Video yükleniyor...

Video Yüklenemedi

Bu video yüklenirken bir sorun oluştu. Bu geçici bir ağ sorunundan kaynaklanıyor olabilir veya video kullanılamıyor olabilir.

Ana Sayfaya Dön

Everyone supporting Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 should remember that the process is already tainted by these actions of busing people, as happened in Bulawayo. The consultation for Bulawayo was meant for residents of Bulawayo, not for imported crowds designed to manufacture consent. Zimbabwe will remain trapped in a... show more

Hopewell Chin’ono

887,439 subscribers

74,631 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce •via X (Twitter)

Komedi Haberler & Politika Eğitim

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Yorum

Yorum bulunmuyor

Orijinal gönderinin yorumları burada görünecek

Benzer Videolar

🗣️Gift Ostallos: “We reject the bill in its entirety as the people of Bulawayo and as the people of Zimbabwe.” He further calls the process “fraud” and calls for a referendum that includes all citizens. #NketaHall

🗣️Gift Ostallos: “We reject the bill in its entirety as the people of Bulawayo and as the people of Zimbabwe.” He further calls the process “fraud” and calls for a referendum that includes all citizens. #NketaHall

Protect Defenders Zw

51,731 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce

The violence against Zimbabwean human rights lawyer Doug Coltart today at the parliamentary hearings for Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 at the Harare City Sports Centre is disgraceful. The racist abuse directed at him by fellow Zimbabweans is equally shameful, exposing a dangerous erosion of tolerance, respect for the rule of law, and basic democratic values. Whatever happens with Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3, it is already tainted by these actions of ZANUPF hooligans, thugs, and despicable individuals. You cannot take parliamentary hearings to the people and then assault them for airing their views, for opposing what you are saying, or for holding alternative opinions. That is not consultation, it is intimidation, and it completely undermines the legitimacy of the entire process. Beating up a fellow Zimbabwean who is a lawyer, stealing his phone, and preventing him from speaking is the very worst conduct in any parliamentary hearing process, including this Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3. Those behind these actions should be deeply ashamed, because they are not only undermining the process, they are embarrassing the country and eroding respect for the rule of law.

The violence against Zimbabwean human rights lawyer Doug Coltart today at the parliamentary hearings for Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 at the Harare City Sports Centre is disgraceful. The racist abuse directed at him by fellow Zimbabweans is equally shameful, exposing a dangerous erosion of tolerance, respect for the rule of law, and basic democratic values. Whatever happens with Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3, it is already tainted by these actions of ZANUPF hooligans, thugs, and despicable individuals. You cannot take parliamentary hearings to the people and then assault them for airing their views, for opposing what you are saying, or for holding alternative opinions. That is not consultation, it is intimidation, and it completely undermines the legitimacy of the entire process. Beating up a fellow Zimbabwean who is a lawyer, stealing his phone, and preventing him from speaking is the very worst conduct in any parliamentary hearing process, including this Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3. Those behind these actions should be deeply ashamed, because they are not only undermining the process, they are embarrassing the country and eroding respect for the rule of law.

Hopewell Chin’ono

52,094 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce

Most of the beautiful white people who were born in Bulawayo Zimbabwe can speak Ndebele language fluently except for Shona people who think that they are special

Most of the beautiful white people who were born in Bulawayo Zimbabwe can speak Ndebele language fluently except for Shona people who think that they are special

Mthwakazi independence

16,748 görüntüleme • 8 ay önce

I have just listened to this video by the new Bulawayo Mayor, David Coltart, I like what I heard. Bulawayo has a real chance for turning around with this mindset of zero tolerance to corruption, craft competence and unity. He must be supported by the Bulawayo community, all of it! Through his previous record as a GNU minister, he will be able to attract international support for Bulawayo. David will not mourn about ZANUPF, he is a good example of a person who will try until stopped, he did that as a GNU minister. You are in for good times Bulawayo, where he is frustrated, the citizens must stand with their mayor. I like his broad based message of working with everyone and not treating his work in partisan ways.

