Is the Labour government finished?
@garyseconomics188K followers
24,517 views
33 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@JaquelineOutram
Gary! You want us to accept your track record of accurate economic predictions - but you won’t accept our expertise on political corruption! I spent 17 years in finance and 10 years (so far) in the anti-corruption space and I’m telling you CORRUPTION IS DRIVING INEQUALITY!
7 likes

@bigpicturepol
There is another possibility of course which is that the evidence from around the world is that wealth taxes don’t raise significant sums of money. They have been tried in different ways in different places and they have always raised pretty trivial sums. Even Marxists like Richard Murphy don’t think a wealth tax is the answer. Even if you take the tax justice UK view of a 1% tax raising £24bn (after presumably a long set up period), that still wouldn’t even fill the black hole in *this* autumn budget, let alone be transformational to the life chances of ordinary people. Would it allow for example tax cuts for working people? No. Since we’d still be £6bn short and Labour MPs would still rather spend any windfall on higher welfare than lower tax for workers. Whats missing from your analysis is introspection. You’ve become so convinced of your own righteousness you’re not challenging your own assumptions anymore. Surprising for a trader.
4 likes

@DannyLee1980
If they stopped allowing MPs to accept personal donations and gifts it would change politics, if you took payment from a 3rd party while in many other employments, you would be sacked for breach of fiduciary duty, or bribery.
3 likes

@FalloutVaultBoy
A 36min video to just say yes seems excessive.
2 likes

@SageOfAmenti
Economics is just one piece of the puzzle. This problem is philosophical, psychological and ideological. If you want more success I think you should start calling labour what they are. Far left.
2 likes

@robborley
I love the theatre of Gary’s Kitchen. It’s needs a spin off show of its own
1 like

@VVasazi
Here's Gary, a nobody, who keeps drowing on about taxing the rich, Gary, fuck off
1 like

@SonjaConscious
I love Gary but without deep rebalancing from nationalised utilities & real protections from profiteering in housing the working class is fucked. A wealth tax alone is not enough. China lifted 800M from real poverty in 45yrs with this mixed market socialist combo, it can heal UK
1 like

@meaningsoflife
Rule number 1: do not fuck with your citizens! Tackle the problem head on - stop the boats!
1 like

@FrankTegrity
The bubble theory is accurate but it really boils down to whats happened throughout history. Anytime a movement that empowers the common folk and diverts the cash flow away from them, it gets demonised & discarded. For the first time since existence the commoners are a global 1/2
1 like

@EFundamentalist
Gary, It has nothing to do with you as a person, your class or the way you present your ideas. It's simply because you want to take money from the rich and give it to the poor. The rich run everything. They got rich by taking it from the poor. No way they want to reverse that.
1 like

@Neale_Packham
Gary, i think you're wrong to look to the government for the solution. they have been unable to correct things because they do not have the skills or the will to. We need to Enable people and business to grow without the huge burden of taxation, Reduce The Government.
1 like

@JJones87684337
Yes.
1 like

@AnadrielAnna
Gary. They’re not dumb like rats. They corrupt like stoats! 🧐 ( sorry real stoats 🥹)
1 like

@wimdows
Gary’s Non-Economics. Or maybe Comics?
1 like

@henrybomby
Have you thought about rebranding a wealth tax to an 'inflation tax'? It moves the conversation away from those wishing to kill the aspirations of this countries wealth creators and the politics of envy etc. (Afterall, to tax the rich you need rich people!) Which makes many people's skin crawl. Myself included. And towards a conversation around taxing those who have disproportionately benefited from assets increasing due to inflation. It doesn't blame the rich for being rich, it starts to explore why we have inflation and money printing and the impacts it has on inequality within society. Which therefore looks to tackle the real problem here. Because people self made rich people aren't the problem, they are the solution!

@_joebelcher
Instead of flogging a dead horse with Labour. Use some of your wealth and your platform to help grow the Greens. It's happening. 3 years is a very long time in politics.

@UnclesGameDev
It's a problem of complexity not economics, centuries old democracy trying to manage a civilization rapidly approaching singularity.

@NLeesy
They got until they call an election unfortunately Gazzor

@philharrison2k
@kevin_busby Tha leftism will be tha down fall Economy in freefall Benefits claimants ballooning Riots on the streets The hatred and decide they have caused is unbelievable












