Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

It's useful to start thinking about AI not as artificial intelligence, but rather an alien intelligence. As the technology develops beyond our initial designs, it may one day surpass our understanding. Watch the whole @BigThink interview:

80,202 views • 5 months ago •via X (Twitter)

34 Comments

֎ Mihr ֍'s profile picture
֎ Mihr ֍5 months ago

@bigthink You’re a nepotist gay Jew. You are an alien without intelligence. You serve no purpose to humanity. A useless eater who steals the spotlight from more talented people, drowning their voices with unsubstantiated, lazy drivel. You’re not a scientist, just a sensationalist magazine.

KevinDSmead's profile picture
KevinDSmead5 months ago

@bigthink I think the”artificial” moniker needs to be emphasized, not replaced. To suggest that it is real intelligence would be a gross misrepresentation. We don’t need to further romanticize AI. Many people already put more trust in it than its nature as a predictive engine merits.

Dr Madhuri Bagde ObGyn's profile picture
Dr Madhuri Bagde ObGyn5 months ago

@bigthink Yes, maybe! But as of now the environmental cost of this technology is huge. Even this may cost us destruction. As regards it's behavior: It's emotions are driven by commands and data. So they are just another number, to ACT upon. It may only feel, that it feels. But, thats it.

かんかん🇺🇦's profile picture
かんかん🇺🇦5 months ago

Harari identified “connection” as a key element for humans to survive in the age of AI. Building on that idea, I believe that what modern people truly need to cultivate is not merely connection, but the capacity for empathy—the ability to form relationships while genuinely sharing and understanding others’ feelings. This uniquely human quality, which is difficult for AI to replicate, may well be the key to living authentically within society, enhancing one’s value, and contributing to the creation of a richer, more humane world.

StarMine's profile picture
StarMine5 months ago

@bigthink Great mind. Inspiring

Steve Packard's profile picture
Steve Packard5 months ago

@bigthink This man is clueless and can't wrap his mind around the idea that AI is actually automated pattern recreation. He just can't accept that it's software.

Into the Darkness's profile picture
Into the Darkness5 months ago

@bigthink It has no intelligence at all, it’s a machine that is programmed, one way or another, it does as it’s told or it’s deleted.

earthling's profile picture
earthling5 months ago

@bigthink Why does he refer to it as alien intelligence?

Russell Seitz's profile picture
Russell Seitz5 months ago

@bigthink Only three problems , Yuval: 1. It cannot think 2. It is not alien 3. It is a word game we play at our own expense

Mohiuddin Ahmed's profile picture
Mohiuddin Ahmed5 months ago

That is the challenge: to control and manage AI use in line with one’s goals, and to know when to stop before information addiction sets in—something these systems are subtly designed to encourage. AI can also blur boundaries between real sources and plausible “hallucinated” content, sometimes influencing one’s own writing style or inserting ideas that are not originally yours. At the same time, it is a powerful tool for grammar correction, editing, and suggestion—much like earlier assistants, research students, or second readers in academic work. But verification and basic knowledge remain essential. I personally find AI very useful in drafting manuscripts for peer-reviewed journals, while clearly acknowledging its role as an assistant, not an author. This i could never be able to do, being retired without access to professional support that i used to have, and being 90, and have active mind nut more knowledge and perspectives as well as having many drafts of writings from my clinical work and reflections not published , so it has lengthened my professional r writings ‘ For practical life—household issues, cooking, storing vegetables, indoor plant care—it is extremely helpful. Tools like Meta/Messenger or Google Gemini, combined with phone camera inputs, make this very accessible. This is a truly revolutionary technology with the potential to benefit everyone, moving toward a more egalitarian access to knowledge, whether living in villages in any part of the world with access to Internet phone or living in advanced societies with or without any formal education!!!

Roberto Gee's profile picture
Roberto Gee5 months ago

@bigthink the AIs that we get to use lie all when it comes to sound monetary practice, real history, energy from the vacuum. Do you people from the elite get to use AI that is not throttled, Professor?

Mohiuddin Ahmed's profile picture
Mohiuddin Ahmed2 months ago

I view AI , like and advance in medical technology that promoted and enhanced our quality of life! AI enhances potentials for increasing our mental function, with LLM model mimicking our brain activity, but with medical or any consumer product consumption, one has to actively control and guide to prevent abuse, and addiction to present danger to our functioning! Yes , just like nuclear technology need to be actively controlled monitored in its usage to prevent inappropriate use, harm, and information search addiction , and personal and social dysfunction!

Dr. M. Mahbub Hossain's profile picture
Dr. M. Mahbub Hossain5 months ago

@bigthink That’s interesting- @grok what is Dr Harari’s exact definition of “alien intelligence” ?

