Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
People keep asking is there a difference between a Belgian Malinois and a German Shepherd. A German Shepherd will assess the situation, decide whether intervention is necessary, and act accordingly. A Malinois has already launched himself into the situation, knocked over your drink, gone swimming in a flood, and... show more
36 Comments
My boy Victor a Mali ๐
Shepherd are like soldiers. Malnois are like ex special forces with PTSD and a meth addiction...
I can appreciate them from afar. I see no reason to move a crackhead with ADHD and superhuman stamina into my home. Ever.
@TonyLaneNV
Every time I hear a friend say they want a Malinios, my response is "no, you don't"
Our dog trainer put it this way. You throw a ball off of a cliff. The German Shepherd will find a way down the cliff to retrieve that ball. The Malinois will jump off the cliff after that ball.
I love these dogs... I am also smart enough to enjoy videos of these dogs... and be content with that.๐
Father was 100% black German Shepherd. Mother was a mix of Belgian Malinois, Dutch Shepherd and German Shepherd.
Having a girl that is a mix of both I can confirm that shes really smart but can be a bit of a spaz
Belgians are German Shepards on meth lol ๐ BUT working line GSD are similar but not as bad. Mine is close to a Belgian. And when sheโs having a playdate with my friend with a Belgian, they suddenly speak the same language like the raptors in Jurassic world. Itโs crazy to watch lol ๐
I will take my 5 working line GSDs (Czech and DDR) over 1 Mal any day. Mals are GSDs on crack with a 6 pack.
They need Alpha trainers , not a first dog for anyone and not for most but when dominated correctly they are Thee BEST ! mine is a fairly common cross with Great Pyrenees for sheep protection they're bigger and will kill a wolf , extremely smart and fast
Is it weird that I would love to have a mastiff with malnois firmware....
That would be dangerous.
Facts
I have a Malinois/German Shepherdโฆ.Itโs always chaos
Malinois are for people who find a Jack Russell too placid.
Oh hell no.
Imagine one as a puppy.
That's why I have one of each. She's a handful.
people describing malinois as german shepherds on caffeine always undersell the actual chaos differential
๐คฃ๐๐คฃ... "How 'bout I just knock you out."... Perfect Belgian Malinois... still laughing!
Fantastic description. Both wonderful animals. Have owned a couple GDS and the closest to the Malinois I've owned is the Louisiana Catshoula Leopard Dog... But still nowhere in the class of the Malinois
๐ so true. I have both.
@contrarian4data Both are true. This is Ruger, my Belgian Malinois 60% GSD 40% mix. Heโs a lot!
Most can't handle a high prey drive GSD, even fewer a Mal.
Beautiful breed. I love high energy pups that can match my husband and I, but I also want lazy downtime. Keep sharing as I can sit back and enjoy with my 2 pups.
@missyTHX1138 Malinois in action and this is not the worst of it
Don't get me wrong, I think Mals are amazing dogs. I'm in awe at what they can do. But there is no way I could provide even a fraction of what a Mal needs, physically or mentally. They're very cute super smart chaos goblins.
German shepherdโs are like German soldiersโฆiโm German but my behaviour at times is more like a Belgian Malinoisโฆ cute but bring chaos to the table lol
My daughter has one. Harlen would die for her.๐ His favourite pastime is chasing squirrels & possums up into the trees! He climbs up a major portion! Belgian Malinois are not for the weak hearted, Harlen is always in hyper alert, even in the car, when it comes to my daughter!
I met my first Malinois last month while walking down the street. I happened to make a short kissing sound with my mouth just to see what would happen. Clearly this dog knew that sound as a cue. He immediately jumped at me and his chest hit my shoulder. I'm 6 feet. All good fun.
We experience the difference every morning. Our GS mix sidles up to my wife in bed, gives her a kiss & then lays down at her feet. Our Mal mix launches herself on to the bed, sits on top of my wife while covering her in kisses & then rolls on to her back to get belly rubs.
I'll stick with my German Shepard. He's a monster if there's a door or window between you. If you make it inside, he's pretty sure you're there to see him. I've been around enough Belgians to know they want you to come inside to fuck you up. I prefer a samurai over a ninja.
Omg. Both are nut jobs and super smart, but mals are really in a class of their own. No other breed compares to them. โค๏ธ
If you think your Mal is nuts, I raise you my Dutchie X Rotti. ๐คฃ Absolute crack head. โค๏ธ
