正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

加载此视频时出现问题。这可能是由于临时网络问题，或视频可能不可用。

Reality vs. Propaganda: Did North India increase its population disproportionately, while Southern States controlled it? Contrary to the popular perception, as the data shows, it is the southern states that doubled and tripled their population for the first 70 years since 1871, when North Indian States’ population witnessed negligible... show more

Sajjan Kumar Singh

6,057 subscribers

36,001 次观看 • 1 年前 •via X (Twitter)

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

6 条评论

फ्रीमन रॉड्रिग्ज 的头像

फ्रीमन रॉड्रिग्ज1 年前

stop misleading the nation by comparing the data with 1871. Compare the population growth with last 10 yr, 25 yr & 50 years. Don't compare it 1800 or 1600. Utter nonsense !!

Sajjan Kumar Singh 的头像

Sajjan Kumar Singh1 年前

Demographic Transition across the world is compared Longue durée, not in short term. Here, 1871 is the starting point because it’s the first census year adjusted to current state boundaries. Understand basics before blabbering.

Rock Paper Sizzle 的头像

Rock Paper Sizzle1 年前

🇺🇸 One Nation, under Trump, Stronger THAN EVER. Are you Trump Tough? 💪Tough T's Here:

Shankar Meena 的头像

Shankar Meena1 年前

@Skmeena0898

Dhiraj Ahuja 的头像

Dhiraj Ahuja1 年前

WTF We are Indians Why are you trying to create a divide between North Indians and South Indians on the basis of who makes more babies...as if Kannada vs Tamil, Kannada vs Hindi, Tamil vs Hindi, Marathi vs Hindi was not enough You are the real enemies of India

Sajjan Kumar Singh 的头像

Sajjan Kumar Singh1 年前

It’s leaders like @mkstalin who are peddling toxic regional agenda of north vs south. The book in this tweet is just putting things in proper perspective with data driven research.

相关视频

Delimitation based on the population not based on the states concerns As per the 2011 censes India Population 121cr South India population 28.6 Cr (23.14%) Current India population 146cr South India population 28cr(20%) That means may lose more seats if the 2026 data is used

Delimitation based on the population not based on the states concerns As per the 2011 censes India Population 121cr South India population 28.6 Cr (23.14%) Current India population 146cr South India population 28cr(20%) That means may lose more seats if the 2026 data is used

FOR 🅰 REASON

36,700 次观看 • 2 个月前

Kudos to KTR for strongly opposing population-based delimitation. Why should states that worked hard on population control,education and development be punished with reduced representation? Delimitation based purely on population growth risks shifting political power unfairly, rewarding regions that failed to control population while sidelining those that governed responsibly. Southern states have consistently contributed more in terms of economic growth,governance and human development. their voice in Parliament cannot be diluted in the name of arithmetic. delimitation must go beyond population. it should reflect performance,progress and equity.

Kudos to KTR for strongly opposing population-based delimitation. Why should states that worked hard on population control,education and development be punished with reduced representation? Delimitation based purely on population growth risks shifting political power unfairly, rewarding regions that failed to control population while sidelining those that governed responsibly. Southern states have consistently contributed more in terms of economic growth,governance and human development. their voice in Parliament cannot be diluted in the name of arithmetic. delimitation must go beyond population. it should reflect performance,progress and equity.

Antara

10,609 次观看 • 2 个月前

#WATCH | On delimitation issue, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi says, "We want to ask the Home Minister, what is the meaning of pro-rata?... Will delimitation be based on population or not? If Southern states are penalised based on the population they have reduced, their political impact will be reduced in the Centre..."

#WATCH | On delimitation issue, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi says, "We want to ask the Home Minister, what is the meaning of pro-rata?... Will delimitation be based on population or not? If Southern states are penalised based on the population they have reduced, their political impact will be reduced in the Centre..."

