Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

NASA should be extremely embarrassed at how much better Everyday Astronaut's coverage of the launch was compared to theirs.

213,509 views • 7 months ago •via X (Twitter)

35 Comments

Booster 10's profile picture
Booster 107 months ago

This comes from a place of love btw. It's because i love NASA that I'm mad at their incompetent handling of their biggest live event in a long long time.

Roger Pierson's profile picture
Roger Pierson7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I actually switched off @Erdayastronaut's stream a few seconds after launch because of the non-stop talking. I popped onto NASA's stream and saw the cameras were...pointed at the crowd. I decided I could handle all the talking after all.

Peter Hague's profile picture
Peter Hague7 months ago

@iNeo_G @Erdayastronaut At a certain point they should just contract out the stream to him.

Blaze's profile picture
Blaze7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut NASA has every incentive to make their launch coverage the best as possible, it's how the public connects with these missions. With Jared at the helm, I'm sure he'll sort this out by Artemis 3.

Slopey's profile picture
Slopey7 months ago

Absolutely this - I was watching the Nasa stream and couldn't believe it when they cut away right at SRB sep to people sitting in chairs with their phones out - abysmal. I was literally shouting at the screen. Tim's streams are much better, but he never stops talking through the whole thing, so I personally can't stand it. We need an EA video with the live audio feed only, and it'd be perfect.

Eddie's Mind's profile picture
Eddie's Mind7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Yeah, it was incompetence by NASA to miss the booster separation, the stage separation, and let the rocket go out of frame during launch. The first two weirdly seemed deliberate.

Ryan McGinnis's profile picture
Ryan McGinnis7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I watched this feed and couldn’t understand what everyone was complaining about And then I saw a replay of the official feed and good lord Some random YouTube dude shouldn’t be able to outperform an entire space agency at professional presentation

Winterborn's profile picture
Winterborn7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Current Nasa Feed. The Muppets could have done a better job on the camera work. Let alone a live feed for what's going on.

Doug 📐's profile picture
Doug 📐7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Yea Tim killed it! I didn’t know the coverage was bad until today because I just stayed on his feed!

Alex Oha's profile picture
Alex Oha7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut How can you get people excited about space with potato-quality streaming?

David Englund 🇺🇸's profile picture
David Englund 🇺🇸7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I guess we all have our favorites. But @NASASpaceflight did their usual OUTSTANDING job of launch coverage. Their multiple camera angles, quality of tracking, and photographic expertise is second to none!! 👏👏

D. Wylde's profile picture
D. Wylde7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut If you've ever been part of government media operations you would fully understand why it's not the greatest. Agreed, they need to improve and really knock it out of the park for the Artemis IV launch but I'm not shocked in the least about it.

Moshe Maserati's profile picture
Moshe Maserati7 months ago

I was in Holiday (Passover) so I didn't get to see the launch live. I saw all the comments after and thought, OK if you compare it SpaceX it probably looked terrible. OMG no. It was just terrible. I don't know who was in charge at the video booth but that guy needs to be tranferred.

Joncubb's profile picture
Joncubb7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I default to his streams, it should be the gold standard for everyone that covers a launch.

Tim Wildauer 🦬's profile picture
Tim Wildauer 🦬7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Counterpoint, if so many others are putting such effort into making quality broadcasts like this, why duplicate that work to make your own broadcast? Anything that can’t be captured (audio, onboard views, etc.) should be available, but that’s it.

