Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

There was a problem loading this video. This could be due to a temporary network issue or the video might be unavailable.

The AFL has confirmed the Judd McVee third umpire overrule was an error and that both clubs have been contacted to concede the mistake. The Demons were only 15 points down at this stage. McVee clearly touched the ball, AFL ARC over ruled the behind call and called it... show more

Jon Ralph

104,972 subscribers

146,427 views • 1 year ago •via X (Twitter)

News & Politics Sports

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

11 Comments

B1 year ago

Multi billion dollar industry and we got RING cameras and 1995 technology to tell us it the ball hit the post or not

Mobile Scanner1 year ago

Scan any documents, convert images into text, PDF files, etc. 👍

Steve1 year ago

I’m sure Dillon would say that Arc decisions have never been better

Clint 🐯🖤💛🏆💙❤️🦈1 year ago

Still waiting on the evidence that showed Tom Lynch’s goal overturned in the 2022 Elimination Final 🤷‍♂️

⚓️ Chris Read ⚓️1 year ago

Can they also confirm that Nick Blakey ran to China and back without taking a bounce before he kicked that goal 🤣😂😜

Jasper Chellappah1 year ago

Incorrectly overruled. Pathetic

John1 year ago

Isn’t he hanging onto the goal post to touch the ball though? Both feet off the ground so he’s climbing the post. Crows shoulda been awarded a free kick Cmon Ralphy get off it

deliciousSC1 year ago

AFL still owes Adelaide a few

Prince Imperial1 year ago

How long does this have to go on for before there is a change! They should only overrule the soft call if they are 100% sure it’s a mistake. A blatant wrong call. It has to be concrete. How many times with suspect footage do they overrule on gut feel. It needs to stop.

Costa1 year ago

The umpiring in general is abysmal. So many trash umpires. Sort it out afl.

Kozzy Owns You1 year ago

2 Horrible decisions have been made against us in those goals

Related Videos

The AFL wrote to Clubs yesterday following feedback over a few weeks regarding the interpretation of holding the ball and how it is being officiated. Examples were provided to Clubs clarifying one aspect of holding the ball - reasonable time. Read more:

The AFL wrote to Clubs yesterday following feedback over a few weeks regarding the interpretation of holding the ball and how it is being officiated. Examples were provided to Clubs clarifying one aspect of holding the ball - reasonable time. Read more:

AFL

68,227 views • 2 years ago

The bravest goal umpire in the world. It cleared the padding. The replay shows daylight between the post and the ball. Snicko didn’t work. If he had reviewed it you could easily make a case the ARC would have called it a goal. Adelaide will believe they should have won #afl

The bravest goal umpire in the world. It cleared the padding. The replay shows daylight between the post and the ball. Snicko didn’t work. If he had reviewed it you could easily make a case the ARC would have called it a goal. Adelaide will believe they should have won #afl

Jon Ralph

382,665 views • 3 years ago

"It's as big a mistake as I can remember." The panel reacts to the 'shattering' call that ended the Crows finals hopes, as Damian Barrett explains he expects the AFL to stand down the goal umpire. #9AFLFS | Channel 9 📺

"It's as big a mistake as I can remember." The panel reacts to the 'shattering' call that ended the Crows finals hopes, as Damian Barrett explains he expects the AFL to stand down the goal umpire. #9AFLFS | Channel 9 📺

Footy on Nine

115,288 views • 3 years ago

A complete failure of both umpiring and the rule book. Umpire Brian O'Nora incorrectly called a HBP a foul ball. On review, the pitch clearly missed the bat, but New York ruled that the HBP was inconclusive and, since foul tips aren't reviewable, the foul call was upheld.

A complete failure of both umpiring and the rule book. Umpire Brian O'Nora incorrectly called a HBP a foul ball. On review, the pitch clearly missed the bat, but New York ruled that the HBP was inconclusive and, since foul tips aren't reviewable, the foul call was upheld.

Umpire Auditor

447,394 views • 1 year ago

"They (The AFL) are saying that Essendon was right and the AFL ARC doctor, on this occasion, was wrong." 🗣️ Tom Morris on the ARC taking Tom Edwards off for concussion despite passing an HIA

"They (The AFL) are saying that Essendon was right and the AFL ARC doctor, on this occasion, was wrong." 🗣️ Tom Morris on the ARC taking Tom Edwards off for concussion despite passing an HIA

7AFL

179,206 views • 3 months ago

“They must sit down and simplify this stand nonsense.” Richo has called for the AFL to fix the stand rule. MORE 👉 #AFL

“They must sit down and simplify this stand nonsense.” Richo has called for the AFL to fix the stand rule. MORE 👉 #AFL

3AW Football

12,353 views • 27 days ago

Clayton Oliver has admitted he thought his time at the Demons was done. The four-time best and fairest winner broke his silence today, setting the record straight on a potential move to the Cats | Melbourne Demons AFL Nick Butler #AFL

Clayton Oliver has admitted he thought his time at the Demons was done. The four-time best and fairest winner broke his silence today, setting the record straight on a potential move to the Cats | Melbourne Demons AFL Nick Butler #AFL

10 News First Melbourne

14,243 views • 1 year ago

This home plate umpire, Dan Merzel, called this ball down the third base line fair which resulted in a single. The third baseman picked the ball up after he said it crossed over the line into foul territory. I say that is a foul ball and the ump made the wrong call. What do you think? Fair or foul?

