Why isn't Unity being used as much as Unreal Engine 5 to develop realistic-looking games?
80.819 Follower
587.285 Aufrufe
38 Kommentare
Kommentare aus dem Originalbeitrag auf X (Twitter)

@RouaniJihad
As a Unity developer myself I can think of a few reasons: 1- Ray Tracing was added late, and the current implemention is comically slow and the denoiser is very poor. 2- There's still no virtualized geometry system. 3- Making an engine for AAA isn't as profitable believe it or not, the only reason Epic was able to develop UE is because Fortnite is a massive cash cow that subsidizes engine development, Unity has no such cash flow. 4- Unity realizes point (3) so their focus instead is on the lower end instead of AAA, that's where they are very successful at (over 50% of all mobile games, 80% of VR games are made with Unity, and around 40-50% for indie games on steam). 5- Nearly 70% of Unity's revenue comes from Vector AI, which is their Ad business, basically the main way Unity makes money is by selling Ads on Unity games, and Ads primarily exist on mobile games hence why they prioritize mobile. 6- And of course it's not all precalculated genius, you can very much credit their failure in AAA to some monumental fumbles, like how they burned over a billion $ to buy Weta Digitals only to do absolutely nothing with their VFX tech and to lay them off and sell some portions of the business years later. This is not to say they don't have AAA games, some of my personal favorites are: V Rising, No Rest for the Wicked.. and that's about it lol The engine is very much capable of delivering AAA quality in many aspects like graphics, but not all aspects, terrain tools and animations for example are severely lacking.
988 Likes

@NikTek
This was very insightful, thank you 🙏
147 Likes

@remi_oukrat
@RouaniJihad I would like to add that the public API is developed in C#, which is not the most efficient language for achieving high performance. In contrast, C++ is widely regarded as the best and most common language for creating video games. And UE5 provides C++ API like homemade engines.
1 Like

@RouaniJihad
That's a myth: 1- The core of Unity is C++, the language exposed to devs is C# yes but game builds can be C++ thanks to IL2CPP. 2- Unity does have DOTS and ECS which are made to enable extremely high number of entities without crippling performance, but it's not enabled by default and requires some work to integrate (I hear they're planning to make it the default backend by Unity 6.8).
2 Likes

@MikeMumbelz
Unity alienated a lot of people with their licensing fee changes a year ago. Even after the backlash and they walked it back the damage was done. A bunch of developers jumped from Unity because they couldn't handle the possibility they could be retroactively charged years after a game was released because of the policy change. Unreal Engine has its issues but it comes with less risk when Unity's biggest issue is how it's managed as a service.
46 Likes

@MaxRovensky
Their HDRP is fantastic but Unity requires you to set up A LOT more boilerplate to achieve this, look at the Heretic breakdown from a while back Unreal comes with a ton of both game-centric and cinematic machinery built-in that Unity requires you to implement from scratch
25 Likes

@Khen_na_
Because the company is complete shit.
25 Likes

@ExtolmentStudio
Surprised at all the people saying Unity is more complex, it’s more like a blank canvas
19 Likes

@VeryCoolMike69
Every unity game runs like it's being held together by paperclips and hope
15 Likes

@timsoret
Almost none of what you see in this demo is available out of the box in vanilla Unity.
15 Likes

@AdamDawidowicz
Because Unreal offers a better rendering pipeline overall. Because up until recently Unity kept several fragmented pipelines. Because Unity's leadership offers considerably worse business proposal with their per seat license than Unreal with their from sales threshold. Because high fidelity talent migrated to Unreal, so Unity is left with less devs to recruit from. Should I go on?
13 Likes

@takeshi_no_uta
One, we haven't seen a game use this version of Unity yet. Two, they lost a LOT of goodwill after they announced changes to pricing (see this part of the Unity Wikipedia article: There's a very clear line between Godot getting big enough for Nvidia to make an RTX fork of the engine, and this controversy.
8 Likes

@hmgamesnsoftwa1
For indie devs, Unreal Engine 5 is easier to use and provides a lot of free or cheap assets. You know, Epic gives paid assets for free every month, and trust me, some are really good and you can use them in your project. Even if you don't have much experience, you can still create a game.
8 Likes

@LeafbornGame
Because Unity focuses on scalability, while Unreal focuses on photorealism. Unity’s primary goal isn’t photorealism, but scalability; high-quality graphics are simply a part of that scalability.
8 Likes

@roders77
Unity was pretty amazing for a while. But upper management turned it into a cash shop, yoking every possible penny and improving next to nothing. If I hadn't bought thousands in tools and assets, I'd use something else. Unreal is pushing DLSS so hard though, it's fake quality.
6 Likes

@lenis0012
Because HDRP sucks. Unity works great for stylized games with the Universal Render Pipeline. But HDRP is a disaster. Just look at Cities Skylines II.
5 Likes

@Sacb0y
Short answer is unity isnt as good for massive worlds atm. But the moe to coreclr will help i think as thats blocking some stuff it seems.
4 Likes

@amrhsn
Call of Duty Mobile is made with Unity. This is a certificate stating that Unity can build any level at any scale.
3 Likes

@atamanoyare
Because they tried to raise prices unfairly and tried to take a large percentage of sales from games and people lost trust
3 Likes

@KapitanAlien
Look at tarkov and ask again
2 Likes

