I have just listened to this video by the new Bulawayo Mayor, David Coltart, I like what I heard. Bulawayo has a real chance for turning around with this mindset of zero tolerance to corruption, craft competence and unity. He must be supported by the Bulawayo community, all of it! Through his previous record as a GNU minister, he will be able to attract international support for Bulawayo. David will not mourn about ZANUPF, he is a good example of a person who will try until stopped, he did that as a GNU minister. You are in for good times Bulawayo, where he is frustrated, the citizens must stand with their mayor. I like his broad based message of working with everyone and not treating his work in partisan ways.

Hopewell Chin’ono

131,268 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

#ZimElection2023 DAVID COLTART: BORN 66 YEARS AGO IN BULAWAYO, PRACTICED LAW IN BULAWAYO FOR 40 YEARS, STILL CAN’T SPEAK SINDEBELE, CALLS THE CITY OF KINGS & QUEENS ‘BHULUWEYO” YET CHAMISA WANTS TO IMPOSE HIM AS MAYOR David Coltart has been promised Bulawayo’s Mayoral position by the leader of Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC), Nelson Chamisa, reports New Zimbabwe.Com: The promise is based on the wish that Chamisa’s CCC will win most of Bulawayo’s 29 council seats and that the elected councillors will obey Chamisa’s orders in the vote for mayor. Although Coltart came a distant number last, after he was heavily defeated in the CCC ‘community caucus’ candidate selection for Ward 4 in Bulawayo, Chamisa imposed him as the winner, ahead of the real winnera, as Harare’s choice for Bulawayo mayor. Chamisa used CCC’s Bulawayo rally two days ago on Sunday to make public his handpicking of Coltart as his Bulawayo mayoral choice. This is raising eyebrows not least because it's the Bulawayo community - not Chamisa or his Harare cohort - which must choose its Mayor through its elected councillors. Besides, why is Chamisa bent on singling out Bulawayo, and imposing a mayor there? Unconcerned that this is irreparrably damaging his claims to be a democrat, and speaking as if he thinks he would be an Executive Mayor, Coltart thundered at the Sunday rally: “I have been a lawyer in this city for 40 years. I want to use my 40 years experience as a lawyer to review all the contracts in Bhuluweyo, to see whether they are in the interests of the citizens of Bhuluweyo, if we find the contracts are not in the interests of Bhuluweyo...,” to Chamisa's amusement. It is outrageous for Coltart to think he can be the mayor of a local community whose language he does not speak, despite having been born there 66 years ago and having worked there as a lawyer for 40 years. The best he can do is to pronounce 'Bulawayo' as 'Bhuluweyo', just like the Rhodies pronounced it 43 years ago. Hayikhona!

#ZimElection2023 DAVID COLTART: BORN 66 YEARS AGO IN BULAWAYO, PRACTICED LAW IN BULAWAYO FOR 40 YEARS, STILL CAN’T SPEAK SINDEBELE, CALLS THE CITY OF KINGS & QUEENS ‘BHULUWEYO” YET CHAMISA WANTS TO IMPOSE HIM AS MAYOR David Coltart has been promised Bulawayo’s Mayoral position by the leader of Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC), Nelson Chamisa, reports New Zimbabwe.Com: The promise is based on the wish that Chamisa’s CCC will win most of Bulawayo’s 29 council seats and that the elected councillors will obey Chamisa’s orders in the vote for mayor. Although Coltart came a distant number last, after he was heavily defeated in the CCC ‘community caucus’ candidate selection for Ward 4 in Bulawayo, Chamisa imposed him as the winner, ahead of the real winnera, as Harare’s choice for Bulawayo mayor. Chamisa used CCC’s Bulawayo rally two days ago on Sunday to make public his handpicking of Coltart as his Bulawayo mayoral choice. This is raising eyebrows not least because it's the Bulawayo community - not Chamisa or his Harare cohort - which must choose its Mayor through its elected councillors. Besides, why is Chamisa bent on singling out Bulawayo, and imposing a mayor there? Unconcerned that this is irreparrably damaging his claims to be a democrat, and speaking as if he thinks he would be an Executive Mayor, Coltart thundered at the Sunday rally: “I have been a lawyer in this city for 40 years. I want to use my 40 years experience as a lawyer to review all the contracts in Bhuluweyo, to see whether they are in the interests of the citizens of Bhuluweyo, if we find the contracts are not in the interests of Bhuluweyo...,” to Chamisa's amusement. It is outrageous for Coltart to think he can be the mayor of a local community whose language he does not speak, despite having been born there 66 years ago and having worked there as a lawyer for 40 years. The best he can do is to pronounce 'Bulawayo' as 'Bhuluweyo', just like the Rhodies pronounced it 43 years ago. Hayikhona!