Quorum Patriot's profile picture
Quorum Patriot7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Cut them some slack, they haven’t done this for 50 years. 🤣 Ok but really, SpaceX has it down to a production because they are well versed. This latest generation of the NASA public broadcast team doesn’t even have the shuttle launch experiences to pull from…

normalish's profile picture
normalish7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I think this just make sense. Tim has been filming every launch he can for 12 years and this space stuff is still new to NASA hahahaha

𝐇𝐓𝐀𝐑𝚰𝐇𝐂 🌈☀️'s profile picture
𝐇𝐓𝐀𝐑𝚰𝐇𝐂 🌈☀️7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I’ve already seen several comments not mocking the whole April fools launch thing, but that NASA can’t seem to stream a rocket launch anymore. 😭 It’s frustrating cuz it’s true

Fred Fuchs's profile picture
Fred Fuchs7 months ago

I have watched probably 300 SpaceX launches and thier coverage is awesome. But I am a retired engineer. As a visionary, Elon is sort of the best of Steve Jobs and Albert Einstein. It is all in the details and Issacman is a liked minded person. The future is so exciting to me and I am sorry I will get to see the really amazing future we will have in 50 years if the world stays focused on the shared future of our human race.

Multiplanetary artist's profile picture
Multiplanetary artist7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut It was. Same thing here, I love NASA to bits. Their stream was abysmal, also they at some point hinted at having celebrities on. I am like hell no I rather you guys interview the engineers. This was not the first time with embarrassing comms, they had one much worse in the past.

Amogh's profile picture
Amogh7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut They should just hire them fpr Artemis 3.

Helder De Baere's profile picture
Helder De Baere7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut They should just hire the pro’s to do the job for them

Caffeinatedesign's profile picture
Caffeinatedesign7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut My term for NASA’s coverage for a long time has been ‘vapid’. It’s just insincere fluff, like a morning talk show where the goal is to be SO EXPRESSIVE. NSF and EDA can be a bit over enthusiastic, but it’s genuine, and it’s focused on the real star of the show, not pomp.

Summerisle's profile picture
Summerisle7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut We've been spoiled by the polished broadcasting efforts of SpaceX who are a private company with a product to sell. I'm just glad the astronauts made it into orbit safely and hope they get some great footage and photographs when they get to the Moon.

CryptoJer's profile picture
CryptoJer7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Friends don’t let friends watch the @NASA feed of ANY rocket launch , they tell them to watch it on @Erdayastronaut instead! Period @

Jeremy Pacheco's profile picture
Jeremy Pacheco7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut This same thing happens during the Olympics USA broadcast. Constant cut to the crowd.

Paul Leavitt's profile picture
Paul Leavitt7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I need @NASAAdmin to hire @Erdayastronaut to overhaul their entire PR department. If he can do this with his budget, imagine what he could with with NASA money.

phexus's profile picture
phexus7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Seeing people holding up their phones is something I never want to see, ever. On the other hand, I find Everyday Astronaut's streams annoying, so I stopped watching a while back. He always talks too much when unnecessary, instead of letting us enjoy the sound of the rocket.

Julian le Roux's profile picture
Julian le Roux7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut On the flip side, it's a wonderful underdog moment when one guy with passion can do better than a decades-old multi-billion-dollar organization.

Charlie Foxtrot's profile picture
Charlie Foxtrot7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut I had to turn off NASA's coverage well before liftoff because of the constant nattering of the two Lesbanese hosts. EA was over the top - but thankfully less cringe.

Space Coast Tesla's profile picture
Space Coast Tesla7 months ago

calling NASA embarrassing over stream quality during a crewed mission is insane. SpaceX is a private tech company that launches constantly...NASA has done exactly FOUR orbital launches in the last 15 years, and two of those were Artemis I and Artemis II the mission and crew safety comes first, always. entertaining people watching at home is somewhere near the bottom of the list. nobody at NASA is sitting there worried about giving you flawless 4K camera coverage and perfect stream quality

Eric Hulgan's profile picture
Eric Hulgan7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut NASA keeps everything they fear blurry. And they feared Artemis would blow up due to fuel leaks from seal failure.

Tricky Poo's profile picture
Tricky Poo7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut Everyday Astronaut has amazing cameras covering it but he is so annoying! Constantly talking and loves being in the shot

Opus's profile picture
Opus7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut There is no reason not to collaborate with SpaceX to come up with a plan to improve. Other than certain ego's would collide.

Marc's profile picture
Marc7 months ago

@Erdayastronaut In fairness Tim is the best in the business and has the best on board who aren’t already working in industry

Related Videos