Skip navigation
Why The Islamic Dilemma Just DOESN’T Work…
0:00 / 1:03

Why The Islamic Dilemma Just DOESN’T Work…

The Muslim Apologetic

@TaymiApologia3.4K followers

Visit on X
326 likesDownloadOriginal post

10,735 views

Why The Islamic Dilemma Just DOESN’T Work…

41 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Enes 🇹🇷's profile picture

    @enesovat22

    If the Quran generally confirms Matthew mark Luke John then can we say it’s confirming the general themes and ideas in those 4 gospels ? Like the death, resurrection and salvation in Jesus ?

    45 likes

  • GESUETERNO's profile picture

    @GESUETERNO26396

    You must get dizzy with all that circular reasoning you do! You got destroyed as you always do! Thank you for being such an asset to Christianity!

    16 likes

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    We just tried this on YouTube, let’s try it here! Tell me how I got destroyed and I’ll remove the vid! You have one chance, GO!

    17 likes

  • ray's profile picture

    @COYB93

    @GESUETERNO26396 You said it’s impossible for a Christian and Jewish scholar to not see muhamad in the Bible, then backtracked 🐁

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    @GESUETERNO26396 “You said it’s impossible” Show where i said this. I’ll wait

    1 like

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    @GESUETERNO26396 Saying u can’t miss it now means it’s impossible for someone to miss it? U good?

  • GESUETERNO's profile picture

    @GESUETERNO26396

    @COYB93 Oh no dawah boy, your getting cooked at every turn! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 your an absolute embaressment to your ummah! Or is Marian Webster dictionary corrupted now!! Keep taking the L little boy!

  • scoots134's profile picture

    @scoots134

    If they were conscious edits, I feel like it would sound like "You have heard it was said that Moses hand was leperous, but I tell you it was not [insert the correction and purpose of the change afterwards]." The Quran does none of that though and comes across as misunderstanding the tales Muhammad heard from the surrounding religious groups he engaged with. He was known as the "Ear" afterall.

    7 likes

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    There is no distinction in how it’s presented by you vs the Quran. Here is why, the Quran is familiar w a tradition that says OTHERWISE to what it’s saying. Weather it verbalises edits or no is irrelevant. An edit is understood in virtue of it being a POLEMIC. Hope it helps

    8 likes

  • scoots134's profile picture

    @scoots134

    That isn't an argument. An edit cannot just be a different detail and must be a deliberate and acknowledged change otherwise it's just a misunderstanding or an outright error. Therefore, point out one ayah in which the author of the Quran frames it as a correction rather than a misunderstanding or goes in depth about a tradition in the Old/New Testament making a clear correction. Back up your claim rather than saying I'm wrong with no evidence to back it up.

  • scoots134's profile picture

    @scoots134

    Also, if the author truly knew about the previous scriptures, why are so many large portions of the Israel's history not referenced such as the Judges, Priesthood, Kings, and Kingdom splits not referenced or corrected? Considering how in depth many of those portions are in the Biblical text, there are no corrections made regarding them leading one to assume the author of the Quran is not nearly as knowledgeable about the Biblical texts as you claim

  • Ali-O𝙣𝙚M𝙚𝙨𝙨𝙖𝙜𝙚☝︎'s profile picture

    @Kryptotajeer

    If the Qur’an as Muhaymin (guardian and overseer) over the previous scriptures as it explicitly states in 5:48 and throughout its texts, it is fully aware of those scriptures and deliberately corrects or edits them where needed. This alone renders the Islamic Dilemma a dead argument. It’s honestly one of the weakest arguments Christians advance, even though they treat it as their strongest.

    6 likes

  • ithinkitmyway's profile picture

    @ithinkitmyway

    This is how they tried to deceptively mistranslate arabic to suit their narrative. @GodLogic_GL caught her red-handed.

    2 likes

  • John Voight, DDS's profile picture

    @LordDiososceles

    Does the Quran ever say it’s editing the previous scriptures? If not a clear reading of the text indicates that the Quran’s authors just flat out got things wrong.

    1 like

  • voice's profile picture

    @voicefighterr

    Stop giving them clout.. this is clearly not working or helping them see the truth.

    1 like

  • The Muslim Apologetic's profile picture

    @TaymiApologia

    Who said it’s about them?

  • Losty93's profile picture

    @DenisApraku93

    You guys literally prefer waraqa words than what the actual scriptures says Yh right Yes no ,no no, no yes religion 😏 😂😂😂

    1 like

  • Légionnaire's profile picture

    @Legionnaire432

    Poor plagiarisms doesn't help you out. 😁

  • Plumb bob's profile picture

    @Plumbbob1716016

    It still works because now you don’t want to use your own scholars now you wanna try to avoid the scholars that you used to turn to the scholars

  • Faiyaz Ahmed's profile picture

    @FaiyazAhme10165

    Can Christian defend the Bible very interesting debate