Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
City governments: Forcing ground-floor retail upon housing developers is a lose-lose for all.
59,841 views • 10 months ago •via X (Twitter)
47 Comments

tulsa city gov should note this lesson

Disagree from tenant perspective. It’s great to have a Trader Joe, Vonns, or Barry’s/Equinox on the ground floor. Makes the area far more walkable

Trader Joe’s isn’t taking these sites I think you are misunderstanding

Ok. Walk me through it. I’m open to changing my mind

This one up the road has a Vonns & Equinox on the ground floor.

@realEstateTrent Lincoln gets a lot of foot traffic. Amara has empty ground floor space, and so does the Charlie I believe. Trent is pointing out B locations with subpar foot traffic and parking.

@realEstateTrent Understood

Bottom floor has to be flexible and allow housing when that is what the market calls for and commercial when the market calls for. In orders for buildings to survive long term they must be adaptable.

they need to lower rent to bring in useful businesses to ground floor. Mainly groceries or market or coffee or restaurant. Problem is they give it to random biz like dentist or dog grooming. Some businesses need to be at the mall or plaza, under apt should only be everyday biz

The rent has nothing to do with it. Even at zero rent it makes no sense

10000% - I agree. We have wayyyyy too many storefronts and people willing to rent to anyone.

Do you believe this to be true even in higher density areas already or are you referring to markets that are heavy commuter and heavy vehicle traffic already?

Ground floor retail works great where there’s high density and people are walking around all over the place

How about high density areas but on corridors that are highly vehicular traffic currently… I’m speaking as a Santa Monica resident and we have exactly what you are talking about being built everywhere

Good breakdown!

Thank you.

it is so obvious

The only place this works is in large cities where you get that foot traffic. It's rare. They're doing in the suburbs and it's insane and they want $35-40/ft

we live for underutilized ground floor retail. if you're a LL suffering from this.. DM me. we will swoop up your un-leasable spaces. it works extraordinarily well for our dog daycare biz.

Ironically the space occupied by retail is probably better off just being parking

should let the developer include housing on the ground floor in areas where retail simply does not work. how many housing units are being prevented from being built each year? what a waste. what a lose-lose

This is where I have landed as a compromise for now and the future.

I literally went off on this diatribe yesterday. If the planners who dream this stuff up would check the occupancy requirements *posted on many national retailers websites * and contrast them with conditions on the ground… build it and they will come works if you build right

Great point!

totally agree

Just another example of the government trying to step in to a space they have no clue how to effectively and efficiently operate in.

Trouble is non-retail people simply do not understand how many people it takes to support a retail store. They think a few hundred apartments will make the retail successful.

yes, outside of big cities it's dumb, since most people would need cars to access it. But works extremely well in large cities. But this all boils down to how badly we have screwed up urban design in general.

City governments should be going the other way - incentivizing the conversion of vacant retail into residential

Surrounded by them, especially ones across from strips are insane. Seen any developers subsidize or partner with an operator that they want to bring in. Akin to the restaurant in a hotel I’d imagine.

Lol, this might be the dumbest urban planning take I’ve ever heard. Strip mall guy can’t imagine a reality that isn’t about cars and parking lots. Bro, touch grass, travel to Europe or Manhattan 🤦♂️

Trent is right I use to live across the street to 5 retail stores above an apartment which opened and closed within 1-2 years Eye sores and vacant 50% of the time.

I bet those are nearly all federal incentivized “neighborhood investment districts”. Government always wants to play developer, yet they have no experience and risk no capital. Shorewood, Wisconsin @ShorewoodWis did the same kind of bullshit. They wouldn’t allow anyone to build over 2-3 floors, then they would buy a building, fund it with TIF, sell it for a $1 and THEN allow 5+ story buildings. They killed the benefit for the citizens of the village. Those buildings will never contribute to the tax rolls more than they did as a shitty 1-2 story retail bldg. @ShorewoodWis will have to continuously sell TIF bonds and the property taxes of residents will continue to skyrocket for decades. All because the village idiots (board) think they are developers. The easy solution would have been to change the bldg codes to allow 6+ story construction, the current owners sell at market value, developer buys and builds 6+ story apt, pays the SAME EXACT TAXES as under the TIF bond, except instead of the extra going to pay off the bond, the money goes to lower the property taxes of all property owners in the Village. Instead of a 5-6X increase in property taxes in @ShorewoodWis over last 25 years, residents would have had experienced less than 1/2 the increase or more all funded by free market new construction with no risk of any bond defaults. The village board of idiots never told the residents about the risk of defaults and what it would cost. Ask the residents who funded TIFs for Kohls.

Every city planner thinks they can turn their downtown or some random street into a "dense, urban, walkable community" if they just force developers to build ground floor retail. Here in Albuquerque it's always vacant. One exception was in a large new infill building where they made a space large enough for a grocery store and had some parking. Maybe you could get away with a single 500 SF space for a coffee shop but when they try to get multiple suites they always sit empty or rotate through a bunch of failed businesses. Let the market decides what it needs and wants, not city planners with visions of urban utopia.

This was not obvious to me before. Thanks you.

I guess if you think about it, most areas in Europe and other places that have walkable boulevards, it's a couple of main areas, and the rest is actually residential on the ground level. Do you think they should designate several key boulevards as having to have retail space? Or they shouldn't have any regulation at all? Or possibly simply allow residential ground floor space to be easily rezoned to commercial.

This is a complex issue and you don’t do it justice. We created car dependent cities via regulation that created this mess and so yes just doing ground floor retail isn’t going to fix the problem. It has to be part of a larger strategy to add transit, zoning reform, bike and pedestrian infrastructure. I think a bridge from where we are to where cities are trying to go, would be to require ground units to be built in way that allows for easy conversion to retail, such as ceilings higher than typical units. Then when demand develops, landlords can convert some space without major and cost prohibitive construction.

Welcome Back! Happy New Vlog😄

Ugh. Please don’t use cartoon overlays on top of your face while you are talking. Your audience can understand words alone. Great video otherwise.

I do the best I can. Just doing these on the fly. Sorry.

Such inteligent comments. Too bad more people do not understand this

Agree w post but what about the chicken egg argument (i.e. foot traffic happens if an area achieves critical mass)? Why not make ground floor frontages flexible spaces which can be resi, office or retail depending on stage of neighborhood submarket? Idealist or smart?

💯

Hey! I reached out to you on LinkedIn

Typical. The municipalties often tequire stupid things. Not just retail, but other sorys of projects that make no sense. They crave tax dollars and think it works everywhere.

If you put live work space on the bottom it can be dual use. Think 2-400sf street facing and then 600-800sf 1 bed behind Owner operators like photographers accountants designers etc would love to have small space for seeing clients and doing work. Worst case sublease desks

In golf, they call this a Low percentage shot In football, they caught a Hail Mary


!["Must win... if [Man] City lose I think it's all over" Micah Richards says it is a league-defining weekend in the Premier League 😮](https://image.24vids.com/tw-2020484609230639163/media/HAo0BsiWMAAAp51.jpg)