Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
Alex O’Connor explains the contingency argument for God
44,769 views • 3 months ago •via X (Twitter)
39 Comments

whether by an uncaused cause or an infinite series of causes, causal power must exist without being grounded in a prior/external cause.

Literally 10 seconds in he starts by saying that it's naive to think this in the first place.

So boring these boredom arguments

It’s a technical argument… it’s not rock and roll I grant you.

@darwintojesus that's a decent explanation, but not as compelling as using necessary/contingent, per se/per accidens terminology. Seems that he's been reading some Ed Feser. I don't follow @CosmicSkeptic, but what is his current stance of the existence of God?

He calls himself an agnostic, which is what basically all new atheists actually are but they don’t understand correct terminology and he does. He also says he wants to believe and likes the idea of God but just can’t so far… he has a huge issue with the problem of suffering and being it up often.

@TJadlow @CosmicSkeptic The idea that God who has given us free will should always intervene when men do evil and cause suffering is wrong. In this day of AI which is created my man, if we decide to give it free will tomorrow …

@TJadlow @CosmicSkeptic … and it uses that free will to create chaos in the binary world of computers we as human wouldn’t be held responsible for the free actions of AI. For every effect there is a Cause so for every suffering there is a system or person behind it and it sure isn’t God.

@darwintojesus @CosmicSkeptic That doesn't alleviate the problem. God could have made a world where there is no evil at all. I can reconcile it, but it will take a conversation.

An uncaused cause must exist for all other causes to stem from. God must exist.

the guy says there can’t be an infinite number of “causes” in the hierarchical causation, then, when he finds the fundamental reason he’s looking for (gravity, which is the most fundamental reason holding the chain of events he’s analysing) then he says, “but what’s holding gravity?” … and this is the problem with words, it’s too easy to get lost and confused in the argument. physics is in the continuous pursue of the fundamental cause, which is why so many physicists believe in the grand unification theory, because it would be nicer to have a single cause that encapsulates all other (so far) fundamental causes. however, the assumption that the number of fundamental causes cannot be infinite (or even finite >1) is an assumption, and not an undeniable truth. it’s just an axiom he decided to insert in the argument.

@thinkforchrist did a longer (and much better) explanation of this. Recommend checking it out (and their very underappreciated channel)

He's what a stupid person would think an intelligent person is. If he didn't have the accent he does, and didn't speak with such confidence more people would see through him.

If you can’t explain something simply you don’t understand it. If there were an argument here he could explain it without 45 minutes of pseudo intellectualism.

And THAT the uncaused cause is explained by the impossibility of the contrary, it indeed has an explanation. Or proof by contradiction is not strictly deductive.

Still doesn’t answer why an uncaused cause exists? Once we are here to observe, the contingency argument kicks in, but it is still specious obfuscation bc it doesn’t define god as Jesus or Yahweh or anything else; and Gödel’s 2nd Incompleteness Theorem ( a mathematical proof) says all formal systems are necessarily incomplete, so it is inverse Highlander rules: The CANNOT be only one

It's not argument for God. It's argument that reality requires grounding to not collapse. That could be some force like he said, or many forces combined supporting each other like self-supporting bridge.

loved this one .. seems a derivation from the TAG argument? As God is the grounding for the universals holding everything in place coherently.

even he admits that it's a bad argument. 1. If the universe needs a Cause to exist, why doesn't God? 2. If God can exist without cause, why can't the universe? 3. Aren't you applying the rules of the universe to a time before the universe, a time where its rules may not apply?

I watched the full video on YouTube. Alex's arguments are seriously flawed. Let me show you how dumb it is: 1/x

He is the radiance of the glory of God and the exact imprint of his nature, and he upholds the universe by the word of his power. After making purification for sins, he sat down at the right hand of the Majesty on high, — Hebrews 1:3

I do not charge for this service, and I am better looking. I woulf have done it better. 😎

He could have explained that in 2 minutes. Fascinating though

Is there some reason why you didn’t link to the entire video? I mean, it seems like you actually went to some significant effort to truncate it by posting an edited version of the original video. How does this reflect a kind of argument in good faith? How can you reconsider this with your supposed quest for truth?

One of my favorites. I taught this one to our high schoolers at our church.

Yeah, this is a really good argument if you’ve never had a remotely spiritual experience in your life. If that’s the case then yes this is very compelling. But I have so I don’t personally find it compelling

This guy is an atheist, no?

And he’s not convinced by it.

He's a blessing. Let's pray that God will grant him repentance leading to the knowledge of the truth (2 Timothy 2:25) 🙏

When Christians need atheists to explain their arguments for them. And when you ignore all of Alex's arguments against them.

There is not one most powerful argument for the existence of God.

Contingency is fake

god mentioned zero times

His dominoes analogy is wrong. Each domino was at one point in the present, relying on what he calls vertical causation. So no, you couldn't just take one domino out afterwards, or at least it makes no sense. How we represent causation afterwards using a logical time frame, is evidently very useful, but it is not ontological.

Tiring
Not that great. There is no need for a first cause. Causes could go on forever (eternal). If they cannot, and there must be a first cause, God need not be it ( no God, or a caused God). The two types of causes is a red herring.

I believe a strongest adjunct to his argument, and kind of where he stops, is that the fundamental ‘cause’ tends towards organization (and profoundly at that ) rather than what would seem much more likely: entropy and chaos. You can toss a box of legos onto the floor a trillion times; it’s never going to sort itself out by color. Order, harmony, sequence etc are profound circumstances in and of themselves.

Woah

Not if time is a circle.