This home plate umpire, Dan Merzel, called this ball down the third base line fair which resulted in a single. The third baseman picked the ball up after he said it crossed over the line into foul territory. I say that is a foul ball and the ump made the wrong call. What do you think? Fair or foul?

👉M-Û-R-Č-H👈

44,775 views • 3 months ago

The AFL has confirmed there’s no communication from the coaches box to umpires during play. The ump said “I just got word” but it would have been from another field umpire. Konstanty kicked the ball away, not a Dons player. Dons should have eventually got the free kick Fox Footy

The AFL has confirmed there’s no communication from the coaches box to umpires during play. The ump said “I just got word” but it would have been from another field umpire. Konstanty kicked the ball away, not a Dons player. Dons should have eventually got the free kick Fox Footy

Jon Ralph

92,086 views • 1 year ago

This umpire gave this kid and his team two warnings for throwing the bat at the catcher. He told them if it happened again they were going to get ejected from the game. Well….it happened again. The batter hit the ball back to the pitcher and the pitcher overthrew first base. But, the umpire called a dead ball and called the batter out and ejected him from the game. The coach came out to argue and said the batter didn’t throw the bat, that it was a regular follow through on the back swing. He told the umpire they had it on film. The umpire said he had it on film too. Then the third base coach came down to argue and the umpire told the coach he was wrong and that he had it on video. You can hear the parents screaming at him. Some people said that was a terrible call and he let go legally on the follow through. You can also hear them tell the umpire that he had it out for that kid. 🤯 But a lot of people sided with the ump and said he handled it well and with that many warnings that it was a fantastic call. 💯 The umpire gave the same kid two prior warnings. Even if it wasn’t intentional, there has to be consequences after a third time. He could seriously injure the catcher. This will help the batter in the future hopefully. What do you think? Was this the right or wrong call?

This umpire gave this kid and his team two warnings for throwing the bat at the catcher. He told them if it happened again they were going to get ejected from the game. Well….it happened again. The batter hit the ball back to the pitcher and the pitcher overthrew first base. But, the umpire called a dead ball and called the batter out and ejected him from the game. The coach came out to argue and said the batter didn’t throw the bat, that it was a regular follow through on the back swing. He told the umpire they had it on film. The umpire said he had it on film too. Then the third base coach came down to argue and the umpire told the coach he was wrong and that he had it on video. You can hear the parents screaming at him. Some people said that was a terrible call and he let go legally on the follow through. You can also hear them tell the umpire that he had it out for that kid. 🤯 But a lot of people sided with the ump and said he handled it well and with that many warnings that it was a fantastic call. 💯 The umpire gave the same kid two prior warnings. Even if it wasn’t intentional, there has to be consequences after a third time. He could seriously injure the catcher. This will help the batter in the future hopefully. What do you think? Was this the right or wrong call?

👉M-Û-R-Č-H👈

2,118,601 views • 1 month ago

"I was reading the AFL boys choose their own songs" Nicholas Walsh explains that after a goal in the AFL the ball goes back to midfield for a bounce to restart the game. The players have time to celebrate & it creates a great atmosphere in the ground. Could we not do this in the GAA after a goal (not a point)

"I was reading the AFL boys choose their own songs" Nicholas Walsh explains that after a goal in the AFL the ball goes back to midfield for a bounce to restart the game. The players have time to celebrate & it creates a great atmosphere in the ground. Could we not do this in the GAA after a goal (not a point)

Smaller Fish

31,071 views • 10 months ago

"It's not OK to put the L-plate umpires out there!" Former AFL umpire 'Razor' Ray Chamberlain and Gerard Whateley were at odds over the state of umpiring, and whether the four-umpire system has exposed a lack of depth. #AFL360

"It's not OK to put the L-plate umpires out there!" Former AFL umpire 'Razor' Ray Chamberlain and Gerard Whateley were at odds over the state of umpiring, and whether the four-umpire system has exposed a lack of depth. #AFL360

Fox Footy

113,010 views • 1 month ago

🗣️ "The umpires just made an error and we have to live with it." 🗣️ "Brisbane would have every right to be screaming blue murder if that was to affect finals." After the AFL conceded an umpiring error, should the Lions be awarded an extra goal? #9AFLSFS | Watch on 9 & 9Now 🖥️

🗣️ "The umpires just made an error and we have to live with it." 🗣️ "Brisbane would have every right to be screaming blue murder if that was to affect finals." After the AFL conceded an umpiring error, should the Lions be awarded an extra goal? #9AFLSFS | Watch on 9 & 9Now 🖥️

Footy on Nine

21,184 views • 1 month ago

Umpire Austin Jones incorrectly called a HBP and strikeout to Jung Hoo Lee on a pitch that clearly hit the bat. However, whether a batter made contact with the ball is not reviewable so the obviously incorrect call was upheld. A similar error happened last September.

