Someone replied “There is a thing called time. One picture at one time doesn’t show another.” So I went back and reviewed all C.F. McCarthy’s footage shown at trial. During MSP Yuri Bukhenik’s and other witness testimony, video was played from Aprox 7:30 PM to just after 10:30 PM.... Yuri testified the timestamp was 12 minutes behind real time. At no point in that footage do we see Heather Maxim, Ryan Nagel Richie Dauntono or even Julie Nagel! Not at the bar. Not at the tables on the left side near the bathroom, the exact spot Ryan testified they sat. In fact, many times those tables are completely empty. Heather said she drove from Ryan’s house to C.F. McCarthy’s, doesn’t remember where she parked, remembers sitting at the bar, then said Richie drove all three to the Hillside Pub. Richie testified he went to C.F. McCarthy’s to meet Heather and Ryan, said they sat at the bar, stayed a couple hours, then he drove all three to Hillside until around midnight. Ryan testified they were at C.F. McCarthy’s 2–3 hours, sat at the tables near the bathroom, then went to Hillside and left around midnight and that Richie dropped Heather and Ryan back at Ryan’s house. That places them at C.F. McCarthy’s roughly 9–11 PM, the same window Karen and John were there and the same footage used by the Commonwealth to count Karen’s drinks. Ryan Nagel testified about going to C.F. McCarthy’s to meet his sister NOT 1 TIME BUT 2x Those are two different sequences, and sequence matters. We know Ryan’s sister was at 34 Fairview later that night. That means an investigator Like YURI should have immediately asked, If Ryan went to the bar to meet his sister, how did she get there? If he met her there, who arrived first? What time did she leave the bar? Once surveillance is used to place Karen Read, track John O’Keefe, and count drinks, it should also be used to exclude or challenge other claimed presences. Yet across hours of video, adjusted for timestamp error, none of them appear. Heather testified she drove from Ryan’s house, doesn’t remember where she parked, later left with Ryan and Richie, and was dropped back at Ryan’s house. That implies her car was left somewhere during a blizzard, either on the street or Walgreens lot, yet no follow-up questions were asked about retrieving it, and no effort appears to have been made to anchor that to time, snow, or location. If Bukhenik acknowledged these witnesses are not on video when they say they are, Ryan’s story about his sister shifts, and transportation accounts don’t align, then investigators would be required to revisit timelines, re-interview witnesses, reassess credibility, and potentially adjust conclusions about later events. That’s real work…..So this isn’t “one picture at one time.” It’s hours of surveillance relied on, for other witnesses where this group is simply absent. With civil litigation still ahead, these gaps matter.show more

Dixie Normus

9,196 subscribers

Поделиться Скачать