Prof Jonathan Moyo

129,056 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce

Here is a SOLID argument for ED2030. The MOST CONSEQUENTIAL project implemented by President President of Zimbabwe is the Gwayi - Shangani dam. This dam will COMPLETELY transform the fortunes of Matabeleland North & Bulawayo province. According to Engineers onsite, it’s 74% complete! They all upbeat about completing the project this year. For me, it’s the massive irrigation potential that it will unlock & the permanent eradication of water shortages in Bulawayo. ED can be President until 2030, he knows what he is doing.

Here is a SOLID argument for ED2030. The MOST CONSEQUENTIAL project implemented by President President of Zimbabwe is the Gwayi - Shangani dam. This dam will COMPLETELY transform the fortunes of Matabeleland North & Bulawayo province. According to Engineers onsite, it’s 74% complete! They all upbeat about completing the project this year. For me, it’s the massive irrigation potential that it will unlock & the permanent eradication of water shortages in Bulawayo. ED can be President until 2030, he knows what he is doing.

𝑲𝒖𝒅𝒛𝒂𝒊 𝑴𝒖𝒕𝒊𝒔𝒊

10,816 görüntüleme • 6 ay önce

In Bulawayo CBD it is not business as usual. Most buildings are closed. This is a win for us ordinary people. We sent a message to the government. ZANU PF must go. No vision 2030. No third term business. No amendment of the constitution. Its our right to peacefully demonstrate!

In Bulawayo CBD it is not business as usual. Most buildings are closed. This is a win for us ordinary people. We sent a message to the government. ZANU PF must go. No vision 2030. No third term business. No amendment of the constitution. Its our right to peacefully demonstrate!

MaZwangendaba

167,334 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

My recent visit to Cowdray Park, Bulawayo, for the inauguration of the Presidential Borehole Drilling Scheme, served as a poignant reminder that sustainable development must rise above the fray of partisan polarization. Development is, by its very nature, an apolitical endeavor that demands absolute national solidarity. It is this spirit of collective advancement that underpins CAB3, signaling a transformative epoch in the acceleration of Zimbabwe's developmental trajectory. This imperative for unity was underscored by Bulawayo Deputy Mayor Cllr Edwin Ndlovu, who lauded President ED Mnangagwa's efforts in bridging political divides. In tandem, ZANU-PF Bulawayo Provincial Chairman Cde J. Sibanda implored the citizenry of Bulawayo to coalesce around the President's overarching vision for a prosperous future. #CAB3 #Vision2030

My recent visit to Cowdray Park, Bulawayo, for the inauguration of the Presidential Borehole Drilling Scheme, served as a poignant reminder that sustainable development must rise above the fray of partisan polarization. Development is, by its very nature, an apolitical endeavor that demands absolute national solidarity. It is this spirit of collective advancement that underpins CAB3, signaling a transformative epoch in the acceleration of Zimbabwe's developmental trajectory. This imperative for unity was underscored by Bulawayo Deputy Mayor Cllr Edwin Ndlovu, who lauded President ED Mnangagwa's efforts in bridging political divides. In tandem, ZANU-PF Bulawayo Provincial Chairman Cde J. Sibanda implored the citizenry of Bulawayo to coalesce around the President's overarching vision for a prosperous future. #CAB3 #Vision2030

Dr P Tungwarara, Presidential Advisor

41,365 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce

🎙️#CCCPresser: We are also aware of the current fraudulent voter transfer activity which is being instigated by ZANU PF. • We are aware of the systematic and irregular transfers of voters from rural areas into urban areas being done by ZanuPF, packing them in targeted wards and constituencies more particularly in Harare, Masvingo and Bulawayo. • Security personnel are also manipulated into transferring their votes to specified areas as is in the case with the over 2,000 military recruits in Bulawayo. • Bulawayo City vendors for example have been forced to transfer to Bulawayo CBD using fake addresses. • The above evidence is clear testimony that ZanuPF is embarking on command voting in order to forcefully influence the voting behavior of these affected voters. We remind them that these shenanigans will not work because the citizens are fed up with the corruption and misgovernance under this administration.

