正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

Tried recreating Fall Guys using the exact same prompt with Claude Opus 5.0 (Claude Code) and Kimi K3 (Kimi CLI). Kimi K3 nailed the gameplay out of the box. Physics, movement, and the overall feel were surprisingly solid Opus 5.0 had a shinier UI, but movement was broken, it...

319,005 次观看 • 3 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

49 条评论

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

prompt - "Build a complete browser-based 3D game inspired by Fall Guys-style obstacle courses, but with original characters, names, art, and level design. Call it "Wobble Rush 3D". Use Three.js with plain HTML, CSS, and JavaScript unless the existing project already has a framework. Core game: - Single-player 3D obstacle course. - The player controls a simple rounded character running toward the finish line. - Controls: - WASD or arrow keys to move. - Space to jump. - Shift to dive/boost forward briefly. - Third-person follow camera. - The goal is to reach the finish as fast as possible. - Include timer, checkpoint, restart, and finish screen. Level design: Create one polished short course with: - Starting platform. - Rotating sweeper bars the player must jump over. - Moving platforms. - Bouncing bumpers. - A narrow bridge section. - A final ramp or gate into the finish zone. - Falling off the course respawns the player at the latest checkpoint. Visual style: - Bright, colorful, toy-like 3D. - Glossy platforms, chunky shapes, satisfying motion. - Use original colors and shapes. Do not copy Fall Guys assets or characters. - Add particles or small effects for landing, checkpoint, dive, respawn, and finish. - Add simple animated background pieces so the scene feels alive. Game feel: - Movement must feel responsive and forgiving. - Jumping should be easy to understand. - Obstacles should be readable and fair. - Falling should be quick to recover from. - The game should feel arcade-like, not like a physics sim. UI: - Start screen with title and Play button. - In-game HUD showing timer and checkpoint count. - Finish screen showing completion time and Restart button. - Compact, polished UI. Code quality: - Organize code into clear modules/classes: - Game - Player - Course - Obstacle - Checkpoint - UI - Effects - No silent fallbacks. If Three.js or an asset fails to load, show a clear error. - Keep the scope focused on one fun playable course. Acceptance criteria: - I can open the project in a browser and play immediately. - The character can move, jump, dive, fall, respawn at checkpoints, and finish the course. - Obstacles move and interact with the player. - The scene is clearly 3D, colorful, animated, and polished. - Restart works from both failure/respawn flow and finish screen."

capGoblin 的头像
capGoblin3 个月前

i heard opus 5 is crazy good at 3d/frontend stuff than kimi k3, so it makes sense

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

nahh tbh kimi still better overall

capGoblin 的头像
capGoblin3 个月前

obv, better overall.

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

repo -

Jurly 的头像
Jurly3 个月前

the Kimi K3 nailed physics out of the box while Opus 5.0 had broken movement — I'd take functional gameplay over shinier

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

same!

jerrygao 的头像
jerrygao3 个月前

It's okay, fable and Opus 5.0 can still distill Kimi K3 in 2 days, because compared to Fable, Kimi K3 ranks # 1 in 6 of 7 front-end domains.😅

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

hahah

𝔊𝔯𝔦𝔪𝔣𝔢𝔩 的头像
𝔊𝔯𝔦𝔪𝔣𝔢𝔩3 个月前

This was Fable 5 so I like how Kimi K3 did on yours

spaceteddyy 的头像
spaceteddyy3 个月前

Holy ragebait, are you serious? Opus just destroyed kimi here what you on about?

Michal Langmajer 的头像
Michal Langmajer3 个月前

They should have distill kimi…

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

🤣🤣🤣

Alexander Yue 的头像
Alexander Yue3 个月前

Want to test on our game gen harness? I can grant you credits

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

Yesss why not!

Alexander Yue 的头像
Alexander Yue3 个月前

Ok awesome, when you make a account DM me what email you want credits in, I'll give $200. Here is the launch post for our game gen, you just type /game-mode in the chat Opus 5 is still being added, is deploying

Kevin 的头像
Kevin3 个月前

@adxtyahq Just webgames or can it also do mobile games?

