve

相关视频