🎙️#CCCPresser: We are also aware of the current fraudulent voter transfer activity which is being instigated by ZANU PF. • We are aware of the systematic and irregular transfers of voters from rural areas into urban areas being done by ZanuPF, packing them in targeted wards and constituencies more particularly in Harare, Masvingo and Bulawayo. • Security personnel are also manipulated into transferring their votes to specified areas as is in the case with the over 2,000 military recruits in Bulawayo. • Bulawayo City vendors for example have been forced to transfer to Bulawayo CBD using fake addresses. • The above evidence is clear testimony that ZanuPF is embarking on command voting in order to forcefully influence the voting behavior of these affected voters. We remind them that these shenanigans will not work because the citizens are fed up with the corruption and misgovernance under this administration.

Citizens' Coalition for Change

16,565 görüntüleme • 3 yıl önce

"Why is our President scared of the five-year term? He wants to build an empire—an empire of the Mnangagwas." — A war veteran speaking after the Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 hearing at City Hall in Bulawayo. #CAB3 #ConstitutionAmendmentBill3 #NoToAgenda2030 Open Parly ZW

"Why is our President scared of the five-year term? He wants to build an empire—an empire of the Mnangagwas." — A war veteran speaking after the Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 hearing at City Hall in Bulawayo. #CAB3 #ConstitutionAmendmentBill3 #NoToAgenda2030 Open Parly ZW

OpenCouncilZW

20,101 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce

Bulawayo Mayor David Coltart announced that The City of Bulawayo has decided to honor the legacy of Pathisa Nyathi by naming a street after him. This gesture is intended to ensure that his contributions to culture and history will be remembered for generations to come. #Asakhe

Bulawayo Mayor David Coltart announced that The City of Bulawayo has decided to honor the legacy of Pathisa Nyathi by naming a street after him. This gesture is intended to ensure that his contributions to culture and history will be remembered for generations to come. #Asakhe

CITE

30,082 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

Finally, David Coltart Mayor of Bulawayo has been given an opportunity to speak, he says absolute power corrupts absolutely, there is no separation of power and this bill gives the president too much power in appointing judges,....and Chiefs cant be partisan. I was elected by 86% of the Bulawayo people but i must not serve more than my term, its a moral and honourable thing to do! The extension of the term limit contravenes section 328 as this calls for a referendum first. source CITE

Finally, David Coltart Mayor of Bulawayo has been given an opportunity to speak, he says absolute power corrupts absolutely, there is no separation of power and this bill gives the president too much power in appointing judges,....and Chiefs cant be partisan. I was elected by 86% of the Bulawayo people but i must not serve more than my term, its a moral and honourable thing to do! The extension of the term limit contravenes section 328 as this calls for a referendum first. source CITE

ZimNewsUpdates

53,303 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce

Good morning citizens. This is the plight of Bulawayo residents in Pumula East. No water for 5 weeks now. 45 years after independence people are using sewer water. This is a disaster looming. We need help. We need service delivery.

Good morning citizens. This is the plight of Bulawayo residents in Pumula East. No water for 5 weeks now. 45 years after independence people are using sewer water. This is a disaster looming. We need help. We need service delivery.

MaZwangendaba

91,267 görüntüleme • 1 yıl önce

PLEASE SHARE🙏🏾 | Another young man has reportedly been abducted in Bulawayo after speaking out strongly against the proposed Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3. Denford Sithole was taken at Nketa Hall shortly after a consultation meeting where he openly opposed the amendment. Witnesses say he was taken by an unidentified man in civilian clothes who drove away in a car with registration number AGF 570. His whereabouts are currently unknown. In a separate incident in Bindura, a Bindura University of Science Education (BUSE) student was also allegedly abducted for organising fellow students to attend public consultations in large numbers to reject the bill.

PLEASE SHARE🙏🏾 | Another young man has reportedly been abducted in Bulawayo after speaking out strongly against the proposed Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3. Denford Sithole was taken at Nketa Hall shortly after a consultation meeting where he openly opposed the amendment. Witnesses say he was taken by an unidentified man in civilian clothes who drove away in a car with registration number AGF 570. His whereabouts are currently unknown. In a separate incident in Bindura, a Bindura University of Science Education (BUSE) student was also allegedly abducted for organising fellow students to attend public consultations in large numbers to reject the bill.

