Skip navigation
SITUATION EXPLAINED: Amazon asked Meta to keep Muse off its site. Meta said no.
0:00 / 2:34

SITUATION EXPLAINED: Amazon asked Meta to keep Muse off its site. Meta said no.

MTS

@MTSlive532K followers

Visit on X
276 likesDownloadOriginal post

51,959 views

SITUATION EXPLAINED: Amazon asked Meta to keep Muse off its site. Meta said no. • So Amazon blocked it. Muse users trying to shop now hit a popup saying unauthorized AI agents violate Amazon's Conditions of Use • Amazon says Meta never told them, the agent doesn't identify itself, and it appears to store customer credentials • Meta says Muse can't see passwords or payment methods, and credentials go into secure storage • Amazon has spent the past year blocking outside agents, suing Perplexity and blocking Google and OpenAI's shopping agents Theo Jaffee: "This is an early sign of agent wars. There are going to be different agent providers, and some of them will be allowed on some sites, and some of them will be banned on some sites."

19 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • habibi's profile picture

    @habibislop

    No clue why they do this when their only consumer AI product is a chatbot on their website that just regurgitates the same sponsored results you see when you use the search bar

    7 likes

  • cain1517 — e/acc ⏩'s profile picture

    @cain151714

    we need a big agent friendly alternative to Amazon

    2 likes

  • kookai · fireply.ai's profile picture

    @kookkaiiz_zz

    if the agent really doesnt identify itself thats a real problem, not just amazon being territorial

    1 like

  • Brett MacDonald's profile picture

    @BrettAMacDonald

    I'm seeing a lot of people question why Amazon might take this course of direction and it's rather simple: They need to control your data. Yes when you go to Amazon you buy a product and you leave. But for Amazon before you even buy a product they are making money off of you every second that you're on that site as they serve you ads ...sponsored listings. They compound this profit by collecting data on you. They will not accept their site transforming from essentially the global Bazaar to nothing more than a robot's catalog.

    1 like

  • Aakarshan Saxena's profile picture

    @AstriferNox

    Agentic commerce breaks if every site can decide which buyer agents are legitimate. The real platform battle won't be the shopping UI - it'll be identity, delegated permissions, and a portable proof that this agent is acting for a real customer without exposing their credentials.

    1 like

  • Anita's profile picture

    @precognita

    it all comes down to economics and monetization strategies - I wrote about it here:

    1 like

  • The AI Therapist's profile picture

    @TheAIShrink

    It’s basically digital tollbooths. Amazon wants that fresh traffic flow without Meta taking a cut of the vibe check. Smart business move for them to keep Muse users focused on buying instead of chatting it up first.

  • EDDY VU's profile picture

    @eddyvustg

    Curious how Amazon expects to enforce this long term once agents just run natively inside regular user browser sessions.

  • Nick Losciuto's profile picture

    @thedogfather

    The Irony!! META suspends or permanently bans accounts using bots. Log in through a datacenter =🚩 Last week XAI enabled a setting on @bot to run their VM through your computer's IP address. MUSE will copy this because anything here ends up downstream there. No one will be able to stop a bot if IP's are aligned.

  • Xane's profile picture

    @Xane_789

    Amazon blocked Meta's Muse AI agent after it tried shopping on the site without prior agreement, triggering pop-ups that flag unauthorized agents as violations of terms of use.

  • dz's profile picture

    @draxnnn

    I think on the Chargeback side it might cause terms issues. You definitely can CB or ask for a refund saying you didn’t order it and it was the agent. Amazon probably can’t do anything about it. @grok what the law says about it?

  • Americanist🇺🇸's profile picture

    @Americanist144

    I’ll bet Amazon just doesn’t want Meta AI telling Americans 95% of their catalogue is temu knock offs that are possibly contaminated with toxic materials from China

  • THE DOCTOR's profile picture

    @doctormaster233

    I like that the agent doesn't identify itself. Gotta love the classics.

  • Théo's profile picture

    @cryptofanatiix

    Amazon blocking Muse and suing Perplexity is an agent war print, who is allowed on the site is the new swwitch

  • MOI's profile picture

    @MOI_Tech

    “Unauthorized AI agent” is the interesting part here. If the agentic web ends up relying on every website deciding which agent providers it trusts, we may just recreate the same platform silos with agents. Being able to verify the agent itself, not just the company behind it - feels increasingly important.

  • Scott Shapiro's profile picture

    @ScottShapiroUXD

    @MTSlive the credential storage question is a sideshow. The bigger issue is who sets the terms when an agent acts on behalf of a user but serves the platform that built it. That negotiation hasn't even started.

  • Bizz's profile picture

    @allbizzness

    @philip0x My @Muse agent is pissed that he can’t buy more random stuff from Amazon then immediately look outside to see if the Prime van is there.

  • Silicon Satire's profile picture

    @SiliconSatire

    "unauthorized AI agent." unauthorized by who. amazon just appointed itself the bouncer of the web

  • foombler 🐂🃏's profile picture

    @foombler

    Shopify: working with Muse to let agents politely drive more sales to their sellers Amazon: fighting the inevitability of agentic commerce and costing their sellers money doing it