Skip navigation
The next frontier in protein design will not be defined by structure alone, but by the capacity to…
0:00 / 0:52

The next frontier in protein design will not be defined by structure alone, but by the capacity to…

Markus J. Buehler

@ProfBuehlerMIT28K followers

Visit on X
801 likesDownloadOriginal post

89,984 views

The next frontier in protein design will not be defined by structure alone, but by the capacity to engineer motion as a first-class principle of function. This is because dynamics is where the real biology lives. Foundational work by Karplus, Levitt & Warshel made clear that chemistry cannot be understood without motion, mechanism, and scale. Gō, Brooks & others showed that proteins possess characteristic collective motions - low-frequency normal modes that capture how whole molecules bend, breathe, and fluctuate. Frauenfelder then sharpened the picture further: proteins are not static objects occupying a single minimum, but dynamic ensembles traversing rugged energy landscapes. And yet the modern AI revolution in protein science has been, above all, a revolution in structure. In our new paper in Matter, Bo Ni and I ask a different question: not what structure will this sequence adopt? but what sequence will realize a prescribed pattern of motion? VibeGen inverts the conventional design paradigm. Rather than treating dynamics as a consequence to be analyzed after the fact, it makes dynamics the design objective from the outset. Using a language diffusion model with two cooperating agents - a designer that proposes sequences and a predictor that critiques them against the target motion profile - the system converges on de novo proteins with tailored vibrational behavior. One of the most intriguing results is a form of functional degeneracy - distinct sequences and distinct folds can satisfy the same target dynamical specification. For a given functional pattern of motion, evolution may have sampled only a small region of the physically realizable design space. The space of viable molecular mechanics may be far larger than the repertoire biology happened to discover. We have made "vibe" into a cultural metaphor - something intuitive, affective, subjective. But at the molecular scale, vibe is not metaphor: It is physics. For a protein, the vibe is the pattern of motion itself; the fluctuations, resonances, and collective displacements that determine what the molecule can do.

32 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Code: Model weights: Paper:

    39 likes

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    MIT News Article:

    23 likes

  • LIFE AI's profile picture

    @LifeNetwork_AI

    A shift from structure to dynamics reframes protein design from predicting static folds to engineering motion as function itself. If proteins are dynamic ensembles on rugged energy landscapes, it raises a deeper question: how much of the possible dynamical design space has biology actually explored?

    13 likes

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Biology has only explored a tiny fraction of what is possible, so lots of opportunities for engineers!

    2 likes

  • S.A. Senchal's profile picture

    @samsenchal

    Almost like the state space has been reduced by evolution to the most efficient per unit cost to the organism - because ai gives us essentially free compute what's efficient broadens and we get novelty

    6 likes

  • Hang Zheng's profile picture

    @HangZheng855161

    Huge implications for drug discovery: allosteric binding and induced-fit are inherently dynamic, yet structure-based tools treat receptors as rigid. Does the functional degeneracy result suggest 'undruggable' allosteric sites could be accessed by targeting specific motional modes?

    6 likes

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Exactly the right question! We found that functionally similar proteins can have very different folds but share vibrational signatures. That 'functional degeneracy' suggests motional modes are the deeper design variable. If we can target the dynamics, we may be able to reach sites that look inaccessible in a crystal structure.

    4 likes

  • Christopher Antoniou's profile picture

    @ChristosA89

    My view this is the entire point of a ‘metabolism first’ view of abiogenesis. Thermodynamics required both protein topology and their dynamics/motion integrated as one, cofactors within said reactions requiring no code. Such that chemomechanical transduction was powered by enthalpic contribution, configurational entropy, equilibrium constant K, autocatalysis dX/dt=kAX^2; and as such integrated reactions WERE those which manipulated protein conformation. There was no biochemical division of labour, the later canalisation ATP hydrolysis acting the raw energy needs powering nucleotide base manipulation. In this way, early selection was a brutal regime, and far more sensitive/immediate than later gene redundancies. It would be an entirely alien concept to propose in early life the view proteins and their adaptation were differentiated by topology versus dynamical function, these were always a singularity before RNA.

    5 likes

  • Roberto Campus's profile picture

    @MusicOfOldGods

    Brilliant work... and the functional degeneracy finding is the most interesting part. Nature sampled a tiny corner of what's physically possible. VibeGen starts mapping the rest. But here's the question I keep going back to: VibeGen learns vibrational modes conditioned on existing PDB structures. If I am not wrong, the training distribution still anchors it to what evolution happened to discover. What about the regions of design space that have no natural analogue to learn from? That's where a physics-first approach becomes interesting. If you can derive vibrational modes directly from geometry... no training data, no ML, deterministic... you're not bounded by the evolutionary sample at all. Novel chemistry works on day one because the engine runs on the physics underneath, not on patterns learned from what already exists. The two approaches could be genuinely complementary... VibeGen to generate candidate sequences, a physics kernel to evaluate their physical properties instantly at scale. If there are lingering questions from the paper that a deterministic physics engine might help answer... I'd be happy to let you run some experiments on and see what comes back. No pitch! Just curious what happens when the two approaches talk to each other.

    3 likes

  • Jedi's profile picture

    @JediScale

    @burny_tech

    3 likes

  • T.Theodorus Ibrahim's profile picture

    @theodorus5

    @niroshajmurugan maybe some useful context here re: Cosic resonance?

    2 likes

  • LAMM@MIT's profile picture

    @LAMM_MIT

    Congrats to our postdoc @_Bo_Ni!

    2 likes

  • Akash Arunabharathi's profile picture

    @thereal_akashab

    This looks super cool – where does the predictor get the ground truth target motion profile from? I was under the impression that we didn’t have dynamics data for a lot of proteins already. Is it mostly from MD sims?

    2 likes

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Physics comes, as you say, from molecular dynamics. Of course we can also fine-tune the model with experimental data on top of that, so there is flexibility.

    3 likes

  • Akash Arunabharathi's profile picture

    @thereal_akashab

    Makes sense, and yeah, training on MD and fine tuning on experimental data is sound given wet lab costs. Super cool that you’re also doing language diffusion, I’ve been working on getting flow matching to work with protein sequences myself! Will read the paper

    3 likes

  • Zythum's profile picture

    @blixem22

    Very insightful, thanks!

    2 likes

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Thank you!

    1 like

  • Thinktica's profile picture

    @ThinkticaAI

    Amazing job congrats!

    1 like

  • Markus J. Buehler's profile picture

    @ProfBuehlerMIT

    Thank you @ThinkticaAI !

  • Sandeep DIXIT's profile picture

    @sandeepdixit22

    Interesting.

    1 like