𝐂𝐫𝐢𝐦𝐞 𝐖𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡 𝐙𝐖

38,807 görüntüleme • 4 ay önce

CCC MP BACKS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT NO. 3 BILL CCC Member of Parliament for Budiriro North, Honourable Susan Matsunga, backed Constitutional Amendment No. 3 Bill, supporting the proposal to change the election of the President from a direct public vote to election by Parliament. #CAB3Debate #ConstitutionalAmendmentNo3 #Zimbabwe #Parliament #Governance #PoliticalStability #PoliticalDebate #ZBCNews #Recap

CCC MP BACKS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT NO. 3 BILL CCC Member of Parliament for Budiriro North, Honourable Susan Matsunga, backed Constitutional Amendment No. 3 Bill, supporting the proposal to change the election of the President from a direct public vote to election by Parliament. #CAB3Debate #ConstitutionalAmendmentNo3 #Zimbabwe #Parliament #Governance #PoliticalStability #PoliticalDebate #ZBCNews #Recap

ZBC News

13,787 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce

An hour ago, I was on South Africa’s public broadcaster, the SABC News News discussing the implications of Zimbabwe’s new law, Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3, which came into effect two days ago. The amendment extends President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s term of office by an additional two years to 2030, removes the direct election of the President by citizens and transfers that responsibility to Parliament, and effectively removes the elections that had been scheduled for 2028. We also discussed what these changes mean not only for Zimbabwe but for the entire region, particularly South Africa, which has borne the brunt of migration from Zimbabwe, both legal and illegal, driven largely by the country’s prolonged economic and political crises. What happens in Zimbabwe never stays in Zimbabwe. Political instability, economic decline, and democratic backsliding inevitably have consequences for neighbouring countries. That is why Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 is not merely a Zimbabwean issue; it is a regional issue with far-reaching political, economic, and social implications.

An hour ago, I was on South Africa’s public broadcaster, the SABC News News discussing the implications of Zimbabwe’s new law, Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3, which came into effect two days ago. The amendment extends President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s term of office by an additional two years to 2030, removes the direct election of the President by citizens and transfers that responsibility to Parliament, and effectively removes the elections that had been scheduled for 2028. We also discussed what these changes mean not only for Zimbabwe but for the entire region, particularly South Africa, which has borne the brunt of migration from Zimbabwe, both legal and illegal, driven largely by the country’s prolonged economic and political crises. What happens in Zimbabwe never stays in Zimbabwe. Political instability, economic decline, and democratic backsliding inevitably have consequences for neighbouring countries. That is why Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 is not merely a Zimbabwean issue; it is a regional issue with far-reaching political, economic, and social implications.

Hopewell Chin’ono

106,261 görüntüleme • 27 gün önce

“The People Did Not Ask for This Bill" - Hon. Karenyi Kore Rejects CAB 3 in Parliament Hon. Karenyi Kore's contribution to the parliamentary debate on Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 (CAB 3). During the debate, Hon. Karenyi argued that the people of Zimbabwe did not ask for the Bill and called for it to be subjected to a referendum. She also raised concerns about electoral reforms, political violence, corruption, and the need for an electoral system that citizens can trust. "The people did not ask for this Bill. CAB 3 does not create a single job and should be subjected to a referendum to avoid a conflict of interest. We want an electoral system citizens can trust. People want opportunities, not an extension of political power. The problem is not the Constitution; it is political violence and corruption. The voice of the people must remain the voice of our democracy. I stand with unemployed youth, farmers, vendors, workers, mothers and pensioners." — Hon. Karenyi Kore during debate on Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3.

“The People Did Not Ask for This Bill" - Hon. Karenyi Kore Rejects CAB 3 in Parliament Hon. Karenyi Kore's contribution to the parliamentary debate on Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 (CAB 3). During the debate, Hon. Karenyi argued that the people of Zimbabwe did not ask for the Bill and called for it to be subjected to a referendum. She also raised concerns about electoral reforms, political violence, corruption, and the need for an electoral system that citizens can trust. "The people did not ask for this Bill. CAB 3 does not create a single job and should be subjected to a referendum to avoid a conflict of interest. We want an electoral system citizens can trust. People want opportunities, not an extension of political power. The problem is not the Constitution; it is political violence and corruption. The voice of the people must remain the voice of our democracy. I stand with unemployed youth, farmers, vendors, workers, mothers and pensioners." — Hon. Karenyi Kore during debate on Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3.

