This is why it's impossible to tax Billionaires
@HinataMotivates17K followers
947,110 views
34 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@demunjones
Only a financial imbecile or a leftist looney tune would have trouble understanding. Elon Musk has paid more federal income tax than any human in the history of the United States.
57 likes

@JoelKatz
And yet after all these decades, no major politician has ever seriously proposed treating unrealized gains as realized for AMT purposes if they're used as collateral because they're more interested in having class warfare talking points than in closing actual tax loopholes.
35 likes

@USEagleEye
Just like I can use anything I have of value as collateral if the people lending me the money see value in it. Not complicated and not unique to billionaires.
24 likes

@jay_villis
This is how lying manipulators herd their sheep audience. Every single person who has an item of value can do this even on a small scale. You do it when you go to a pawn shop, give an item of value, get money, repay money, get to keep item... Elon just does the same thing with larger quantities. What Trevor is advocating for is no different than taxing you yearly for the value of your Lego collection. Besides that, it's not just greed is just pure maliciousness because they for one do sell their stock because it's how they get money to spend and when they do they pay taxes on it like everyone else. You're gonna get your rich people tax money ya greedy bastard.
12 likes

@ansgarjohn
No one in history has paid more tax than @elonmusk over $10b at least.
11 likes

@KewPak
What does a comedian host know about capitalism? Apparently nothing.
10 likes

@EERandomness
You can take out a loan (with shares as collateral) to buy something that MAKES MONEY, because you can pay back the loan from the money made. You can't take out a loan to pay taxes because taxes don't make money
3 likes

@demunjones
@grok What individual person has laid the most Federal Income tax in the history of the United States?
2 likes

@vilaERyn
Haha tell me everything you don’t understand without telling me what you don’t understand
2 likes

@jwbritus
Come on Trevor, you mean you don't understand how the Capitalist system works? I hope you have a good accountant.
2 likes

@realRamonRaj
Can u imagine how a regular person would think about finance basics when even Trevor Noah cant understand it? If Elon doesnt pay that money back, those financial institutions will confiscate the Tesla shares he put up as collateral
2 likes

@XaviHok
You get taxed when you earn your salary, then again when you invest what's left in stocks and sell them for a profit. Now you want to tax people simply for holding those stocks? How many times do you want to tax the same dollar?
1 like

@DanielW04617182
So he's advocating to tax 401k and individuals with shares? Because that's what this means.
1 like

@1van_nelson
It’s funny because he also does the same thing lol
1 like

@JMulMCMLXXVIII
Based on that reasoning in reverse, if you go to a baker and give him money for a cake, he can just give you the ingredients and the deal is done. But you wouldn't. You'll only pay for the final product. If a bank wishes to take a risk, that's their business.
1 like

@Danrbem
Well, this clip made me dumber. amazing to see how he struggles with basic concepts.
1 like

@schar16762
Anyone that owns shit can use this same strategy this guy is a retard
1 like

@zardoz151
At some point I had enough equity in rental houses, I started buying with zero cash down. My commercial banker would combine a loan with a couple of high equity loans i had with them. I would show up at the closing, my banker would be there with a new loan document. Like magic.
1 like

@TheDanHenrikson
Somehow they've figured out how to increase my property taxes on an assessed value of a house that I haven't sold and won't know the value of until I do. They just want you to believe it doesn't make any sense.
1 like

@823jjd
If its an unrealized gain then they are not actually billionaires, you are being lied to so you don't complain about the poverty politicians have inflicted upon you.
1 like













