What would Mickey Mantle do?
@DanAlanRourke38K followers
20,501 views
29 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@drodegennaro
im a fan of yours but brother this is one of the most crack pot takes i have ever heard. dude is 35 years old, if he goes out and rips his achillies to shreds you are never going to see him again. or at least as we know him. come down to earth my g, respectfully.
6 likes

@DanAlanRourke
Appreciate you. If he’s on the verge of tearing his Achilles then he shouldn’t play. But his plan is to play

@drodegennaro
have they said that? outside of judge, cause he always says that. if the yankees said that, ill fall back. regardless, it all just makes me so sick to my stomach. hes gotta get his ring man
1 like

@MarcusS484828
Playing through calf strains can lead to Achilles tears. That's what happened to Kevin Durant and Tyrese Halliburton.
5 likes

@DanAlanRourke
For sure but we don’t know the severity. Judge said he’s played through calf strains many times before
3 likes

@MarcusS484828
I understand that, but Judge is 34 years old now and the title window is closing more year by year. I just don't know if it's worth it, but that's just me.

@bbqbaseball62
Mickey Mantle played his entire career on at least 1 and probably 2 torn ACL's......with hangovers.
2 likes

@dooberwoober01
Mantle would’ve won 4 rings by now so the comp isn’t really doing it for me
1 like

@DylanHickey99
Id guess tear his Achillies and never be the same player again
1 like

@DanAlanRourke
Depending on the severity which we dont know sure but Judge has played through calf strains before
1 like

@DylanHickey99
If its truly a solus strain, they have no choice but to shut him down. It sucks and I want him to play but it isnt worth him tearing his Achilles.

@LTotelli
I’ll always respect your opinion but this is an awful take. He’d be nowhere near his typical level and his Achilles could be impacted and a rupture would kill his (and the team’s) 2027 season. And lineup wise it would get wonky if he has to DH. Not worth it (at least for the WC).
1 like

@DanAlanRourke
Appreciate you brother. He’s played through calf strains before and in the end he says he plans on returning so. Don’t know how severe it is so we can only speculate
1 like

@ABSports99
The dude couldn’t hit a fastball before he got hurt. I would much rather have a fully healthy Heliot Ramos at this point.
1 like

@DanAlanRourke
Judge’s presence alone makes us a lot better
1 like

@ADIANKAIBA22
This is y I hate this fan base yall have no brain cells and they are saving judge for 2027-2031 seasons you know the 5 years he has left on his contract maybe do a little bit of research and critical thinking before post a 30 second video looking like a moron on Derek Jeters internet

@FolliesBlue
I agree, likely he plays if he can limp without ripping himself to shreds. But Rebuttal: * He wasn't the same Judge all year - pre/post injury * He came back, looked bad, over 50% strikeout rate * If he is slow on bases that is liability * Our awful trade deadline and unwillingness to play Rice at catcher even a few times a month (all while Wells stunk) means we have zero flexibility at DH. Someone good sits if he plays, and he looks bad, will not have time to get right, and will be slow.

@DanCanobbio
Get the clap

@TylerYogi99
Play compromised and blow out an Achilles and throw the whole next season out the window before it starts?

@literallysup
20 something year old doing Long Island boomer takes like a 65 year old WFAN caller. Kind of take your racist uncle would drop