Change Radio

32,506 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce

#NothaboAndDaughtersMurderCase The bodies of Nothabo Zandile Khumalo and her daughters Natalie and Nala murdered a month ago allegedly by her husband Ndodana Mkhanyisi Tshuma failed to arrive in Zimbabwe today - again - after missing a connecting flight in Addis Ababa to Bulawayo from London. They were initially scheduled to arrive in their home town of Bulawayo yesterday afternoon for burial on Monday or Tuesday. The Ethiopian Airlines flight that was carrying the bodies failed to land at Bole International Airport yesterday due to bad weather and had to divert to neighbouring Djibouti. By the time it arrived in Ethiopia from Djibouti, the connecting flight to Bulawayo from Bole International Airport had left. Ethiopian Airlines flies from Addis Ababa to Bulawayo via Ndola in Zambia, taking about six hours and 35 minutes. The route goes from Bole International Airport to Simon Mwansa Kapwepwe International Airport in Zambia. The continuation flight from Ndola to Joshua Mqabuko Nkomo International Airport in Bulawayo takes one hour and 40 minutes.

#NothaboAndDaughtersMurderCase The bodies of Nothabo Zandile Khumalo and her daughters Natalie and Nala murdered a month ago allegedly by her husband Ndodana Mkhanyisi Tshuma failed to arrive in Zimbabwe today - again - after missing a connecting flight in Addis Ababa to Bulawayo from London. They were initially scheduled to arrive in their home town of Bulawayo yesterday afternoon for burial on Monday or Tuesday. The Ethiopian Airlines flight that was carrying the bodies failed to land at Bole International Airport yesterday due to bad weather and had to divert to neighbouring Djibouti. By the time it arrived in Ethiopia from Djibouti, the connecting flight to Bulawayo from Bole International Airport had left. Ethiopian Airlines flies from Addis Ababa to Bulawayo via Ndola in Zambia, taking about six hours and 35 minutes. The route goes from Bole International Airport to Simon Mwansa Kapwepwe International Airport in Zambia. The continuation flight from Ndola to Joshua Mqabuko Nkomo International Airport in Bulawayo takes one hour and 40 minutes.

TheNewsHawks

35,644 görüntüleme • 3 gün önce

In the second matter before the Constitutional Court, filed by former opposition Member of Parliament Prince Dubeko Sibanda, the argument was that Parliament could not lawfully debate Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 because the bill itself is unconstitutional. The Constitutional Court ruled that the application was not yet ripe for determination, meaning that the parliamentary process must first run its course before the applicant can return to court to challenge the outcome. Once again, many lawyers have described the Court’s approach as an example of constitutional avoidance. In their view, the Court is declining to engage with the substantive constitutional questions now and is instead postponing their determination. However, the issues will not disappear. Even if the matter proceeds through the High Court first, it is almost inevitable that it will eventually return to the Constitutional Court on appeal for a final determination on the merits. In short, the Constitutional Court has not resolved the constitutional questions surrounding CAB 3; it has merely deferred them.

In the second matter before the Constitutional Court, filed by former opposition Member of Parliament Prince Dubeko Sibanda, the argument was that Parliament could not lawfully debate Constitutional Amendment Bill No. 3 because the bill itself is unconstitutional. The Constitutional Court ruled that the application was not yet ripe for determination, meaning that the parliamentary process must first run its course before the applicant can return to court to challenge the outcome. Once again, many lawyers have described the Court’s approach as an example of constitutional avoidance. In their view, the Court is declining to engage with the substantive constitutional questions now and is instead postponing their determination. However, the issues will not disappear. Even if the matter proceeds through the High Court first, it is almost inevitable that it will eventually return to the Constitutional Court on appeal for a final determination on the merits. In short, the Constitutional Court has not resolved the constitutional questions surrounding CAB 3; it has merely deferred them.

Hopewell Chin’ono

39,069 görüntüleme • 1 ay önce