Skip navigation
Ocean Heat Source 09: The dominant source is either a) geothermal/hydrothermal heating from below…
0:00 / 0:42

Ocean Heat Source 09: The dominant source is either a) geothermal/hydrothermal heating from below…

Stephanie Buchanan

@stephXskystory5.8K followers

Visit on X
286 likesDownloadOriginal post

13,728 views

Ocean Heat Source 09: The dominant source is either a) geothermal/hydrothermal heating from below, or b) electromagnetic induction. Here’s where I’m at with the five mechanisms I’m testing to explain the abyssal warming acceleration: 1. adiabatic compression: closed 2. isopycnal heave: quantified; observationally limited 3. AABW/overturning: closed as the dominant quantitative explanation 4. geothermal/hydrothermal: in progress, looking weak as the dominant explanation, closing two loopholes... 5. electromagnetic induction: solver in development, strongest remaining hypothesis Two mechanisms closed. One ran into the limits of the observations. Two left to test... We're closing in.

30 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • SpaceWeatherNews's profile picture

    @SunWeatherMan

    If it's EM induction I want a virtual hug from everyone. Hope you caught the bit on you yesterday/last night

    92 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    I caught it :) thank you, Ben. That was really kind and made my night. And yes… if it turns out to be EM induction, you absolutely get the virtual hug 😂

    27 likes

  • Ethical Skeptic ☀'s profile picture

    @EthicalSkeptic

    If electromagnetic induction is responsible for a significant portion of anomalous ocean heat arrival, the warming should not feature an abyssal boundary. It should possess a continuous vertical electromagnetic dissipation or taper profile whose arrival shape forms from conductivtiy, pressure, salinity, geomagnetic field densities, and contribution from crustal conductivity (which is even greater in terms of resistivity-heat). The deep oceans could not possibly be immune. Yet this is not what we observe. From a Johnson study released just a couple weeks ago: "We find a statistically significant increase of the heating rate of the abyssal (4,000–6,000 dbar) ocean, from 5.4 (±4.9) TW in 1988 to 20.2 (±3.9) TW in 2018. In contrast, we find no statistically significant change in the heating rate of the deep ocean, estimated at 29.4 (±22.1) TW in 1988 and 25.0 (±17.5) TW in 2018." Johnson, G. C. (2026). Observed multi-decadal acceleration of globally averaged abyssal ocean warming. Geophysical Research Letters, 53, e2026GL124104.

    50 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    Thank you, Roger, that’s a fair test for EM, and actually one I’ll need to run once I get from the thin sheet ocean to the depth resolved solver. In my 5 layer reconstruction I still see positive acceleration in 3-4 kbar too. It’s just stronger and more extensive in 4-6 kbar. I’ll add this to the solver tests.. calculate the vertical J*E profile the coupled ocean + solid Earth solution actually produces, how much dissipation ends up in the solid Earth versus the ocean, and whether the spatial pattern can reproduce what we’re observing. Those are good constraints to put on it.

    26 likes

  • SpaceWeatherNews's profile picture

    @SunWeatherMan

    Why vertically? That’s not what we see in the atmosphere or the crust/mantle. We know that the current is induced, no vertical line of sight, and the currents run flat to the surface (perpendicular to the direction of the core). Unless you are talking about something else? In the other circumstances there are boundary layers that have more or less induction current than those above/below them

    6 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    Ah yeah, I worded that badly, sorry. I meant the vertical profile of dissipation, not a vertical current path. So J*E as a function of depth basically where the heating actually lands through the ocean + solid Earth. Agree, the induction currents are mostly tangential in the thin sheet picture. Once we go depth resolved I want to see whether the dissipation concentrates in particular boundary layers, and whether that heating profile can reproduce the 3-4 vs 4-6 kbar structure we’re observing.

    4 likes

  • SpaceWeatherNews's profile picture

    @SunWeatherMan

    @EthicalSkeptic I was more asking Roger :)

    6 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    @EthicalSkeptic Ohhh, ok good. My wording was perfect 😂

    3 likes

  • Methuselah's profile picture

    @MethuselasMuse

    Great work Stephanie. Looking forward to comparing notes in a few weeks.

    20 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    Thank you, M. I haven’t found a robust geographic footprint match to vents, ridges, plate boundaries, volcanoes, sediments, etc., so now I’m closing out the two remaining loopholes: 1) Can ocean circulation redistribute a geothermal source strongly enough, and into the right places? 2) Can concentrated vent/ridge sources generate enough local heat, rise far enough, dilute appropriately, and cover enough of the observed abyssal warming footprint? Maybe we can do a livestream and compare results when we’re both done? :)

    20 likes

  • Whetherballoon's profile picture

    @Whetherballoon7

    Funny how people not looking for funding and publication/approval from peers don’t even consider a certain trace gas

    5 likes

  • Steven Murphy's profile picture

    @nativeweed

    Thanks for the update, it’s absolutely amazing watching your progress and work!

    5 likes

  • William Schwandt's profile picture

    @illiamSchwandt

    You taught me a new word isopycnal

    4 likes

  • DDHReynolds's profile picture

    @DDHReynolds

    Thanks for stepping us through, Steph.👏👏

    4 likes

  • Mark Green's profile picture

    @CebuYokel

    I wonder if it could be both.

    3 likes

  • wgasa's profile picture

    @vzaitsevlaw

    What exactly would be the magnetic source increasing induction? Floating iron deposits ?

    2 likes

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    The magnetic source in my model is the time varying external geomagnetic field from magnetospheric currents. The ocean is the conductor because seawater is an ionic solution, so its salinity gives it electrical conductivity.

    8 likes

  • wgasa's profile picture

    @vzaitsevlaw

    Have you heard of this guy? You might find him interesting

    1 like

  • Stephanie Buchanan's profile picture

    @stephXskystory

    I have not heard of him, I’ll check him out. Thanks!

    1 like

  • Dominique Caldwell's profile picture

    @Nyque9003073

    The \(C = Q \cdot H \cdot \Omega_k \cdot \rho_m\) Planetary Engine Specification

    2 likes