Skip navigation
The First Amendment protects private venues making their own decisions.
0:00 / 0:40

The First Amendment protects private venues making their own decisions.

Greg Lukianoff

@glukianoff83K followers

Visit on X
187 likesDownloadOriginal post

46,197 views

The First Amendment protects private venues making their own decisions. A culture of free speech asks a different question: Should we celebrate artists being pushed offstage because of their political views? Lastly, people need to understand that attempts to punish political speech almost always result in magnifying it. Would we be talking about Macklemore’s views on Israel right now if it wasn't for this campaign to bar him? Probably not. I joined Jake Tapper 🦅 and Seth Mandel on CNN to discuss.

39 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Mark Hubbard.'s profile picture

    @MarkHubbard33

    The libertarian in me agrees. But we're at war with Islam - no really we are - so people with so much influence over young minds like Macklemore turning the same types of concerts all those innocent Israeli teens were raped, tortured and slaughtered at into Hitler Youth rallies against Jews worldwide - because free Palestine absolutely = kill Jews from river to sea in Isreal, and worldwide via intifada - is not acceptable, in war time. I mean this, look at this ugly antisemitism let loose once again: all the groundwork is being laid for the next Holocaust, esp in UK, Ireland or EU ... I'm very happy that Nazis like @macklemore are cancelled. They are evil inciting violence: that's not a free speech issue anymore. Do you realise despite his big nose Jew stereotype costume pre Oct 7 in his act, that he was criticising Israel's response to the atrocities just 12 days after the atrocities? Just 12 days! We know what that makes him. Pure serpent. The world is a much better place without Macklemores'. His evil is civilisation ending. To hell with all these dumb as plank celebs, they're slime, all of them.

    7 likes

  • @disillusional's profile picture

    @Disillusional5

    Honest question, though: Why does this “backfire” only in one direction? Matisyahu’s concerts were canceled, Michael Rapaport’s shows were canceled, and Jerry Seinfeld has been repeatedly harassed. Did any of that magnify their views or generate comparable outrage?

    5 likes

  • Catmom2018's profile picture

    @CindyLou2019

    He can have whatever political views he wants, however, ticket buyers are not spending their money for a political rally. If that’s what they’re going to get it should be advertised as such and the venue and concert goers can make a decision based on that.

    4 likes

  • Greg Lukianoff's profile picture

    @glukianoff

    Well sure. They can decide not to go. They can decide to go late and skip the opening act. They can decide to boo when he talks about his opinions instead of sings. But it doesn’t address any of the three points I made

    7 likes

  • Catmom2018's profile picture

    @CindyLou2019

    Do I need to address them? You made your points and I made others.

    1 like

  • Mitchell Wexler's profile picture

    @MitchWex

    You are being disingenuous here. He was the opening act, not the reason the tickets are being purchased. So it’s not quite the question you pose. I do strongly agree that if they didn’t push this we wouldn’t have heard much more, and Macklemore benefits from this outcome.

    4 likes

  • Greg Lukianoff's profile picture

    @glukianoff

    I am a lot of things, but I’m never disingenuous

    4 likes

  • Marquis de Custine's profile picture

    @MarquisCustine

    @MitchWex

    3 likes

  • Mitchell Wexler's profile picture

    @MitchWex

    @glukianoff This is really just another reminder of the power of negative attention. As if Trump wasn’t enough to make that clear by now

  • Chance the Gardner's profile picture

    @C_Gardner55

    @TheFIREorg Pushed off stage for his political views or his insistence on sharing them? Are you contending his contract did not preclude his sharing his political blather?

    3 likes

  • Kathryn Paisner's profile picture

    @KathrynPaisner

    Would you say the same thing if Macklemore was celebrating the white-hooded KKK, on stage, instead of their keffiyeh-swaddled brethren?

    3 likes

  • Juan Piece's profile picture

    @ChuolinerPiece

    Huge mistake by Kraft. It would be nice if the Palestine supporters acknowledged that their whole movement is based on bands and boycotts. But they probably won’t care.

    2 likes

  • anajay's profile picture

    @anajay

    My husband took our daughter to an Ed Sheeran show when she was 14 and would have been horrified to encounter a political rally with violent imagery. This would have been less objectionable had Macklemore been headlining, but the supporting act pulling a stunt like this deserves to be fired! I can’t believe the discourse around this. Ed Sheeran is not particularly political and his audience is disproportionately quite young.

    2 likes

  • Searching for sanity's profile picture

    @CfCaridi

    Audience paying for a concert must hear his political views instead? Not a very well reasoned argument.

    2 likes

  • SG's profile picture

    @suegreene633

    I'm not even sure this isn't a security issue. Who wants to be in a stadium packed in w/ thousands of people in altered states as a performer turns the concert into a potentially incendiary political rally spewing accusations of intentional genocide by one group on another? All it takes is just one hot head to start a melee. These performers have tons of different platforms with which to voice their opinions. Must every potential setting be available to them no matter what? I'd not want to be at a concert where this is going on. Makelmore is known for this so if you follow him, you probably know that when you go to his concerts. But what about people who really don't know a performer or opening act is going to turn the concert into a political rally? I think the consumer should be made fully aware of so that they can make an informed decision. What a nightmare for venue owners. Why would they want to be burdened with this added security risk?

    2 likes

  • GuyInSF's profile picture

    @GuyInSF2

    I appreciate your response and the history, I wish you had found the time to include the cancellations of Jewish artists and speakers from shows and academic visits

    2 likes

  • Yanky Stern's profile picture

    @YankyStern41035

    That's preposterous framing. It was not for his views. It was because he subjected his audience to them, an audience that bought tickets to watch a concert.

    1 like

  • Francis's profile picture

    @ManningJul45727

    Yes, the old Streisand effect.

    1 like

  • George Hamilton's profile picture

    @droguul

    Greg this is a bad take. He was an opening act. He was an employee who was making personal rants, on stage. The true comp would be if it was Sheeran doing it and people tried to get the arenas to ban him. You are usually better than this.

    1 like

  • David's Den's profile picture

    @Thacyline

    An even rudimentary knowledge of history lets you know where open antisemitism goes. Human behavior does not answer to your idealistic philosophy. Stop being a child.

    1 like