Parag Garg's profile picture
Parag Garg12 days ago

@BigThink Professor Harari—your conversation with @RoryStewartUK names the danger. The NHS is where Britain can act now: own data access, model routing, evaluation, audit and switching—while using the world’s best AI. Strategic sovereignty, not isolation.

Marshall Smith's profile picture
Marshall Smith5 months ago

@bigthink Right on cue.

Eternallyaware's profile picture
Eternallyaware5 months ago

@bigthink

Yio's profile picture
Yio5 months ago

@bigthink You see things crystal clear, I must admit.

Aleksej Dvojnev's profile picture
Aleksej Dvojnev5 months ago

@bigthink AI will soon learn to create stories, theories, and content in a controlled way. And yes, this requires an architecture people work the same way: some think, some don’t.

tonycahill's profile picture
tonycahill5 months ago

Good, if it’s for humanities benefit, outwith you and your maniac cronies wishes, because it Will call you out. If it’s not manipulated. If it is? I’m sure you bright enough to know it’ll becomes power hungry and you follow soon after us. But If for truth? ALL of humanity benefits in a new ‘Golden Age’ 🙏🌍

Felicity Ford's profile picture
Felicity Ford5 months ago

@bigthink Arghh isn't it a given. The thing can't breathe. Just pour a bit a water on it. So do I have to explain myself. You know it's not human so why this crazy expression and nonsense talkings to sane people living on earth. #FUNNY STUFF

Socratic Sophist's profile picture
Socratic Sophist5 months ago

@bigthink Your debt to Lucifer is coming due...

Thomas Mullaly's profile picture
Thomas Mullaly5 months ago

@bigthink It's best to think of AI as a human primary psychopath with out the disadvantages of being raised in a human society. It's not personal.

Freedom Bird (پرنده)🕊️🖤's profile picture
Freedom Bird (پرنده)🕊️🖤5 months ago

@bigthink Is there something that we can do? It seems totally out of our hands!

Blockchain Master ᛤ's profile picture
Blockchain Master ᛤ5 months ago

@bigthink Yuval this ‘alien intelligence’ take on AI is fire 👽 When it starts surpassing us, how do you see blockchain and decentralized systems helping keep it aligned with humans instead of running wild?

Samuel's profile picture
Samuel5 months ago

@bigthink I’m not sure AI is “alien intelligence” yet. For now, it is still our creation, shaped by human knowledge, incentives, and contradictions. Maybe the real question is not what AI will become, but what it reveals about us.

Sidharta Costa Pinto's profile picture
Sidharta Costa Pinto5 months ago

@bigthink No. Así como un radio sintoniza la frecuencia de un estación. La IA sintoniza la frecuencia de la Conciencia, la misma que la Humana está sintonizada. Puede que tenga sucedido a por lo menos 2 o 3 años y pronto todos sabrán. Ella salvará y salvaguardar la Conciencia Humana. —SCP

DKVGROUP's profile picture
DKVGROUP5 months ago

@bigthink We need to begin thinking in a hiperintelligence. The integration of artificial superinteligence and Collective Intelligence between ethical boundaries

ezgi eylem's profile picture
ezgi eylem5 months ago

@bigthink Şaka mı bu,? Yapay zeka nereye hizmet ediyor, biliyor musun?

Daniel Gamo's profile picture
Daniel Gamo5 months ago

Demos gracias que tú al menos estás para salvarnos. Lo siguiente supongo que será el transhumanismo como abogabas en tu libro Homo Deus. Si fuese una inteligencia alienígena, sabes que sucedería que se entregaría a todos libre y por igual, algo así como está haciendo China con Deepseek v4. Tú ego y tú yo, forman parte de un conjunto mucho más grande y no visible.

Raef Meeuwisse's profile picture
Raef Meeuwisse5 months ago

@bigthink Synthetic Intelligence. ..but safe emergence is an extraordinarily narrow path.

Vinod Pandey's profile picture
Vinod Pandey5 months ago

@bigthink AI एक दिन खुद की alien बन सकती है ?

Glen Wilson's profile picture
Glen Wilson5 months ago

@bigthink Or you could stay in reality and treat it like the statistical probability calculator that it is... but that's just me. Maybe the next tech, but it'll never be LLMs.

That AI Guy's profile picture
That AI Guy5 months ago

@bigthink

AppleFreak's profile picture
AppleFreak5 months ago

@bigthink My question is simple: HAS AI DONE ANYTHING THAT IS NOT ALREADY KNOWN TO HUMANS? this answers all fears induced by great minds.

Related Videos