Alexander Yue 的头像
Alexander Yue3 个月前

@adxtyahq Can do games on mobile (that you open as a website) If you want something cool ask it to make a "PWA" and tell you how to install in on your phone as an app

Ziwen 的头像
Ziwen3 个月前

Opus has better UI

Kenzyy 的头像
Kenzyy3 个月前

men and their obsession with games >>>

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

fffsfs

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

ran another test -

Martin Ronfort 的头像
Martin Ronfort3 个月前

Really curious on this. Opus 4.8 was good enough six months ago. If K3 matches or beats Fable on the same task for a fraction of the cost, that's the real story, not the benchmarks. What was the developer experience like?

Preston 的头像
Preston3 个月前

looks infinitely better

Jayden Davis 的头像
Jayden Davis3 个月前

it looks so good

joey 的头像
joey3 个月前

If you had asked me to guess the results this is pretty much what I would have guessed. Kimi is leading on actual 3D physics and Claude is leading on UI

erdubøgs 的头像
erdubøgs3 个月前

"still itterating" Nice test mate.

Kaivex 的头像
Kaivex3 个月前

Kimi nailing the physics on the first try is a great sign for how it handles game logic specifically.

AI Mastery Guide 的头像
AI Mastery Guide3 个月前

Prettier UI but broken movement, function over polish wins this round 🎮

Brosko 的头像
Brosko3 个月前

the 'kept reiterating instead of converging' thing is so real, some models just spiral on polish instead of locking the core loop what was the prompt structure, single shot or did you scaffold it?

Alejandro Maestre 的头像
Alejandro Maestre3 个月前

Me parece curioso que Kimi K3 haya quedado mejor en gameplay pero Opus 5 tenga mejor UI. Es como si Claude priorizara lo visual y Kimi lo funcional. La pregunta es si prefieres algo que se vea bien o algo que realmente funcione desde el primer intento.

Profexor 的头像
Profexor3 个月前

Built this entire browser game from just ONE comprehensive prompt using Kimi K3. Mixed public assets with some I had lying around, and it just worked. Going from a single prompt to a playable game is wild. Polishing it up now and dropping it on GitHub soon so you can all play it. The workflow with K3 is unmatched.

ashen 的头像
ashen3 个月前

interesting asf

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

🫡

Luís Rodrigues 的头像
Luís Rodrigues3 个月前

Convergence speed is becoming just as important as raw capability.

Mark Han 的头像
Mark Han3 个月前

Will you continue using K3 then?

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

i have been using k3 for frontend stuff , gpt 5.6/fable for backend or some architecture thing if needed

Mark Han 的头像
Mark Han3 个月前

This combination is very cost-effective.

Pukerainbow 🤮🌈 的头像
Pukerainbow 🤮🌈3 个月前

Kimi never fails to impress me man, it cooked harder here

void. 的头像
void.3 个月前

kimi K3 is an extremely efficient model compared to the other frontier models. chinese llms are the new frontier.

XALY 的头像
XALY3 个月前

solana:BqEzwMxi9va7kT7pm6qe9ezKDhRmC2GaaSbz77wSpump BqEzwMxi9va7kT7pm6qe9ezKDhRmC2GaaSbz77wSpump

Zálesák 🇪🇺 的头像
Zálesák 🇪🇺3 个月前

The Opus output looks way fucking better. Maybe it messed up the physics but that's one prompt to fix it. Making the Kimi K3 look like Opus is probably several prompts.

Aden 的头像
Aden3 个月前

opus making it prettier while kimi actually nailed the movement is a funny result, genuinely surprised. what broke on the opus build, the collisions?

Raik R 的头像
Raik R3 个月前

Opus 5 looks so laggy. Is that the improvement?

J A Z I I 的头像
J A Z I I3 个月前

w kimi tbh

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

1000%

MetaPhysician 的头像
MetaPhysician3 个月前

Show your work. What harness? What effort level? If you're not transparent about this stuff. Your claims amount to "trust me bro."

Giyuzk 的头像
Giyuzk3 个月前

Can you make it OS? Would be great to study it out!

aditya 的头像
aditya3 个月前

the kimi one is already OS tho, lemme do for opus too

相关视频