跳过导航
Google researcher LaurieWired warns the shift from C++ to Python in universities is creating…
0:00 / 3:22

Google researcher LaurieWired warns the shift from C++ to Python in universities is creating…

MTS

@MTSlive59万 位关注者

在 X 上查看
5,163 个赞下载原帖

1,893,769 次观看

Google researcher LaurieWired warns the shift from C++ to Python in universities is creating programmers who don't understand how computers actually work: "When I was in college getting my CS degree, my year was one of the last years that was using C++ as the core language for teaching students. Actually they were switching over to Python of all languages." "One of the biggest issues that I have is that a lot of these higher level languages are really abstracting away what is happening under the hood. If you're not aware of how the computers work in general, then you're gonna have problems when it comes to debugging." "Starting with a language like C++ gives you the ability to do these really high level abstractions, but it also gives you the ability to customize your memory management and get really close to the underlying machine. Especially if you're trying to work in high performance computing, game development, or high frequency trading." "At C++ conferences, there's almost this fundamental anger response when it comes to mentioning something like C or C++. People start complaining about the complexity of it." Google

35 条评论

评论来自 X (Twitter) 上的原帖

  • Low Level 的头像

    @LowLevelTweets

    @lauriewired Real

    468 个赞

  • vx-underground 的头像

    @vxunderground

    @lauriewired Okay? But how will with impact the silly pictures of cat economy??? Wtf??

    265 个赞

  • TDR 的头像

    @TheDutchRuler

    @lauriewired Why not study assembly instead? Or better yet, get those punch cards with holes in them. That sounds like a perfect thing for a college to let their students study.

    148 个赞

  • Mooncast Productions 的头像

    @MooncastOnline

    @lauriewired C++ is a accretive mess of bad ideas built on top of older, bad ideas. I worked in it every day for 17 years. It's not a good language for understanding the hardware anymore. If you want that, understand why C is the way it is.

    94 个赞

  • Kim Nevelsteen, PhD 的头像

    @knev_phd

    @lauriewired Meh, who cares. CS students should have a course in compiler design and assembly anyways. Any CS degree without those two is garbage anyhow.

    84 个赞

  • Paul 的头像

    @paulginntonic

    @lauriewired A DSA block in C (not even C++) should be like the starting point of formal CS education. Get to building a simple threadpool, hash table, and data serialization by hand. Pays huge down the road

    59 个赞

  • Elkay Water Fountain Enjoyer 的头像

    @ElkayEnjoyer

    @lauriewired C++ as an introduction to coding has always been kinda overkill. they’re trying to teach these kids what’s happening under the hood when they barely have a grasp of what’s happening over the hood 💀

    52 个赞

  • habibi 的头像

    @habibislop

    @lauriewired My college taught us Java in CS 101, then we did C and assembly, then a ton of handwriting pseudocode during data structures/algos/OSes, then we got to use Python in a combinatorics class and Javascript in a computer graphics class

    50 个赞

  • ali 的头像

    @endingwithali

    @lauriewired AGREEEEEE they did this when I took my first programming class in highschool and I am BITTER

    49 个赞

  • Jon Masters 🏴‍☠️ 的头像

    @jonmasters

    @lauriewired I had a similar feeling, but about Java replacing C. At least with Java you’re still vaguely connected to an (abstract) machine

    21 个赞

  • Perry E. Metzger 的头像

    @perrymetzger

    @lauriewired C++ is awful garbage, and many of the best programmers I know started on languages even further from the machine than Python.

    20 个赞

  • Edgar Training 的头像

    @edgar_training

    Waste of time. Better ask students to write a small ASM program, then, using interruptions. And a Linux kernel module using C. Then forget about it for the rest of college. Because most are not going to use it anyway. Neither need to worry about it. As a matter of fact, it's way more important, for a full stack developer, understand how the TCP/IP stack works under the hood than understanding how the CPU handles registers.

    19 个赞

  • Stocko 🦾 的头像

    @_Stocko_

    @lauriewired couldn't this be like a 1hr crash course on yt tho? there really isn't a lot to "how computers work" tbh

    17 个赞

  • jcamdr 的头像

    @jcamdr70

    @lauriewired This is exactly why Rust have a bright future. C++ is unusually complex. Decades of features, compatibility promises, and zero-overhead goals produced a language that is hard to implement and hard to use well.

    15 个赞

  • Xah Lee 的头像

    @xah_lee

    @lauriewired this funny. most c cpp coders dont even know whats lambda calculus or formal languages, the bedrock of computer science.

    13 个赞

  • bellicose_bestie 的头像

    @BellicoseBestie

    @lauriewired i thank god every day the core curriculum at my college was Lisp and all systems courses were in C / C++

    13 个赞

  • smore 的头像

    @babachefz

    @lauriewired the real teacher was never the language, it was the 2am segfault that made you actually learn what a pointer is. python just delays that reckoning until prod.

    12 个赞

  • cheesecake 的头像

    @cheese_cakee_9

    @lauriewired We still have C 😈

    9 个赞

  • Rapsberry 的头像

    @Nayberryk

    @lauriewired wait, her surname's actually Wired? lol talk about nominative determinism

    9 个赞

  • Free Radical 的头像

    @X54h0IT3

    @lauriewired You don't have to know how a car works to drive it. You only need to know somebody that can fix it when it breaks. Most developers don't need to be low level. Most problems we need to solve are high level.

    8 个赞