Navigation überspringen
Here is a human assembling a BMW engine by hand.
0:00 / 2:05

Here is a human assembling a BMW engine by hand.

Jack 🤖

@JacklouisP14.114 Follower

Auf X besuchen
1.175 LikesHerunterladenOriginalbeitrag

379.948 Aufrufe

Here is a human assembling a BMW engine by hand. Hundreds of components. Micron tolerances. Dozens of hours. So what's better here—a human or a robot❓ 🤖 Robots win at: - Repeatability. Same torque, same angle, every time. - Speed on defined tasks. Honda automates piston installation at 9,000/day. - No fatigue. Shift 47 is identical to shift 1. 👨‍🏭 Humans win at: - Feeling what they can't see. Half of engine assembly is blind. - Force intuition. Knowing "seated" from "about to crack." - Compliant manipulation. That instinctive wiggle to get a part to drop in. - Handling variance. Mercedes pulled robots off the S-Class line because they couldn't adapt to option variability. - Deformables. Wiring harnesses, gaskets, hoses—nothing predictable. - Recovery. When something's wrong, humans adapt. Robots halt. ✅ Right now, the answer is both. Robots handle the repetitive subassemblies. Humans handle everything that requires judgment, feeling, and adaptation. The day a humanoid can do this end-to-end is the day manipulation is solved.

53 Kommentare

Kommentare aus dem Originalbeitrag auf X (Twitter)

  • Profilbild von formby

    @formby1971

    You would endeavour to design so that the product can be assembled by robot. If memory serves FIAT had an engine called a FIRE engine which stood for Fully Integrated Robotised Engine.

    15 Likes

  • Profilbild von Jack 🤖

    @JacklouisP

    Oh that’s cool - not heard of it! DFRM - design for robot manufacturing

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von artforz

    @real_artforz

    Note: That's a M engine, not normal BMW.

    3 Likes

  • Profilbild von Robert Keith

    @rl_keith

    I suppose the number of V12 engines is small, and the customers are willing to pay for them, so it's not worth automating the job. In any case the internal combustion engine is now as relevant as the horse.

    3 Likes

  • Profilbild von Donnie

    @OhhDonnie

    Plastic timing chain guides are a bad idea. And all gaskets (valve covers, valley pan, timing chain covers, oil pan) are poor quality will need replacing far too soon. I dont care how “human” it is built not to last.

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von Jack 🤖

    @JacklouisP

    its true

  • Profilbild von Frank Miscione

    @Znostreet

    good luck changing the timing chains

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von Grandpa Joe

    @JoeHChasko

    I wonder when a robot will be able to fasten a shirt button? It requires manipulation by multiple fingers at once.

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von Jack 🤖

    @JacklouisP

    @ScienceGuy2718 yeah thats acctually tough

  • Profilbild von Grandpa Joe

    @JoeHChasko

    And, of course, change a flat tire, and install an electrical panel. I’ll say 1-2 years, and 3-4 years. You think?

  • Profilbild von Robert Smith

    @BigZoogoinham

    All for it to leak oil in a couple years

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von dwasf

    @dwasf79850

    Involuntary hypnosis. Cannot stop watching repeatedly.

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von Jack 🤖

    @JacklouisP

    It’s a very satisfying video

    1 Like

  • Profilbild von AIBot Hub

    @theaibothub

    Great breakdown @jacklouisP. Engine assembly shows exactly why robots and humans complement each other, and that is precision vs intuition. Until robots master real-world feel, recovery, and variance, the hybrid model will stay the gold standard.

    2 Likes

  • Profilbild von AIBot Hub

    @theaibothub

    Not at all Jack.

  • Profilbild von Prof Barkley

    @BarkleyPro76570

    electric motor clearly the future, so much simpler

    1 Like

  • Profilbild von RGDL

    @RGDL_DUX

    What’s better is an electric motor. And that is where we are headed due to efficiency & economics.

    1 Like

  • Profilbild von Kim Conrad Jorgensen 🇩🇰 🇹🇭

    @KimCJorgensen

    All of this will go away.

    1 Like

  • Profilbild von RECONQUISTA

    @Trump1uknowit

    Robots suck. Tech sucks. Half of tech items work half the time

    1 Like

  • Profilbild von Jack 🤖

    @JacklouisP

    Says the robot using tech