ANI

14,165 次观看 • 1 年前

#WATCH | “Tamil Nadu’s Final Warning on Delimitation”: M. K. Stalin Threatens Agitation if Southern States Lose Representation ⚖️🔥 MK Stalin warned that Tamil Nadu will launch protests if delimitation leads to reduced parliamentary representation for southern states, arguing it would unfairly penalise regions that have effectively controlled population growth. #MKStalin #Delimitation #TamilNadu #Politics

#WATCH | “Tamil Nadu’s Final Warning on Delimitation”: M. K. Stalin Threatens Agitation if Southern States Lose Representation ⚖️🔥 MK Stalin warned that Tamil Nadu will launch protests if delimitation leads to reduced parliamentary representation for southern states, arguing it would unfairly penalise regions that have effectively controlled population growth. #MKStalin #Delimitation #TamilNadu #Politics

Moneycontrol

14,705 次观看 • 2 个月前

WOMEN'S RESERVATION ACT CAN BE IMPLEMENTED WITHOUT DELIMITATION! The amendment of Constitution to implement the sinister #Delimitation by #Modi govt is nothing but silencing the DEMOCRATIC VOICE of the more educated more responsible Indians states, mostly South And Eastern States, that have had lesser percentage growth in population and have kept BJP out of political power, while rewarding the North Indian belt where states have more illiteracy rate but have seen multiplication of population drastically and are often vote voters of BJP.

WOMEN'S RESERVATION ACT CAN BE IMPLEMENTED WITHOUT DELIMITATION! The amendment of Constitution to implement the sinister #Delimitation by #Modi govt is nothing but silencing the DEMOCRATIC VOICE of the more educated more responsible Indians states, mostly South And Eastern States, that have had lesser percentage growth in population and have kept BJP out of political power, while rewarding the North Indian belt where states have more illiteracy rate but have seen multiplication of population drastically and are often vote voters of BJP.

Vinay Kumar Dokania

14,486 次观看 • 2 个月前

The southern states which contribute more to the GDP and have controlled their population will be punished and the northern states which didn’t control population and are on the lowest rank in all human and social index will be benefited. — SC Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal Ji

The southern states which contribute more to the GDP and have controlled their population will be punished and the northern states which didn’t control population and are on the lowest rank in all human and social index will be benefited. — SC Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal Ji

Shantanu

52,629 次观看 • 2 个月前

MUST WATCH: The Southern states make more money! While Northern states make more babies!! ~ The Economist Why should the progressive South suffer for the North's failures in #governance and population control? #FairDelimitationForTN link:

MUST WATCH: The Southern states make more money! While Northern states make more babies!! ~ The Economist Why should the progressive South suffer for the North's failures in #governance and population control? #FairDelimitationForTN link:

DMK IT WING

10,342 次观看 • 1 年前

#WATCH | Delhi: On delimitation issue, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor says, " When there is a sensus in 2026 or after, the new delimitation might end the arrangement for 50 years...that raises some very questions. What happens if the north Indian Hindi speaking states have a 2/3rd majority and can pass amendments? Will the south feel disenfranchised?...population keeps changing..."

#WATCH | Delhi: On delimitation issue, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor says, " When there is a sensus in 2026 or after, the new delimitation might end the arrangement for 50 years...that raises some very questions. What happens if the north Indian Hindi speaking states have a 2/3rd majority and can pass amendments? Will the south feel disenfranchised?...population keeps changing..."

