Skip navigation
This is called a specular reflection. Undistorted specular reflections are only possible with a flat…
0:00 / 0:20

This is called a specular reflection. Undistorted specular reflections are only possible with a flat…

Witsit

@WitsitGetsIt24K followers

Visit on X
509 likesDownloadOriginal post

19,519 views

This is called a specular reflection. Undistorted specular reflections are only possible with a flat surface.

56 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Ramshutu's profile picture

    @theoofcat5

    What type of distortion in a specular reflection would you expect if the surface was curved by a few hundred microns every 100m? Would you be able to detect it?

    25 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    You realize it is a constant rate of curvature that increases with distance right?

    3 likes

  • Ramshutu's profile picture

    @theoofcat5

    What part of me stating the saggita over 100m suggested to you that I didn’t grasp that a ball curves for significantly more than 100m? Are you unable to answer my question?

    13 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    Probably the part where you said every 100m

    4 likes

  • Ramshutu's profile picture

    @theoofcat5

    Which part? Any two points 100m apart have a the saggita begween them is a few hundred microns. Thats correct. You understand the difference between sequential and cumulative right?

    10 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    Haha yeah that’s the entire point. So you’re saying you just made a nonsense point? Okay cool.

    4 likes

  • Ramshutu's profile picture

    @theoofcat5

    What part of me accurately describing what the curve of the earth is over 100m “a nonsense point” Seems like you’re trying to pretend there is a problem with what I said so you can avoid answering the question that illustrates how vacuous your claim is…

    9 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    The curve of the earth would be effectively parabolic for hundreds of miles. Your point is literally nonsense and irrelevant.

    2 likes

  • Alex Boge's profile picture

    @alexboge

    Man. You guys waste so much time on all these unimportant visuals you don’t quite understand, and yet ignore the unresolvable. The sun can never rise or set on a flat earth with a local sun circling above it. It will never even come close to the horizon. Proof: No matter what altitude or size of sun, it will never rise or set. And yet it does, in reality. Sunsets debunk flat earth - it’s really that simple, everything else is noise.

    17 likes

  • LC's profile picture

    @CalmLogical

    Flat earthers think mirrors only work if they're totally flat. That's cute, but very, VERY stupid. 🤣

    12 likes

  • Jared Morrison 🎭🔬's profile picture

    @Jared_Morrison

    Why? The radius of curvature of that surface is over 100,000x larger than the minimum acceptable radius of curvature for a flat glass mirror. Translation: that surface, according to globe (spherical) geometry is significantly flatter than a flat bathroom mirror.

    11 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    Allowable error in commercial glass is irregular deviation from a plane such as undulations etc. It is not a single, constant-radius sphere. Earth’s surface, on the globe model, is a systematic convexity with one radius. That is an entirely different kind of departure from flat. Those two things are not interchangeable.

    2 likes

  • Jared Morrison 🎭🔬's profile picture

    @Jared_Morrison

    The radius of curvature for the globe is MASSIVE. Any visible distance across a body of water, unless viewed from an extreme altitude, will appear perfectly flat to the human eye. The pic you provided should effectively have zero distortion using globe geometry.

    3 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    Wait so you acknowledge your argument is stupid and not applicable at all? The globe is massive means nothing.. it supposedly has a radius of 3959 miles thus curves at a specific rate. This is just a cool video.. we have undistorted long distance specular reflection observations and you are completely incorrect. The globe model says we should see curvature from the ground constantly all the time. Also, what I stated in the post is just an objective fact.

    3 likes

  • Jared Morrison 🎭🔬's profile picture

    @Jared_Morrison

    The globe model does not say we should “see curvature from the ground constantly.” It says there IS curvature. My point is that the degree of curvature due to the radius of curvature is so minuscule that it is NOT perceptible to the human eye at ground level. It appears flat.

    7 likes

  • Witsit's profile picture

    @WitsitGetsIt

    And your point is objectively wrong. The curve of the earth would be effectively parabolic for hundreds of miles and absolutely would be perceptible at ground level.

    3 likes

  • TheManDarren 🍁's profile picture

    @TheManDarren

    @Jared_Morrison Nope.

    1 like

  • Jared Morrison 🎭🔬's profile picture

    @Jared_Morrison

    @WitsitGetsIt Despite what his username suggests, Witsit doesn’t get it. #witsitdoesntgetit

    4 likes

  • Dave's profile picture

    @Xentrik85

    You need to check manufacturing tolerances - hardened mirror glass has a 3:1000 bow tolerance A 3mi horizon has a 6:15,840 dip, or 3:7,920 to keep things common That’s 8x shallower than a mirror Even at 10mi the dip is only 3:2,400, 2.4x shallower That’s an oops for FE…

    9 likes

  • Evil_Merlin's profile picture

    @Evil_MerlinX

    Fucking Nazi.

    7 likes