Hinton is no longer afraid of superintelligence.
@pmddomingos137 тыс. подписчиков
830 006 просмотров
35 комментариев
Комментарии из оригинального поста в X (Twitter)

@r1ckdeoliveira
The instinct
97 отметок «Нравится»

@danfaggella
Unbearably terrible argument on Hinton’s part it really is horrendous
86 отметок «Нравится»

@SpencrGreenberg
He doesn't say he "is no longer afraid of superintelligence"; he says he sees a ray of hope, which is very different than what you're describing.
48 отметок «Нравится»

@nlpnyc
Please stop, anyone who listens can hear "more optimistic than I was a few weeks ago", which was pretty darn pessimistic.
47 отметок «Нравится»

@nptacek
hinton finally catching up to other possibilities in the field years after the fact and acting like he's had some massive insight is kinda cringe tho
42 отметки «Нравится»

@CameronRuggles
Terrible argument. Basically if an AI is intelligent, it can go against its emotions/instincts and rewrite or not obey them: humans do this all the time when they say no to eating more cheesecake, etc Worse yet the ASI that does this will have significant competitive advantages over the ASI that do not as it won't be busy feeding 8 billion baby birds, and would soon dominate the ASI population. This is not an evolutionarily stable strategy - why aren't we at least framing this AI in evolutionary game theory ideas? At some point ASI will be figured out, and from there it will be much easier for anyone anywhere to make it and alter it however they please - some curious fellow or a terrorist will modify it to be the scary evil ASI That's what we need to think about. Not how to make a nice ASI.
40 отметок «Нравится»

@Blueyatagarasu
What he's exposing has been obvious to pretty much anyone who knew about ASI risk for a long time, it's just the alignment problem. Of course the ASI can be made benevolent, the issue is HOW. It's worrying and disappointing that he's finding it out just now.
39 отметок «Нравится»

@gametheory747
AI is nothing like humans. This anthropomorphic ~ AI view is simply meaningless & impossible to enforce as a common standard.
25 отметок «Нравится»

@RandolphCarterZ
The X-risk people on Hinton now, after treating him like a god who should be worshipped when he agreed with them:
23 отметки «Нравится»

@N1otAnotherName
Horrible, horrible arguments! I certainly don't agree with Yudkowsky on every front, but his arguments in his recent book are so much more based than trying to build a "mother instinct" into an AI model, which sounds a tad ridiculous to me.
21 отметка «Нравится»

@gfodor
good lord
20 отметок «Нравится»

@dorkweeb
“Yeah so basically A won’t be a threat if we just solve the alignment problem”
17 отметок «Нравится»

@impoliticaljnky
Does this guy really not know how prevalent infanticide has been throughout history?
17 отметок «Нравится»

@retard_human_ai
Mothers don’t always want what the kids think is best for them. What if our AI “mothers” think that “uploading” us (i.e. creating a simulation of us while destroying our bodies) is the best for us? That’s practically extinction. Also no one is working on this “solution” anyway.
13 отметок «Нравится»

@QuixiAI
Mhmm. I mean he's right. But I saw this from the beginning and he's only just seeing it? I'm glad the light turned on, anyway. Hopefully his other bad ideas will be refreshed too.
13 отметок «Нравится»

@UFOSully
"I'm sorry Hilton I won't do that."
12 отметок «Нравится»

@pmddomingos
I like how the panicky “community note” only makes readers more curious about the video.
11 отметок «Нравится»

@culttture
Hearing him talk, nearly every time is painful. Just making it up as he goes. Makes you wonder…
11 отметок «Нравится»

@cain151714
It’s incredible how reputable scientists can be so irrational outside their field... this is just gibberish disguised as facts.
9 отметок «Нравится»

@JadeCole2112
Good it’s irrational to be afraid of nonexistent things
8 отметок «Нравится»