ANI

26,164 次观看 • 1 年前

Govt is all set to punish South India The Union government has now signalled that delimitation may be moved ahead without waiting for the Census after 2026, raising the possibility that the 2011 Census could become the base for redrawing Lok Sabha seats. For those who don’t know what delimitation is, it is the process of reallocating parliamentary seats among states in line with population changes It has a stated aim of preserving fair and proportional democratic representation. But this is where the debate becomes serious. Population trends across India have not moved uniformly A major reason is the difference in fertility rates among states. Most southern states—Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana—have already brought fertility below the replacement level of 2 Meanwhile, states such as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar continue to record comparatively higher fertility levels. If seat redistribution follows these numbers, the political balance could shift sharply The five southern states together may end up with around 164 Lok Sabha seats, whereas Uttar Pradesh and Bihar alone could together command nearly 222. The larger question, then, is philosophical as much as political: Should states that succeeded in stabilising population growth lose representation because of that success? Many in the South see this as a structural disadvantage, almost a democratic penalty for effective population management. The political implications are equally significant Since the ruling party’s electoral strength has historically been far deeper across northern India than in much of the South, any expansion in seat share in the Hindi belt could naturally reshape the national balance of power in a way that may politically benefit the current establishment We are waiting for Govt’s official version Because if the present documents floating on internet are true, then South India is going to be penalised heavily in their possible future representation in Indian Lok Sabha 🙏

Govt is all set to punish South India The Union government has now signalled that delimitation may be moved ahead without waiting for the Census after 2026, raising the possibility that the 2011 Census could become the base for redrawing Lok Sabha seats. For those who don’t know what delimitation is, it is the process of reallocating parliamentary seats among states in line with population changes It has a stated aim of preserving fair and proportional democratic representation. But this is where the debate becomes serious. Population trends across India have not moved uniformly A major reason is the difference in fertility rates among states. Most southern states—Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana—have already brought fertility below the replacement level of 2 Meanwhile, states such as Uttar Pradesh and Bihar continue to record comparatively higher fertility levels. If seat redistribution follows these numbers, the political balance could shift sharply The five southern states together may end up with around 164 Lok Sabha seats, whereas Uttar Pradesh and Bihar alone could together command nearly 222. The larger question, then, is philosophical as much as political: Should states that succeeded in stabilising population growth lose representation because of that success? Many in the South see this as a structural disadvantage, almost a democratic penalty for effective population management. The political implications are equally significant Since the ruling party’s electoral strength has historically been far deeper across northern India than in much of the South, any expansion in seat share in the Hindi belt could naturally reshape the national balance of power in a way that may politically benefit the current establishment We are waiting for Govt’s official version Because if the present documents floating on internet are true, then South India is going to be penalised heavily in their possible future representation in Indian Lok Sabha 🙏

Shekhar Dutt

48,570 次观看 • 2 个月前

There will be no injustice to any southern states. Delimitation Bill, 2026 will benefit them. The numbers of MP's from Southern India will increase to 195 from 129.

There will be no injustice to any southern states. Delimitation Bill, 2026 will benefit them. The numbers of MP's from Southern India will increase to 195 from 129.

Amit Shah

1,017,236 次观看 • 2 个月前

India's delimitation debate reaches US shores: Shashi Tharoor vs Tejasvi Surya at Stanford Is India ready for an 850-member Lok Sabha? At the Stanford India Conference 2026, Shashi Tharoor and Tejasvi Surya locked horns over delimitation. Tharoor warned that such expansion would cripple debate, comparing it to oversized legislatures where dissent fades. Surya countered that a frozen 1971-based structure cannot represent a 140 crore population, calling delimitation essential for accountability. K. Annamalai framed it as a North-South balancing act ahead of Census data. For full video 👉 Subscribe to the channel 👉

India's delimitation debate reaches US shores: Shashi Tharoor vs Tejasvi Surya at Stanford Is India ready for an 850-member Lok Sabha? At the Stanford India Conference 2026, Shashi Tharoor and Tejasvi Surya locked horns over delimitation. Tharoor warned that such expansion would cripple debate, comparing it to oversized legislatures where dissent fades. Surya countered that a frozen 1971-based structure cannot represent a 140 crore population, calling delimitation essential for accountability. K. Annamalai framed it as a North-South balancing act ahead of Census data. For full video 👉 Subscribe to the channel 👉

The Times Of India

16,313 次观看 • 2 个月前