Skip navigation
Feminists don’t know what a Scotsman is.
0:00 / 1:29

Feminists don’t know what a Scotsman is.

MISS K

@MISSKENSINGTON11K followers

Visit on X
818 likesDownloadOriginal post

19,906 views

Feminists don’t know what a Scotsman is.

27 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Globex Enterprises's profile picture

    @riesgomundial

    This is true feminism

    12 likes

  • Puslapuu's profile picture

    @puslapuu

    The feminist movement has been tainted by some truly horrific people. And they weren't fringe. Some of them are still taught in school and treated as heroes by todays feminists. Smart and honest people looking for equality don't associate themselves with the label "feminism".

    8 likes

  • MISS K's profile picture

    @MISSKENSINGTON

    They usually use that argument with me, that the examples given are ‘fringe’. They’re certainly not.

    2 likes

  • Brad's profile picture

    @itsmeBradMC

    Imo the entire "real men ____" trope is also a no true Scotsman fallacy...so not only do they do their fellow feminists that way but men too ..

    7 likes

  • I am not a duck's profile picture

    @greybeardpirate

    I've talked to some feminists who seemed to not be able to reason any other way. I'd show them examples of what feminists do and say, they'd just respond that they weren't really feminists. And the discussion goes nowhere.

    7 likes

  • Iwritestuff's profile picture

    @Iwritestuff404

    I've heard the "that's not feminism" line so many times. Any time you point out that the results of feminism are never equality or the fact the more feminist society becomes the more women absolutely hate men - that's not feminism. It sure is a feminist result!

    4 likes

  • PM's profile picture

    @martin76363565

    Feminism is not about equality in any way whatsoever! Feminism is nothing but an ideology based on the hatred of men, POWER and SPECIAL STATUS for women in ALL THINGS without any RESPONSIBILITY OR ACCOUNTABILITY

    3 likes

  • Tunis/C's profile picture

    @Dialoguealways

    You know that goes both ways right? So while you are rightfully acknowledging the notrueScotsman fallacy, you are also actively ignoring the opposite side of that coin which is "nutpicking". When you grab an individual example and try to lump it onto the ideology as a whole. You are being just as disingenuous as the person you are accusing of "notruescottsmen".

    2 likes

  • MISS K's profile picture

    @MISSKENSINGTON

    Nutpicking requires taking an unrepresentative individual and presenting them as representative of an ENTIRE ideology. Identifying a No True Scotsman fallacy does no such thing. I'm pointing out the logical error of redefining group membership to dismiss inconvenient counterexamples, NOT claiming those counterexamples represent everyone in the group.

    10 likes

  • Tunis/C's profile picture

    @Dialoguealways

    It absolutely does because feminism doesn't have one solid ideology other than female empowerment with the goal of equality. Everything else is individual viewpoints on how to obtain that objective and what that objective is supposed to be. So it would absolutely be fair for someone that calls themselves a feminist to exclude another "feminists" example if they view the particular ideology as either supremacists or assigning gender roles.

    1 like

  • MISS K's profile picture

    @MISSKENSINGTON

    You're literally demonstrating the 'No true Scotsman' fallacy. I cited MULTIPLE prominent feminists on my video, who didn't just participate in feminism but helped DEFINE and shape the movement. Yet because their views contradict YOUR preferred definition, you want to exclude them as not representing “real” feminism. You don't get to retroactively disqualify influential members of a movement simply because their beliefs are inconvenient to your argument.

    1 like

  • Tunis/C's profile picture

    @Dialoguealways

    Do you think MLK has the right to say that Louis Farakkahn doesn't subscribe to black liberation even though they are both influential in the movement?

  • MISS K's profile picture

    @MISSKENSINGTON

    Of course MLK could DISAGREE with Farrakhan's interpretation of black liberation, but disagreeing with someone's ideology doesn't erase their historical involvement or influence in a movement. You're STILL confusing “I reject their interpretation” with “they were never part of the movement.” By your logic, the 'No True Scotsman' fallacy could NEVER be exposed, because every counterexample could simply be dismissed as “nutpicking.” You're confusing using an individual to generalise about an entire ideology, with using an individual to DISPROVE a universal claim about that ideology. One counterexample doesn't prove EVERY feminist thinks that way, but it CAN disprove the claim that NO genuine feminist does. Got it or need me to do a drawing for you?

    3 likes

  • Tunis/C's profile picture

    @Dialoguealways

    At no point did I come to you with disrespect, but that last sentence shows that you are more insistent on being disrespectful than you are challenging my point. I specifically said that each person is allowed to dictate what they believe feminism is and whether or not somebody adheres to that particular ideology. Which is why in my first response to you I said that there were two sides of a coin on one side of no true Scotsman would be nut picking.

  • MISS K's profile picture

    @MISSKENSINGTON

    Your original point wasn't merely that nutpicking exists. Had you simply said that nutpicking is another fallacy worth considering, we wouldn't be having this conversation. But that's NOT what you said. You explicitly accused me of being “just as disingenuous” by supposedly generalising from individual examples to an entire ideology. And now you're committing a MOTTE-AND-BAILEY fallacy by claiming that people can have different interpretations of feminism, which I never disputed. You can't simultaneously insist feminism encompasses competing interpretations and then arbitrarily exclude historically influential feminists because their interpretation differs from yours.

    7 likes

  • Potemkin American's profile picture

    @Chris21146192

    Swinging a sword at a fart.

    1 like

  • (ironic absurd smile)'s profile picture

    @marius8905

    Either enough dissent pushing the hive mind against feminism (preferably based on people's experience with inequality) or, even better, a statistic to be used to disqualify feminism once a certain threshold was meet.

    1 like

  • Riselion's profile picture

    @RiselionY

    And what I notice is that people who say "they’re not true feminists" never tell them that to their faces.

    1 like

  • UFOHeatSeeker's profile picture

    @UFOExposer

    I think that's called gaslighting 🤣

  • JedoBako's profile picture

    @JedoBak

    lol lie, deny, reclassify People are getting an introduction to public relations