Umpire Austin Jones incorrectly called a HBP and strikeout to Jung Hoo Lee on a pitch that clearly hit the bat. However, whether a batter made contact with the ball is not reviewable so the obviously incorrect call was upheld. A similar error happened last September.

Umpire Auditor

355,244 views • 1 year ago

“This is a club that is willing to pay $700k (a year) out of their cap to a player to play for another club.” Kane has called out the Demons over the Clayton Oliver saga... #AFL | #Razorback

“This is a club that is willing to pay $700k (a year) out of their cap to a player to play for another club.” Kane has called out the Demons over the Clayton Oliver saga... #AFL | #Razorback

AFL Trade Radio

31,868 views • 10 months ago

This was the most controversial decisions in modern soccer. The ball hit a camera cable, and the play should have been stopped.This is an objective rules error, not a bad call. Norway has the right to request a replay.

This was the most controversial decisions in modern soccer. The ball hit a camera cable, and the play should have been stopped.This is an objective rules error, not a bad call. Norway has the right to request a replay.

VICTORIA FOREVER MAGA 🇨🇦 🇺🇸 🇬🇷

59,741 views • 27 days ago

"This is a really simple AFL decision that they have not thought about in any way shape of form to consider the advantage that they may or may not give." Ken Hinkley and Sam Edmund discuss the coaching mistake that the AFL have made with this week's State Of Origin match. Sportsday | #AFL

"This is a really simple AFL decision that they have not thought about in any way shape of form to consider the advantage that they may or may not give." Ken Hinkley and Sam Edmund discuss the coaching mistake that the AFL have made with this week's State Of Origin match. Sportsday | #AFL

SEN 1116

102,110 views • 5 months ago

"Last year we sent a reminder to all clubs in a memo before the finals, to say that players must return the ball to the umpire and that if they fail to do so, a free kick can be awarded." Hear more from umpires boss Stephen McBurney:

"Last year we sent a reminder to all clubs in a memo before the finals, to say that players must return the ball to the umpire and that if they fail to do so, a free kick can be awarded." Hear more from umpires boss Stephen McBurney:

AFL

132,292 views • 2 years ago

🚨ODD SCORING ALERT🚨 I was also asked a few times about the Jake McCarthy inside the park home run against Paul Skenes in yesterday's Colorado Rockies and Pittsburgh Pirates game (but not nearly as much as the Harper play). The question is why was this not a triole and an error on the right fielder for kicking the ball. This was ruled a home run because slipping on the warning track and kicking the ball away, while unfortunate, is not considered an error. So, even though McCarthy would have only had a triple, the slip doesn't go as an error, so it's an insid-the-park home run. Also, had it been a triple and an error, it would have still been an earned run as Hunter Goodman's fly out to the warning track would have scored the runner from third. #LetsGoBucs #Rockies

🚨ODD SCORING ALERT🚨 I was also asked a few times about the Jake McCarthy inside the park home run against Paul Skenes in yesterday's Colorado Rockies and Pittsburgh Pirates game (but not nearly as much as the Harper play). The question is why was this not a triole and an error on the right fielder for kicking the ball. This was ruled a home run because slipping on the warning track and kicking the ball away, while unfortunate, is not considered an error. So, even though McCarthy would have only had a triple, the slip doesn't go as an error, so it's an insid-the-park home run. Also, had it been a triple and an error, it would have still been an earned run as Hunter Goodman's fly out to the warning track would have scored the runner from third. #LetsGoBucs #Rockies

MLB Scoring Changes

980,822 views • 1 month ago

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇳🇴‼️🚨 STABILIZED FOOTAGE: I have stabilized the footage to better see the ball's trajectory. You can clearly see it changing the flight path suddenly and going down quickly. The ball touched the camera cable and fell onto an English team’s lap, allowing Bellingham’s goal against Norway. FIFA claims no contact was recorded: “Connected Ball heartbeat sensor has no signal”. Norway’s team has also reported this to the referee. Technically this goal is hence incorrect?

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇳🇴‼️🚨 STABILIZED FOOTAGE: I have stabilized the footage to better see the ball's trajectory. You can clearly see it changing the flight path suddenly and going down quickly. The ball touched the camera cable and fell onto an English team’s lap, allowing Bellingham’s goal against Norway. FIFA claims no contact was recorded: “Connected Ball heartbeat sensor has no signal”. Norway’s team has also reported this to the referee. Technically this goal is hence incorrect?

Lord Bebo

450,661 views • 27 days ago