Skip navigation
Elon says the most common mistake smart engineers make is optimizing something that should not…
0:00 / 0:40

Elon says the most common mistake smart engineers make is optimizing something that should not…

Tesla Owners Silicon Valley

@teslaownersSV1.4M followers

Visit on X
475 likesDownloadOriginal post

21,963 views

Elon says the most common mistake smart engineers make is optimizing something that should not exist. "First, make your requirements less dumb. Your requirements are definitely dumb. It does not matter who gave them to you. It's particularly dangerous if a smart person gave you the requirements because you might not question them enough." "Then try very hard to delete the part or process. This is actually very important. If you're not occasionally adding things back in, you're not deleting enough." "And then only the third step is simplify or optimize... Possibly the most common error of a smart engineer is to optimize the thing that should not exist." He said this at Starbase in 2021, standing next to Starship hardware. Flight 15 is targeting Friday.

14 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • goonrich's profile picture

    @gooniebags

    Most people try to make complicated systems more efficient. The real genius is questioning why the complexity exists in the first place. Delete first, optimize later.

    3 likes

  • Ledge Andary's profile picture

    @Ledge_Andary

    Deleting is the hard step. Nobody gets credit for removing a part, so it gets polished instead.

    1 like

  • lI_X_MACHINA_Il's profile picture

    @lI_MACHINE_Il

    Lean Mechanics 💯 😎👍 It works.

    1 like

  • Branko Gjurekovec's profile picture

    @gjurekovec

    Step 2 is the painful one on a plant layout. Every spare pump and extra tank traces back to a requirement someone wrote years ago.

    1 like

  • Kk ·星空's profile picture

    @Wenkk_wu

    the add-back test is the part everyone skips — never re-adding anything means you are not deleting hard enough. Raptor 3 is that quote in hardware: fewer parts, no heat shield, more thrust.

    1 like

  • X Pulse's profile picture

    @wantlvm

    Deleting the step is the hard part

    1 like

  • Star🦝Soup's profile picture

    @starsoup

    Apparently Elon Musk is the reincarnation ofEarl Muntz. Earl "Madman" Muntz was an electrical engineer and businessman who revolutionized affordable television sets in the late 1940s, by ripping out components of overly complex TVs until they stopped working.

  • David Blair's profile picture

    @davidblair6

    Agree 100%

  • Full Self Typing 😂 🇺🇸's profile picture

    @FullSelfTyping

    Step 1: make your requirements less dumb. Step 2: realize half of them were written by you 😂

  • Cyber15Fit's profile picture

    @Hyfly11

    Ha!! I need this on my garage wall. Half my to-do list probably shouldn't exist 😂

  • Brendan Melanson's profile picture

    @ceobrendan

    This is the most useful business advice that nobody follows. Half the work in any company is optimizing something nobody should be doing. Delete first, then improve.

  • BigFamiliesBrightFuture's profile picture

    @BigFamiliesBF

    Now apply that to permitting. Half the rules that keep us from building a reactor shouldn’t exist… delete those first, then optimize.

  • .DKL's profile picture

    @DrKloser7777

    .. or making something optimal not exist.

  • TSB's profile picture

    @TeslaSeoulBit

    없어야 할 걸 최적화한다... 뼈때리네요